Ethnocentric Curriculum

Ethnocentric curriculum is a sociological concept that describes a system of education reflecting the culture of one ethnic group, usually the dominant culture in a society. This is a prime example of institutional racism: bias built into a system’s routine policies and practices, with no prejudiced individual required.

For example, education within the United Kingdom has traditionally been centered on a dominant White Eurocentric curriculum, and has discounted the contributions of various ethnic minorities.

Those who subscribe to this view argue that ethnic and racial inequality persists in education, especially in history. They claim the UK national curriculum has traditionally ignored Black and Asian history.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

How Are British Schools Ethnocentric?

Critics who call British schools ethnocentric point to these examples:

  • Stephen Ball (1993) argues that the curriculum seeks to reposition “the UK in some mythical golden age of empire” with much harm to multiculturalism and pluralism.

  • Ball (1993) further contends that judgments on aesthetics, such as music, are characterized by a “distrust of experience and relevance” and a “Eurocentric, cultural racism.”

  • Barry Troyna and Jenny Williams (1986) have alleged that the British system is institutionally racist, and they denounce the predominance of European languages, such as Spanish and French, over Asian languages, such as Hindi and Chinese.

  • Martin Myers and Kalwant Bhopal (2009) interviewed Gypsy, Roma and Traveller (GRT) pupils and parents. Pupils did not see their interests in the curriculum, and parents felt their history was underrepresented.

  • Grievances have also been raised that school uniform codes may contradict the cultural norms of certain minorities, and that the timing of vacations coincides with Christian celebrations rather than those of other religious traditions.

The complaints above, however, have not elicited passive acknowledgment.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Dr. Nicholas Tate (1995) defended a shared national culture. A historian and former Chairman of the National Curriculum Council, he argued that “all children in England” must be introduced to “the English literary heritage.”

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Children must also be introduced “to the study of Christianity and to the classical world as the basis of European civilization.” He called these “our common culture and our national identity.”

Moreover, philosophers such as Roger Scruton (1991) and Anthony O’Hear (1991) have noted that “the classical tradition” is the “highest achievement of European culture.”

Stewart Deuchar (1989) has contended that “our civilization” is threatened “by cultures with different attitudes and values.”

Others argue that Britain’s geographical closeness, and closer historical ties to France and Spain, justify teaching French and Spanish ahead of Asian languages.

Finally, the legal philosopher John Finnis (2008) weighed in. He argued that requiring assimilation, and excluding cultures with norms hostile to the common good, does not violate natural justice.

Who Is Said To Be Disadvantaged By An Ethnocentric Curriculum?

The following groups may be cited by some sociologists as the victims of the alleged ethnocentric curriculum:

  • Black African and Caribbean students

  • Muslim students from an Asian background

  • Chinese students

  • Gypsy, Roma and Traveller children

The fullest empirical study behind this claim concerns Gypsy, Roma and Traveller (GRT) children. Myers and Bhopal (2009) asked how GRT families and teachers understood schooling.

  • Aim: To understand how Gypsy, Roma and Traveller (GRT) pupils, parents and teachers saw “community” and “safety” at school, and how this related to attendance and engagement with the curriculum.
  • Method: Qualitative interviews with GRT pupils, parents and school staff across a cluster of schools in one English metropolitan borough. One school was locally known as a “Gypsy school.”
  • Results: GRT pupils did not see the curriculum as reflecting their interests or history. School absence was linked mainly to bullying and racism, not to rejecting education.
  • Conclusion: GRT children’s difficult relationship with school reflects curriculum non-representation plus unaddressed racism and bullying. The “good practice” school took a holistic approach to the community.

This is a single-borough qualitative study. It describes the mechanisms at work in the schools studied, not how widespread the pattern is nationally.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Claimed Impact on Minority Pupils

Some multiculturalist sociologists present the following as adverse consequences of an ethnocentric curriculum:

  • Ball (1993) claims that an ‘uncompromising and traditionalist’ vision of pedagogy that propagates a regressive ‘Little Englandism’ pervades the curriculum. It has been argued that this approach which heavily focuses on middle-class white British culture excludes ethnic minorities as well as girls.

  • The Swann Committee of Enquiry (1985) argued that racism exerts a “pervasive influence on institutional policies and practices,” and that it also manifests itself in “individual attitudes and behavior.”

  • The temporary exclusion rate for Gypsy, Roma and Traveller children is 5 times higher than that for White children and nearly 22 times the rate for Indian children.

  • Bernard Coard (1971) argued that the ethnocentric curriculum, and the readings students had to use, gave Black children a poor self-image and lowered their performance.

