The NatCen study (2011) looked at why young people did, or did not, get involved in the riots in England in August 2011. Researchers interviewed 36 people face to face and sorted them into rioters, looters and watchers. It supports the view that a person’s beliefs, and their weighing of costs and benefits, influence behaviour.
Key Takeaways
Aim
- To understand why people, especially young people, did or did not get involved in the 2011 riots, using the events in Tottenham, in London, as the case to learn.
Method
- The method was an interview study, not an experiment. Interviews were face to face: the interviewer and the person met in person.
- There were 36 interviewees, some under 18 and some over 18. They had been involved in, or around, the riots.
- Interviewers asked why people did or did not get involved. They asked follow-up questions when an answer was unclear.
- The data were qualitative, meaning detailed answers in words and not numbers. The researchers sorted the people into groups.
Results
- People fell into three groups: rioters (people who took part), looters (people who took goods) and watchers (people who were there but did not take part).
- Rioters had three sub-groups: protestors, retaliators and thrill-seekers. Looters had two: opportunists and sellers.
- A tug factor pulled a person back from getting involved. One example is relatives not approving.
Conclusion
- NatCen concluded that behaviour at the Tottenham riots was influenced by dispositional factors, which are causes inside the person, such as beliefs about right and wrong.
Strengths
- Follow-up questions: the interviewer could ask for more detail, so the researchers could find out why people got involved.
- Qualitative data: people explained their reasons in their own words, which gave rich detail.
- Rapport: a bond between interviewer and person may make people more open about what they did.
- Ecological validity (how true to real life a study is): the people had been in real riots, so their reasons come from real behaviour.
Limitations
- Social desirability: people may give answers that make them look good, or lie or exaggerate, so their accounts may be wrong.
- Interviewer bias: leading questions, which hint at the answer wanted, could push people towards certain answers.
- Generalisability (how far findings apply to other people and places): 36 people may not show why people join in other riots or places.
- Recall: people described events from some time before, and they may not know their own reasons.
Ethical Issues
- Informed consent means agreeing after being told how your words will be used. Talking about crime makes this important.
- Confidentiality means keeping names private. Admitting to crime is risky.
- Protection from psychological harm matters because recalling a riot could upset people. A debrief (explaining the study afterwards) is one way to deal with it.
- Nothing is known about how NatCen dealt with these issues.
Exam Use
- In the exam you get marks for the sample (36, some under 18 and some over 18), face-to-face interviews, the groups with their sub-groups and tug factors.
- In the exam you get two marks for a strength or a weakness of interviews, but only if you link it to NatCen.
- Social desirability is credited as a weakness of interviews. Demand characteristics (clues that tell people what a study is about) are not.
- The long answer worth 13 marks asks you to pair NatCen with a study from a different topic.
Background
The August 2011 riots in England were a case of anti-social collective behaviour. That means harmful or rule-breaking behaviour carried out by a group or a crowd. A riot is a clear case.
Psychologists explain why a person joins a crowd like this in two ways.
- A situational explanation says the situation changes what the person does: the crowd and the people around them. One example is deindividuation, which means losing your sense of being an individual in a crowd.
- A dispositional explanation says the cause lies in the person, such as their beliefs or their locus of control. That is how far a person believes they control their own life.
NatCen is the study OCR uses for the dispositional explanation.
Aim
The aim of the study was to understand why people, especially young people, got involved or did not get involved. In the exam you only need to know about the events in Tottenham, in London.
OCR gives no hypothesis for this study, so you do not need one.
Method
Design and Variables
Morrell et al. (2011) wrote the report for the National Centre for Social Research, known as NatCen. The research method was the interview. An interview is a self-report method, because people describe in their own words what they did and why.
The interviews were face to face. That means the interviewer and the person met in person.
This was not an experiment. The researchers did not change anything and did not measure the effect of a change. So there is no independent variable and no dependent variable to name. There is no experimental design either, such as independent measures.
What the researchers collected was what people said about why they did or did not get involved. These answers are qualitative data, which means detailed descriptions in words and not numbers.
Sample
There were 36 people in the sample. Some were under 18 and some were over 18.
Examiners want the size and ages of the sample, not how people were recruited. So learn two features:
- the size, 36;
- the ages, a mix of under 18 and over 18.
Materials
There was no apparatus. The main tool was the interview itself, which meant the interviewer’s questions about why people did or did not get involved. The data were what the people said.
Procedure
- NatCen’s researchers arranged face-to-face interviews with people who had been involved in, or around, the riots.
- The interviewer asked why the person did, or did not, get involved.
- When an answer was unclear, the interviewer asked follow-up questions to find out more.
- The researchers sorted the 36 people into groups by whether and how they had been involved. They also noted the factors that held people back.
Results
The Groups of People
The researchers sorted people into groups. In the exam you are asked for the names of these groups, so learn them with their sub-groups.
- Rioters: people who took part in the riots. There are three sub-groups. Protestors joined to protest. Retaliators joined to hit back. Thrill-seekers joined for the excitement.
