Freud’s 1918 case study followed a young Russian man, known to later writers as the Wolf Man, who feared wolves after a childhood dream of white wolves in a tree. Freud analysed the dream and said it hid a memory the man had pushed into his unconscious. It is the research study for the Freudian Theory of Dreaming.
Key Takeaways
Aim
- To trace the childhood roots of a young man’s illness by analysing a dream he remembered from the age of about four.
Method
- A case study (an in-depth study of one person) using qualitative data (words and meanings, not numbers).
- The patient was one young Russian man, looking back on a childhood dream. He was rich and seriously ill. Others diagnosed him as depressed. Freud called it an obsessional illness (unwanted thoughts and rituals).
- Freud treated him over several years and interpreted his dreams, memories and symptoms. The key evidence was a dream of six or seven white wolves sitting still in a tree, staring at him.
- A case study has no independent or dependent variable. Nothing was changed or measured as a number.
Results
- Freud said the dream had manifest content (what the man remembered: still, staring wolves) and latent content (its hidden meaning).
- He said the dream hid a memory from about eighteen months. The child had seen something sexual that he could not understand at the time. Your teacher will not need more detail.
- The man never remembered it. Freud worked it out. The memory was pushed into his unconscious (repressed). It came back as the dream and a fear of wolves.
Conclusion
- Dreams hide repressed material in disguise, so a dream must be interpreted. This supports the Freudian Theory of Dreaming, Freud’s idea that dreams are disguised hidden wishes.
- A childhood experience pushed into the unconscious can cause illness later.
Strengths
- In-depth data: a case study gives rich, detailed qualitative data about one real patient followed over several years.
- Openness: Freud set out the objections to his own reading and tried to answer them.
Limitations
- Subjectivity: Freud interpreted the dream himself, and he may have read it to fit his own theory. Subjectivity means an answer depends on one person’s opinion.
- Sample: one person, one sex, Russian, young, seriously ill (others said depressed) and rich. This is not typical of everyone, so it is hard to generalise (apply the findings to other people).
- No check: the scene was never remembered, so Freud’s reconstruction cannot be tested. The man later doubted Freud’s account.
Ethical Issues
- Confidentiality: Freud did not name his patient, but the real man became known. A way of dealing with it is to use a false name and give no details that identify the person.
- Informed consent: today a patient must agree to a case being published. A way of dealing with it is to explain what will be published and ask if the person is happy.
Exam Use
- In the exam you get marks for the sample (one person, one sex, Russian, young, depression or a mental disorder, rich or upper class) and for subjectivity. Write “unconscious”, not “subconscious”.
- Do not confuse Freud with Williams. Freud studied one man and used interpretation. Williams used journals, judges and scores.
Background
Freud was a doctor who founded psychoanalysis, a way of treating mental illness by talking about a person’s dreams, memories and feelings. His Theory of Dreaming has these ideas.
- The unconscious mind: The part of the mind we are not aware of. It holds hidden wishes and memories.
- Repression: Pushing painful memories or wishes out of awareness and into the unconscious.
- Wish fulfilment: Freud said a dream is a way of getting a hidden wish.
- Manifest content: The dream as you remember it.
- Latent content: The hidden meaning of the dream.
The hidden wishes are upsetting, so they come out in disguise. To find the meaning, you must interpret the dream. This is the idea behind the Freudian theory of dreams.
The patient in this study was a young Russian man from a rich, noble family. He was 23 when he began treatment with Freud in February 1910 (Freud Museum London, n.d.). His health had broken down in his late teens. After the deaths of his father and sister, he was severely depressed. He could not travel alone or even dress himself. He felt cut off from the world by a veil.
Earlier doctors in German clinics had diagnosed depression. Freud called it an obsessional illness. This means unwanted thoughts and rituals that a person cannot stop.