    Colonial history lessons were singled out. They taught how the British “civilized” the people of the former colonies, and were cited as a source of this harm to self-esteem. Coard used these claims to explain why Black pupils were over-represented in Educationally Subnormal (ESN) schools.

    He argued that culturally biased IQ testing, not lower ability, drove much of that placement. His evidence was personal. It came from his own experience running youth provision for children placed in ESN schools, not from a comparative sample.

Critical Evaluation of the Ethnocentric Curriculum

The arguments of sociologists who call the British system institutionally racist or ethnocentric face several objections.

Are All Cultures of Equal Worth?

Ball’s claims about “Little Englandism” and the exclusion of minority cultures rest on an assumption: that all cultures are of equal worth. Critics regard that assumption as philosophically contestable.

Sir Trevor Phillips, then Head of the Commission for Racial Equality, condemned multiculturalism. He instead argued for “a core of Britishness” (Baldwin & Rozenberg, 2004).

Phillips (2016) later issued a warning. He argued that promoting multiculturalism can make Britain “sleepwalk to a catastrophe that will (…) suppress freedom of expression, reverse hard-won civil liberties, and undermine (…) liberal democracy.”

Behaviour Rules and Equal Treatment

Katherine Birbalsingh disagrees. She rejects the accusation that punishing pupils for braided hair or kissing teeth is racist. She noted that “kissing teeth is rude” and that “Black people know that it is rude” (Busby, 2020).

Standards, she argued, should be universal. She added that “all children, whatever race, are able to behave themselves.”

In her view, “the idea of permitting black children to be rude is to lower your standards for those black children.” On this view, applying an identical rule to every pupil is the least ethnocentric option available.

Does Curriculum Content Explain Attainment Gaps?

Coard’s account struggles to explain the high academic performance of South Asian, particularly Indian, students. Their results exceed those of Black students and, significantly, those of White students too (Gibson & Bhachu, 1988).

Suppose history lessons on colonization lowered performance. Indian children, whose ancestors lived in the British Raj, would then have very low self-esteem and fail in the classroom. The data show the opposite.

  • Aim: To compare the school performance of South Asian pupils in Britain with White and Black pupils, and with South Asian communities in the United States.
  • Method: Comparative ethnographic and attainment data from South Asian communities schooled in the British and American systems.
  • Results: Indian and other South Asian pupils in Britain significantly outperformed both Black and White British pupils. Their ancestors had lived under British colonial rule, as had those of many Black Caribbean pupils.
  • Conclusion: Shared exposure to a colonial-history curriculum, or shared minority status, cannot alone explain underachievement. One formerly colonised group outperformed both the majority group and another minority group.

Coard’s evidence was case-based, a weaker design than this comparative study. The pattern varies sharply by ethnic group, which curriculum content alone does not predict.

More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Rival Explanations of Attainment Gaps

The ethnocentric curriculum argument is one of several sociological explanations for why ethnic groups differ in average attainment. None excludes the others, and each places the main mechanism somewhere other than curriculum content.

A pupil could be affected by curriculum content, teacher expectations and material disadvantage at once. Yet no single study tests all three against each other.

Claims that curriculum content is the explanation therefore outrun the evidence.

Teacher Expectations and Labelling

Labelling theory locates the problem in classroom interaction, not curriculum content. Gillborn and Youdell (2000) argue that teacher racism, often unconscious, is a major factor in Black pupils’ underachievement.

On their account, wider cultural stereotypes lead teachers to read Black pupils’ behaviour as more threatening or disaffected than it is. Expectations fall, and a self-fulfilling prophecy lowers performance.

Sewell (1997) offers a complementary account. He argues that peer pressure among African-Caribbean boys to adopt an “urban” or “street” subculture rewards defiance of authority over academic effort.

These are genuine rivals. A curriculum account predicts that changing what is taught should narrow the gap. A labelling account predicts the gap would persist, even with a fully representative curriculum, unless teacher expectations changed too.

Social Class and Material Deprivation

A structural account blames socio-economic disadvantage, such as income, housing and parental occupation, rather than culture. Strand (2011) tested it directly against ethnicity data.

  • Aim: To estimate how much of the gap between White British pupils and minority ethnic groups social class and other socio-economic disadvantage explain.
  • Method: The Longitudinal Study of Young People in England followed over 14,500 pupils from age 11 to 14. Strand compared ethnicity with social class, free school meal eligibility and home ownership.
  • Results: The ethnic gap at age 14 was over three times the gender gap but about a third of the class gap. Controls largely explained it for Black African, Pakistani and Bangladeshi pupils, not Black Caribbean pupils.
  • Conclusion: Social class drives most ethnic attainment gaps in England. The unexplained Black Caribbean gap is consistent with an additional ethnicity-specific mechanism, such as curriculum content or teacher expectations.