- Looters: people who took goods. There are two sub-groups. Opportunists took the chance to steal for themselves. Sellers took goods in order to sell them.
- Watchers: people who were there but did not take part.
An opportunist is a looter, not a rioter. So learn each sub-group with its main group.
Exam questions so far have asked for the group names, not for how many people were in each group.
Tug Factors
Some things pulled a person back from getting involved. These are called tug factors.
The example to learn is relatives not approving. A person might stay away because their family would not approve.
In one exam question, “no means to pay for goods” and “poor job prospects” were not accepted as tug factors.
What the Findings Add Up To
People were involved for different reasons. The researchers grouped them as rioters, looters and watchers. Factors such as relatives not approving held some people back.
People also gave reasons for their choices. OCR reads these reasons as beliefs about right and wrong and a weighing up of the costs and benefits of getting involved. That reading leads to the conclusion.
When you describe the study in the exam, you get marks for the sample, the procedure and the findings. A description with no findings is capped.
Conclusion
NatCen concluded that anti-social behaviour such as the Tottenham riots is influenced by dispositional factors. These are factors about the person, such as their beliefs about what is right and wrong and their weighing up of the costs and benefits of getting involved.
This supports the dispositional explanation of behaviour in a crowd. In an essay, you can set it against the situational explanation.
Strengths
- Follow-up questions: An interviewer can ask for more detail when an answer is unclear. In NatCen this let the researchers find out why people got involved.
- Qualitative data: Interviews give detailed answers in words. NatCen could find out why some people were looters and others were watchers.
- Rapport: A bond can form between the interviewer and the person. People may then be more open about their part in the riots.
- Ecological validity: The people had been in real riots, so their reasons come from real behaviour and not a game in a laboratory.
- A mix of ages: The sample included people under 18 and over 18, so it was not just one age group.
Strengths Must Link to the Study
In the exam, a strength of interviews earns one mark. A second mark needs a link to NatCen. A bare “interviews are detailed” may earn nothing, unless it is tied to follow-up questions or qualitative data.
“Follow-up questions let the researchers find out why people got involved in the riots” scores two. A claim such as “interviews make a person less likely to lie” earns nothing.
Limitations
- Social desirability: People may give answers that make them look good, or lie, or exaggerate, or avoid being judged. So their accounts of the riots may not be true.
- Interviewer bias: The interviewer could ask leading questions, which hint at the answer wanted. This is bias in questioning, so people may describe their involvement as the interviewer expects.
- Generalisability: The findings are about the riots in Tottenham. The reasons may not apply to other riots, places or countries.
- Recall: The interviews were about events that had already happened, and people may not know their own reasons.
- Grouping by judgement: Sorting people into groups depended on the researchers’ judgement. Two researchers might sort the same person differently, which is a risk to reliability (getting consistent results).
- Cause and effect: The study found the reasons people gave. Interviews cannot show that beliefs caused people to get involved.
- Time-consuming: Interviewing people one at a time takes a long time.
Social Desirability, Not Demand Characteristics
Some people may have denied being involved. Others may have made their part sound bigger, or hidden it to avoid being judged.
This is social desirability: answering the way that makes you look good. In the exam you get marks for it as a weakness of interviews.
Demand characteristics are different. They are clues that tell participants what a study is about, so they change what they do. Examiners do not credit demand characteristics for this question.
Generalisability
Generalisability means how far findings apply to other people and places. In the exam, do not just write “36 is too small”. Say why the size and the place matter.
You only need to know the events in Tottenham. Other riots, in other places or at other times, could have different reasons. So the reasons may not predict how people behave elsewhere.
People in countries with different policing, history or job opportunities may also have different reasons. This is called cultural bias: a study that fits one culture but not others.
Recall and Construct Validity
The interviews were held after the riots, so people had to remember events from some time before. A person may forget parts or get them wrong.
People may also not know why they did something. After the event, they may give a neat reason that sounds sensible.
So an answer may not match a person’s real reason. This is a problem for construct validity. That means whether a measure really tests what it claims to test.
Ethical Issues
Interviewing people about crime raises ethical issues. The British Psychological Society sets out the rules psychologists follow. OCR’s specification lists three issues and three ways of dealing with them.
Nothing is known about how NatCen dealt with these issues. The points below say what a researcher could do in a study like this one.
- Lack of consent: People talking about illegal acts need informed consent, which means knowing how their words will be used. Some interviewees were under 18, so a parent may also need to agree.
- Confidentiality: Admitting to a crime could get a person into trouble.
- Protection from psychological harm: Talking about a riot, or about staying away from it, could upset someone.
Each issue has a way of dealing with it.
- Consent: Explain what the study involves and ask the person, and a parent where needed, if they agree.
- Confidentiality: Keep names private and use no names in the report.
- Harm: Debrief the person after the interview, which means explaining the study and checking they are alright. Let them stop at any time. This is the right to withdraw.