Freud thought the adult illness had its roots in a childhood illness. As a child, the man had been terrified of wolves. The terror began after a dream. Before it, the boy had been naughty and bad-tempered. After it, he became very anxious. This is why Freud saw the dream as a turning point.
Aim
Freud’s aim was to trace the childhood roots of his patient’s illness. He worked from a dream the man remembered from about the age of four.
Freud’s own note says the account was meant as an objective estimate of what the analysis had shown.
Method
Design and Variables
Freud (1918) used a case study. A case study is an in-depth study of one person or one small group. It collects qualitative data, which means words, ideas and meanings, not numbers.
A case study has no independent variable or dependent variable. Freud did not change anything, and he did not measure anything as a number. He worked from the man’s dream, memories and symptoms.
The method is called psychoanalysis. Freud talked with his patient over several years in the time before the First World War.
Sample
The sample was one man. In the exam, you need these features of the sample.
- One person: The case is about a single patient.
- One sex: He was male.
- Russian: He came from Russia.
- Young: He was in his twenties when he was analysed.
- A mental illness: Other doctors diagnosed depression. Freud called it an obsessional illness that grew from a childhood fear of animals. “Depression” or “a mental disorder” both earn the mark.
- Rich: His family lived on country estates, with a nurse and an English governess. “Rich”, “upper class” and “aristocrat” all earn the mark.
Freud did not name his patient. Later writers called him the Wolf Man and gave his real name as Sergei Pankejeff.
Materials
There was no apparatus. Freud’s evidence was what the man told him.
- A dream from childhood: At about four, just before his fourth birthday, the man dreamed his bedroom window opened by itself. Six or seven white wolves sat still in a walnut tree outside, staring at him. They looked like foxes or sheepdogs, with big tails and ears pricked up. He woke screaming.
- Memories and associations: An association is whatever comes to mind when you think about something. Freud asked about each part of the dream and noted what the man said.
- Symptoms: The fear of wolves, and later an obsessional illness.
- Childhood stories: Fairy tales and tales told to the boy.
- A sketch: The man drew the dream for Freud. In later life he painted it again, and two of his paintings are in the Freud Museum London.
Procedure
- The man came to Freud as an adult, very ill. Freud treated him for several years. He later set a fixed end date to push the treatment forward.
- In treatment, he told Freud about the dream of the wolves. Since that dream, he had been afraid of wolves.
- Two details struck the man most. The wolves were completely still, and they stared at him. Freud made these the key to the dream.
- Freud used a rule that dreams often show important things in reverse. So still wolves might hide movement. Wolves staring at the boy might hide the boy himself looking.
- Freud linked the dream to other memories. They included an illness at about eighteen months and sleeping in his parents’ room when ill. Together, these pointed Freud to a scene with movement.
- Freud linked parts of the dream to stories the boy knew. The number of wolves matched the fairy tale “The Wolf and the Seven Little Goats”. Their whiteness matched white sheep and white bedclothes.
- Freud put these together. He said the dream hid a memory from about eighteen months of his parents’ intimate behaviour, which the child could not understand then. Freud called this the primal scene.
Results
The Wolf Dream
The man told Freud the dream as an adult. These are the details in his account.
- Setting: It was winter and night. His bed stood with its foot towards the window. Outside was a row of old walnut trees.
- The action: The only thing that happened was that the window opened by itself.
- The wolves: Six or seven white wolves sat in the big walnut tree, either side of the trunk. They were very still and stared at him. They looked more like foxes or sheepdogs, with big tails and pricked ears.
- The fear: He was terrified that the wolves would eat him. He screamed and woke up.
- Afterwards: His nurse hurried to his bed. It took a long while to convince him it was only a dream. Then he felt he had escaped danger and went back to sleep.
- A drawing: He drew the tree and the wolves for Freud. The drawing matched his description.
- How long the fear lasted: He thought it was his first anxiety dream. Until he was eleven or twelve, he was afraid of seeing something terrible in his dreams.