As a large, nationally representative study, it sits higher on the evidence hierarchy than the case-based work behind the wider argument.

Its limit mirrors Coard’s: it shows how much of the gap survives controls, not whether curriculum content explains what remains.

Functionalist and Marxist Views of the Curriculum

Functionalists, following Durkheim, argue that a shared curriculum builds the common values and solidarity a diverse society needs (see functionalism in education).

Critics reply that this “common culture” is one ethnic group’s culture presented as universal. Ball’s “Little Englandism” charge is that objection in curriculum terms.

Marxists treat the curriculum as one way schooling reproduces a dominant class’s ideology (see the Marxist perspective on education). The ethnocentric curriculum thesis narrows that claim to ethnicity.

Some Marxist-influenced sociologists warn that culturalist explanations may understate how much of the ethnic gap is a class effect in disguise. Strand’s analysis speaks to that tension.

Contemporary Research

Research since 2015 now tests the content claim systematically. Ball (1993) and Troyna and Williams (1986) argued their case. They did not test it on a sample of curriculum materials.

Recent content analysis addresses that gap directly, in history and in geography. Its convergence across independently studied subjects strengthens the claim. A second thread follows a policy debate that escalated after 2020.

Eurocentric Narratives in History Textbooks

Nagre (2025) tested the content claim in history, the subject critics single out most often.

  • Aim: To assess whether the narratives in current English secondary school history textbooks remain rooted in Eurocentric discourses of superiority.
  • Method: Nagre reviewed nine history textbooks in use in English secondary schools. The study drew on post-colonial theory to analyse how each represented non-European peoples.
  • Results: With few exceptions, textbooks drew on long-standing tropes such as ‘Oriental’ despotism, ‘African’ servility and ‘native’ backwardness, set against European civility. Their narratives were totalistic, oppositional and teleological.
  • Conclusion: Eurocentric framing, as critics such as Ball (1993) described it, persists in current history textbooks rather than having been resolved by curriculum reform.

Totalistic means treating European civilisation as a single standard. Oppositional means defining other peoples mainly by contrast with it. Teleological means presenting European development as the natural endpoint.

This is a content analysis of nine textbooks. It shows what the materials contain, not how pupils experience them.

Whiteness in the Geography GCSE

Winter (2023) found a similar pattern in a different subject.

She studied how whiteness was enacted in the Geography GCSE topic of global development in two English secondary schools. The study combined textual analysis of curriculum materials with lesson observations and interviews with pupils and teachers.

The curriculum’s framing of “developed” and “developing” nations reproduced a “dividing the world” narrative that mapped onto racialised distinctions. Pupils’ knowledge from outside school often clashed with exam requirements.

Teachers rarely resolved that tension. They largely prioritised getting pupils through the assessment.

With only two schools, the study cannot show how widespread the pattern is. Its value lies in showing a similar mechanism to Nagre’s operating independently in a second subject.

The Policy Response After 2020

The long-running debate over the history curriculum’s treatment of ethnicity and empire escalated after 2020 (Mansfield, 2023). Critics targeted the “Island Story” narrative.

That narrative is a self-contained account of British history, disconnected from the empire through which Britain engaged with the world. Critics said it excluded ethnic minority pupils from a curriculum that claims to represent them.

Mansfield reports that the UK government’s 2021 Commission on Race and Ethnic Disparities placed responsibility for inclusive teaching mainly on individual teachers and schools working within the existing curriculum. It did not mandate systemic reform of curriculum content.

That position echoes Tate (1995) and O’Hear (1991): the shared curriculum need not change, and inclusion is a matter of how, not what, is taught.

This remains a live policy tension, not a settled empirical question.

What the Evidence Still Lacks

Nagre (2025) and Winter (2023) show what current materials contain. Strand (2011) shows how much of the attainment gap survives controls for class.

No study links the two, and neither textbook study measures whether such content damages self-esteem or attainment.

A longitudinal or quasi-experimental design could test it. Researchers could track whether pupils taught a revised, less Eurocentric syllabus show different outcomes from comparable pupils taught the standard one.

Until then, the causal step in Coard’s argument remains an inference from parallel evidence.