Nothing suggests the researchers needed to deceive the people they interviewed. Deception means misleading participants. In the exam, debriefing is a way of dealing with an issue and not an issue itself.
Exam Questions
How the Exam Asks About NatCen
These are the question types seen so far.
- Identify (1 mark each): pick the right sample size, the right interview type, a sub-group of rioters or a tug factor from a list.
- State (1 mark each): name a main group such as rioters or looters. Sub-groups are also credited.
- Strength or weakness of interviews (2 marks each): one mark for the point and one for using NatCen.
- Criticism of dispositional factors (3 marks): in a short scenario. One mark for the criticism, one for developing it, one for using the scenario.
- 13-mark essay: a statement about the course, such as how far findings can be generalised.
The group names are also used in research methods questions, such as working out a percentage from a tally of types of rioter.
The examples below are practice questions written in the style of the exam. They are not the exam board’s own wording. The scenario is invented.
Practice Question 1: Weakness of Interviews (2 marks)
Question: Give one weakness of using interviews in the NatCen study. [2 marks]
Model answer: Interviewees may give a socially desirable answer. For example, a person who was involved in the riots might say they were not, because they fear being judged by the researchers.
- Mark scheme: 1 mark for a creditable weakness, such as social desirability, lying, exaggeration, avoiding judgement, interviewer bias or time taken. 1 mark for using NatCen, for example the riots.
- Not credited: demand characteristics.
Practice Question 2: Criticise Dispositional Factors (3 marks)
Imagine that after a football match, some fans smash windows near the stadium. A researcher says the fans did this because of their own personality and morals.
Question: Give one criticism of explaining the fans’ behaviour using dispositional factors. [3 marks]
Model answer: Dispositional factors put too much weight on personality. They underplay the situation. A fan may smash a window not because of poor morals, but because everyone else is doing it and it feels acceptable in that crowd.
- Mark scheme: 1 mark for the criticism. 1 mark for developing it. 1 mark for using the fans in the scenario.
- Other credited points: it is hard to generalise from the individual, because different people see the same event in different ways.
Practice Question 3: Describe the NatCen Study (5 marks)
Question: Describe the NatCen study of the August riots. [5 marks]
Model answer: NatCen studied why young people got involved in the August 2011 riots, including the events in Tottenham. The researchers held face-to-face interviews with 36 people, some under 18 and some over 18.
They sorted the people into rioters, looters and watchers. Rioters included protestors, retaliators and thrill-seekers. Looters included opportunists and sellers. Relatives not approving was a tug factor.
NatCen concluded that behaviour at the Tottenham riots was influenced by dispositional factors, such as beliefs about right and wrong and the costs and benefits of getting involved.
- Mark scheme: marked by levels. The top level needs both the procedure and the findings, described accurately and clearly. Sample, method, groups and conclusion all count.
- Capped: an answer with no procedure or no findings. Evaluation earns no marks in a “describe” question.
The 13-Mark Question
The 13-mark question is the long answer worth 13 marks: 6 for describing and 7 for evaluating. It ends with a judgement. It names a study or theory and asks you to use a second study from a different area of psychology.
NatCen is in Social Influence, so you cannot pair it with the other Social Influence core study. A study from another topic, such as Memory, works. Without a second area, you cannot reach the middle level.
For a question about generalisability, a good partner is a memory study of one man with amnesia. Describe NatCen’s sample, procedure and findings, then evaluate how far they can be generalised.
Later Research
Drury et al. (2020) used interviews with 68 participants, and other sources, in three places to study how riots spread. Some people joined in because earlier rioting made them feel part of the same group as the rioters. Others joined because it made the police seem weak.
This explanation is about the situation, meaning how people act as part of a group. These findings come from the published abstract.
Stott et al. (2017) studied the 2011 riots in Tottenham and Hackney. They found that the riots cannot be understood only through earlier social conditions.
What happened between people in the crowd mattered a great deal. This depended on the groups people felt part of. For example, people who saw themselves as one group may have acted together. This also comes from the abstract.
NatCen is the study used for the dispositional explanation. Later research suggests both the person and the situation matter. It does not show that NatCen was wrong. It adds to it.
References
Drury, J., Stott, C., Ball, R., Reicher, S., Neville, F., Bell, L., Biddlestone, M., Choudhury, S., Lovell, M., & Ryan, C. (2020). A social identity model of riot diffusion: From injustice to empowerment in the 2011 London riots. European Journal of Social Psychology, 50(3), 646-661. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.2650
Morrell, G., Scott, S., McNeish, D., & Webster, S. (2011). The August riots in England: Understanding the involvement of young people. National Centre for Social Research (NatCen).
Stott, C., Drury, J., & Reicher, S. (2017). On the role of a social identity analysis in articulating structure and collective action: The 2011 riots in Tottenham and Hackney. The British Journal of Criminology, 57(4), 964-981. https://doi.org/10.1093/bjc/azw036