Freud linked two details to events in the boy’s life.
- Christmas: The boy’s birthday fell on Christmas Day, and the dream came just before it. Freud said the walnut tree stood for the Christmas tree. The window opening was like a door opening on Christmas Eve.
- His father: Freud said the wolf the boy feared stood for his father.
The Two Levels of the Dream
Freud said the dream had two levels.
- Manifest content: The dream as the man remembered it. Six or seven white wolves sat still in a tree and stared at him.
- Latent content: The hidden meaning. Freud said it was a disguised memory of the boy’s parents’ intimate behaviour.
Freud said the dream showed the scene in reverse. The still wolves stood for movement. The wolves staring at the boy stood for the boy himself looking.
A Memory That Was Never Remembered
The man never remembered the scene. Freud said it was not remembered but constructed.
This means he built it from the dream, the associations and the symptoms, which kept pointing to the same thing.
Freud knew many readers would doubt this. Could a child of eighteen months take in such a scene? Could a four-year-old understand it? Freud answered with the idea of deferred action.
Deferred Action
Deferred action means a meaning is added later. At eighteen months, the boy saw the scene but could not understand it. At about four, he was old enough to grasp what it meant, and it frightened him.
The memory was pushed into his unconscious. It came out in disguise, as the dream and as the fear of wolves.
Childhood Fears and Rituals
The man also told Freud about odd behaviour in his childhood. Freud called some of it an obsessional illness. These changes came in stages.
The Timeline
- Up to about three and a half: Quiet and good-tempered. His parents said he should have been born the girl and his sister the boy.
- About three and a half to four: A naughty phase. He was irritable and threw tantrums.
- Just before his fourth birthday: The dream of the wolves.
- About four to four and a half: Constantly anxious, and afraid of various animals, especially of being eaten by a wolf.
- From about four and a half: A long period of obsessive religious piety, with elaborate prayer rituals.
The anxiety lasted about six months. It ended when his mother began reading him Bible stories. He became interested in Jesus, who shared his birthday. This is the usual order, but the man himself could not be sure of it (Freud Museum London, n.d.).
Fears and Cruelty
- Wolves: His older sister made him look at a picture book showing a wolf standing upright and striding. He screamed that the wolf would eat him. She was delighted at his terror.
- A butterfly: He once chased a big butterfly with yellow-striped wings. He was suddenly seized with terror and gave up the chase.
- Beetles and caterpillars: He feared and loathed them. At the same time, he tormented beetles and cut caterpillars to pieces.
- Horses: He screamed when a horse was beaten, and once had to leave a circus because of it. At other times, he enjoyed beating horses himself.
Rituals
A ritual is a set of actions a person feels forced to repeat.
- Prayer: He was very pious for a long time. Before he went to sleep, he had to pray for a long while and make an endless series of signs of the cross.
- Kissing the holy pictures: Each evening, he climbed on a chair to kiss every holy picture in his room.
- Unwanted thoughts: Thoughts that insulted God came into his head against his will. On a journey to a health resort, he felt forced to think of the Holy Trinity whenever he saw three heaps of horse dung in the road.
- Breathing out: When he saw beggars, disabled people or very old men, he had to breathe out noisily so as not to become like them. Freud linked this to the boy’s father. The man remembered seeing his father ill in a sanatorium.
Freud saw all of this as one illness. In the exam, one or two examples are enough to show what “obsessional” means. You do not need to learn them all.
The Later Illness
The fear of wolves did not last. Later it changed into an obsessional illness, which means unwanted thoughts and rituals.
Freud said this was the same hidden material forcing its way out. In 1918, Freud described the man as cured.
The Man’s Later Life
His later life was not a happy one (Freud Museum London, n.d.).
- The Revolution: A few years after treatment ended, the Russian Revolution broke out. As a wealthy aristocrat, he lost his property and fortune and had to leave Russia.