Key Takeaways

  • Definition: An ethnocentric curriculum treats one ethnic group’s culture as the default in what is taught. Sociologists call it institutional racism.
  • Critics’ Case: Ball (1993) and Troyna and Williams (1986) argue the English curriculum privileges White Eurocentric content, notably in history.
  • Defence: Tate (1995) and others argue a shared “common culture” is legitimate and supports national identity.
  • Counter-Evidence: Indian pupils outperform both White and Black pupils (Gibson & Bhachu, 1988). Curriculum content alone cannot explain that.
  • Rival Explanations: Strand (2011) found social class explains most ethnic gaps, except for Black Caribbean pupils. Teacher expectations also matter.
  • Recent Evidence: Nagre (2025) found Eurocentric narratives in nine current history textbooks. No study yet shows they harm pupil outcomes.
More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

References

Ball, S. J. (1993). Education, majorism and ‘the curriculum of the dead’. Curriculum Studies, 1 (2), 195-214.

Baldwin, T., & Rozenberg, G. (2004, April 3). Britain “must scrap multiculturalism.” The Times.

Bhopal, K. (2011). ‘This is a school, it’s not a site’: Teachers’ attitudes towards Gypsy and Traveller pupils in schools in England, UK. British Educational Research Journal, 37(3), 465-483.

Busby, E. (2020, January 12). Schools unfairly punish black students for hairstyles and for ‘kissing teeth’ amid racial bias, teachers say. The Independent. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/school-racial-bias-black-students-kissing-teeth-teachers-a9279056.html

Coard, B. (1971). Making black children subnormal in Britain. Integrated Education: Race and Schools, 9 (5), 49-52.

Deuchar, S. (1989). The new history: A critique. Campaign for Real Education.

Finnis, J. (2008). Universality, Personal and Social Identity, and Law.

Gibson, M. A., & Bhachu, P. K. (1988). Ethnicity and school performance: A comparative study of South Asian pupils in Britain and America. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 11(3), 239-262. https://doi.org/10.1080/01419870.1988.9993603

Gillborn, D., & Youdell, D. (2000). Rationing education: Policy, practice, reform and equity. Open University Press.

Mansfield, A. (2023). Increasing inclusion for ethnic minority students by teaching the British Empire and global history in the English history curriculum. Oxford Review of Education, 49(3), 360-375. https://doi.org/10.1080/03054985.2022.2087618

Myers, M., & Bhopal, K. (2009). Gypsy, Roma and Traveller children in schools: Understandings of community and safety. British Journal of Educational Studies, 57(4), 417-434. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8527.2009.00442.x

Nagre, K. (2025). (Mis)educating England: Eurocentric narratives in secondary school history textbooks. Race Ethnicity and Education, 28(1), 134-153. https://doi.org/10.1080/13613324.2023.2192945

O’Hear, A. (1991, February 22). Out of sync with Bach. The Times Educational Supplement.

Phillips, T. (2016). Race and faith: The deafening silence. Civitas.

Report of the Committee of Enquiry into the Education of Children of Ethnic Minority Groups (Swann Committee). (1985). Education for all (Cmnd 9453). HMSO.

Scruton, R. (10 February 1991). Rock around the classroom, Sunday Telegraph.

Sewell, T. (1997). Black masculinity and schooling: How Black boys survive modern schooling. Trentham Books.

Strand, S. (2011). The limits of social class in explaining ethnic gaps in educational attainment. British Educational Research Journal, 37(2), 197-229. https://doi.org/10.1080/01411920903540664

Tate, N. (13 July 1995). Speech to the Shropshire Secondary Headteachers Annual Conference.

Troyna, B., & Williams, J. (1986). Racism, education and the state: The racialisation of educational policy. Capital & Class, 10 (2), 222-224.

Winter, C. (2023). The geography GCSE curriculum in England: A white curriculum of deceit. Whiteness and Education, 8(2), 313-331. https://doi.org/10.1080/23793406.2022.2132179

Saul McLeod, PhD

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MRes, PhD, University of Manchester

Chartered Psychologist (CPsychol)

Saul McLeod, PhD, is a qualified psychology teacher with over 18 years of experience in further and higher education. He has been published in peer-reviewed journals, including the Journal of Clinical Psychology.


Olivia Guy-Evans, MSc

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MSc Psychology of Education

Associate Editor for Simply Psychology

Olivia Guy-Evans is a writer and associate editor for Simply Psychology, where she contributes accessible content on psychological topics. She is also an autistic PhD student at the University of Birmingham, researching autistic camouflaging in higher education.

Ayesh Perera

Researcher

B.A, MTS, Harvard University

Ayesh Perera, a Harvard graduate, has worked as a researcher in psychology and neuroscience under Dr. Kevin Majeres at Harvard Medical School.