- Vienna: He settled there with his wife and had little money. He often depended on financial support from Freud and his colleagues.
- More analysis: In 1926, he went into analysis again, this time with Ruth Mack Brunswick. He struggled with psychological difficulties throughout his life.
- Painting: He sold paintings to get by. He painted mostly still lifes and landscapes, but also several versions of his dream.
- The “Wolf Man”: He became something of a celebrity in psychoanalytic circles and gave interviews. He signed his letters and paintings “Wolf Man”.
This is one reason why some writers doubt Freud’s claim that the man was cured.
Conclusion
Freud reached these conclusions.
- Dreams hide repressed material in disguise: The manifest content hides the latent content. So a dream must be interpreted to find its meaning. This supports the Freudian Theory of Dreaming.
- A pushed-away experience can cause illness: The boy’s experience was repressed into his unconscious. Freud said it caused the fear of wolves and the later obsessional illness.
- Meaning can be added later: An early experience can cause trouble years afterwards, once the child is old enough to understand it.
Strengths
The case study has these strengths.
- In-depth, qualitative data: Freud gathered rich detail about one real person over several years. It links the dream, the memories and the symptoms into one story.
- Open reasoning: Freud explained each step. He set out three objections to his own reading and tried to answer them.
- A worked example: The case is widely taught to show how psychodynamic ideas (Freud’s ideas about hidden forces in the mind) are used on a real patient.
- A partial echo in later research: Later work shows that memories can be changed by later events. This does not support Freud’s reading of the case.
In the exam you get marks for points that are tied to the study. Say what Freud did, as in “Freud gave the patient’s dream a hidden meaning”.
Limitations
The case study has these limitations.
- Subjectivity: Freud interpreted the dream himself, and he may have read it to fit his own theory. A dream may have no hidden meaning. Subjectivity means the answer depends on one person’s opinion.
- Researcher bias: Freud wrote the case partly to defend his ideas against rivals, so it was not a neutral test. Researcher bias is when the researcher’s own views shape the results.
- Sample: One person, one sex, Russian, young, seriously ill and rich. The sample is not typical of everyone, so the findings are hard to generalise.
- Memory: The man was an adult looking back on a dream from childhood. He could not say for sure how old he was, and put it at three, four or at most five. Early memories can be unreliable.
- No check: The scene was never remembered, so nobody can test whether Freud’s reconstruction is right. His later note says it may have been seen, or imagined later.
- A claim of cure: Freud said the man was cured. The man’s later life and his own words suggest otherwise.
- Another explanation: The wolf fear can be explained without any hidden memory.
Subjectivity
Subjectivity is the named criticism of Freud’s theory. Freud decided what the dream meant, and nobody else checked.
Freud also offered the patient his own ideas about what must have happened, and asked him to confirm or reject them. Freud said the man produced new material without being prompted. But Freud, who held the theory, also decided what counted as confirming it.
Freud wrote the case partly to answer two rivals, Carl Jung and Alfred Adler. So the case was written to defend a theory.
Sample
In the exam you get marks for a feature of the sample and the criticism that goes with it. These are the ones to learn.
- One person: You cannot generalise from one man to everyone.
- One sex: He was male, so the findings may not apply to women.
- Russian: The case may be culturally biased. This means it may not apply to people from other cultures.
- Young: The findings may not apply to children or to older people.
- Depression or a mental disorder: The findings may not apply to people without a mental health problem.
- Rich: The findings may not apply to people from other social classes.
These all say the same thing: low population validity. This means the findings may not apply to other groups.
Writing “generalise”, “unrepresentative” or “biased” is making the same kind of point. Do not take marks for the same point twice. “One man, so not women” and “upper class, so not other classes” are different points.
The Man’s Own Later View
Freud said the man was cured. In fact, he had treatment on and off over many years.
About sixty years later, he gave interviews. He described the analysis in unflattering terms and disputed parts of Freud’s reading (Obholzer, 1982). This is stronger counter-evidence than an outside critic’s, because it comes from the one person the case was built on.
A Different Explanation
You do not need to learn this part. A later learning-based (behaviourist) reading would say a fear of wolves needs no hidden memory (Rachman, 1977). Fears can be learned by being frightened directly, by watching someone else’s fear, or by being told something is dangerous.
Freud’s own account holds material for all three. The boy’s older sister held up a picture of a striding wolf to frighten him. He heard fairy tales in which wolves eat children. Freud thought it possible that his father had threatened in fun to gobble him up.
This does not explain everything. It says little about why the fear began at a dream, or about the later religious illness. But it explains the fear of wolves at least as simply as Freud did.
Ethical Issues
The case was written long before modern ethics rules. These are the issues a student can raise today.
- Confidentiality: Freud did not name his patient, but his identity became known later. To deal with it, use a false name or a letter and give no details that identify the person.
- Informed consent: Freud published a long private treatment. Today a patient must agree first. To deal with it, explain what will be published and ask if the person is happy.
- Protection from harm: The man was already very ill and had treatment on and off over many years. To deal with it, keep risk to everyday levels and stop if the person is distressed.
Exam Questions
What Examiners Look For
In the exam the study is called the dream analysis study of “The Wolfman”. One real question asked for two criticisms of the sample. In 2023 the study was a common partner in the 13-mark essay.
The other types below are possible questions, based on how OCR asks about studies in general.
- Two criticisms of the sample (4 marks): For each criticism, one mark for stating a feature of the sample and one for outlining the criticism. Most students score well here.
- Describe the study (4 to 6 marks, possible): Marked by levels. You need both the procedure and the findings for the top level. Evaluation in a describe answer earns nothing.
- A criticism of the method (2 marks, possible): The criticism must fit the method. A criticism of the sample does not answer a method question.
- 13-mark essay: The Freud study is a common choice as the second study. See the end of this section.
The exam also sets questions on Freud’s theory, not the study. They use a short story about a dream.
- Gap-fill: unconscious mind, latent content and wish fulfilment.
- Application: pick out the manifest content and the latent content of a dream.
- Criticism of the theory: subjectivity, difficult to test, based on unreliable research, and narrow interpretation. These are credited for the theory, not for the study.
- Define repression: pushing a painful memory or wish out of awareness.
Do not answer these with the Wolf Man case. Use the ideas on the dream in the question.
Three mistakes cost marks. Students write “subconscious” when the word is “unconscious”. Students describe the theory when asked to evaluate it. And students call Freud’s explanation “too reductionist” (explaining a complex thing by one simple cause), which does not fit it. Subjectivity is the criticism to use.
The questions and model answers below are examples written for revision. They are not the exam board’s own wording.
Freud or Williams?
Students often mix up the two core studies in Sleep and Dreaming. The Williams study is the other one.
| Feature | Freud study (Wolf Man) | Williams study |
|---|---|---|
| Theory it supports | Freudian Theory of Dreaming, a psychodynamic theory (it explains dreams by hidden wishes) | Activation Synthesis Theory, a biological theory (it explains dreams by brain activity) |
| Method and sample | Case study of one patient: a young Russian man, rich, with depression or a mental disorder | Natural experiment using self-report: 12 students, two male and ten female, aged 23 to 45 |
| What was analysed | One man’s dreams and symptoms, centred on a childhood dream of wolves in a tree, interpreted by Freud (qualitative) | 120 written reports, scored by three judges as numbers (quantitative) |
| Idea about dreams | A dream disguises a hidden wish: manifest content hides latent content | Bizarre dreams reflect REM brain activity, so no hidden meaning is needed |
| Named criticism of its theory | Subjectivity | Reductionism |
Two quick tests help. If an answer mentions one man, wolves, the unconscious or latent content, it is Freud. If it mentions judges, scores, journals or REM brain activity, it is Williams.
Practice Question 1: Two Criticisms of the Sample (4 marks)
Question: Explain two criticisms of the sample used in the Freud study. [4 marks]
Model answer: One criticism is that the sample was one person. So you cannot generalise the findings to other people.
Another criticism is that he was Russian. So the findings may be culturally biased, because they may not apply to people from other cultures.
- Mark scheme: For each criticism, 1 mark for a feature of the sample and 1 mark for outlining the criticism.
- Credited features: One person, one sex, Russian, young, depression or a mental disorder, rich or upper class.
- Not credited: The same point twice. A feature with no criticism.
Practice Question 2: Describe the Study (6 marks)
Question: Describe the Freud study of the Wolf Man. [6 marks]
Model answer: Freud used a case study of one young Russian man with a serious mental illness. Freud treated him for several years.
The man told Freud a dream from about the age of four. Six or seven white wolves sat still in a tree and stared at him. He had been afraid of wolves since the dream.
Freud asked about each part of the dream. He linked it to the man’s memories and to fairy tales.
Freud said the dream had manifest content, the wolves, and latent content, a hidden memory from about eighteen months of his parents’ intimate behaviour.
The man had never remembered it. Freud said it had been repressed into the unconscious and came out in disguise as the dream and the fear of wolves.
He concluded that dreams hide repressed material.
- Mark scheme: Marked by levels. Level 3 (5 to 6 marks): accurate procedure and findings in detail. Level 2 (3 to 4): some of each. Level 1 (1 to 2): a few points.
- Cap: As general advice, an answer with no findings, or no procedure, is unlikely to reach the top level.
- Not credited: Evaluation, such as strengths and limitations.
Practice Question 3: A Criticism of the Method (2 marks)
Question: Explain one criticism of the way Freud interpreted the dream. [2 marks]
Model answer: The interpretation was subjective. Freud decided what the dream meant, and he may have read it to fit his own theory.
- Mark scheme: 1 mark for a criticism of the method, such as subjectivity. 1 mark for developing it with a link to the study.
- Not credited: A criticism of the sample, because the question asks about the method.
The 13-Mark Question
The 13-mark question is a judgement question. It is worth 6 marks for describing and 7 for evaluating. There are no marks for applying.
To reach the middle levels, you must refer to the named study or theory and to one from a different area. Freud cannot be paired with the Williams study or the Activation Synthesis Theory. All are in Sleep and Dreaming.
In 2023 the Freud study was a common partner for a study from a different topic. That worked because Sleep and Dreaming is a different area from that topic.
Check whether the question names a study or a theory. If it names a study, do not just restate the theory. Describe what Freud did and found, then evaluate it. Subjectivity is the named criticism.
Later Research
You do not need to learn this part. Hennings, Lewis-Peacock and Dunsmoor (2021) showed volunteers many pictures around a fear-learning task. A later emotional event strengthened and changed memory of pictures seen just before it.
This is a partial echo of deferred action. But it is one laboratory study with unrelated pictures. It gives no support to Freud’s reading of the case.
References
Freud Museum London. (n.d.). The Wolf Man’s dream [Online learning resource]. https://www.freud.org.uk/schools/resources/the-wolf-mans-dream/
Freud, S. (1918). From the history of an infantile neurosis. In The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. 17. Hogarth Press.
Hennings, A. C., Lewis-Peacock, J. A., & Dunsmoor, J. E. (2021). Emotional learning retroactively enhances item memory but distorts source attribution. Learning & Memory, 28(6), 178–186. https://doi.org/10.1101/lm.053371.120
Obholzer, K. (1982). The Wolf-Man: Conversations with Freud’s patient—sixty years later. Continuum.
Rachman, S. (1977). The conditioning theory of fear-acquisition: A critical examination. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 15(5), 375–387. https://doi.org/10.1016/0005-7967(77)90041-9