Bruner and Minturn’s Perceptual Set Study (1955)

Bruner and Minturn’s 1955 study tested whether expecting a letter or a number changes what a person sees. Twenty-four students saw a broken capital B for a split second. It could be read as the letter B or the number 13. Those expecting letters tended to see a B, and those expecting numbers tended to see a 13.

Key Takeaways

  • Aim: To test whether expecting a letter or a number changes how people perceive a broken B, which can be read as a B or a 13.
  • Method: Each of 24 student volunteers took part in three conditions, called sets: expecting letters, expecting numbers and expecting either. This is a repeated measures design, with half starting with letters and half with numbers (counterbalanced). AQA words it as independent groups (see Exam Questions). Before the letter and number sets, people saw four training cards; the either set used a mixed series of letters and numbers. A tachistoscope, a card-flashing device, then showed the broken B at 30 milliseconds, rising by 20 milliseconds each time until it was reported three times in a row. People drew it and named it each time. The independent variable was what people were told to expect (letters, numbers or either), with exposure time also varied. The dependent variables were the drawing (closed or open) and the name (B or 13).
  • Results: At the short flash, 16 of 24 drew it closed (gap shut or partly shut) after letters, 8 after either and 2 after numbers. At the middle flash the counts were 16, 5 and 2. At the long flash they were 8, 3 and 1. For names at the short flash, 92% said B after letters and 83% said 13 after numbers. At the long flash, 58% still said B after letters, but only a third drew it closed.
  • Conclusion: Expectation changed how people perceived and drew the same figure, mainly when it was shown briefly. The authors argued that identifying an ambiguous figure decides how it is put together as a shape.
  • Strengths: Control: everyone met every condition, with order counterbalanced, so differences cannot come from different people. Standardised procedure: the figure, device and timing rule never changed, and the first report came at about the same exposure under both sets, so neither set needed longer. Two measures: drawing and naming showed that what people call a figure and what they draw can differ.
  • Limitations: Low ecological validity: a tachistoscope and one ambiguous card are far from everyday seeing, so the results may not apply to real life. Small volunteer sample: 24 students, with no ages, sexes or university given and no statistical tests, so a reader cannot tell how much was chance, although the gaps (16 against 2) make a real effect plausible. Demand characteristics: people were told what each series would contain, so some may have drawn what was expected.
  • Ethical Issues: Deception: the stated purpose, recognition speed, was not the real question, so this mild cover story counts as deception in our reading. A way of dealing with it is to tell people as soon as possible that they were misled. Informed consent: the paper describes no consent procedure. A way of dealing with it is to explain what people will take part in and ask if they are happy. Debriefing: the paper does not describe it. A way of dealing with it is to explain afterwards what they took part in, why, and how the results will be used. The risk was low.
Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Aim

A perceptual set is a readiness to perceive something in one way rather than another. Expectation can create one.

In GCSE terms, the aim of the study is to test whether expecting a letter or a number changes what a person sees.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

To test this, the study needed a figure that could be seen in two ways. This is called an ambiguous figure.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

The figure was a B with a gap. A B is an upright line with a curved part on its right (our description).

Here, the curved part was moved one millimetre away from the upright, so the figure could be seen as a B or as a 13 (Bruner & Minturn, 1955). That left a gap.

Read the upright as a 1 and the curved part as a 3, and you get the number 13. Join them up and it is a B.

A drawing with the gap shut or partly shut is called “closed”. A drawing with the gap left is “open”.

The authors’ own question was different. It was about how we organise what we see, such as picking a shape out from its background.

They asked whether a law called closure, from the Gestalt school of psychology, still works once we have decided what a shape is. Closure says a nearly complete shape tends to be seen as complete.

The aim can be put as two questions.

  • The Effect: Do people expecting letters draw and name the broken B as a B more often than people expecting numbers?
  • The Time: Does the effect weaken when the figure is shown for longer?

Method

Design and Variables

This was a laboratory experiment, run in a controlled setting. In outline, people were told to expect letters, numbers or either. Then a device flashed a broken B for a split second, and they drew it and said what it was.

Each person took part in three conditions. A condition is one version of the experiment, such as expecting letters.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

The figure was the same every time. So any difference in how people drew or named it cannot come from the figure itself. The aim was that it came from what they expected.

The independent variable is what the researcher changes. The dependent variable is what the researcher measures. Here there were two of each.

In an exam, name what people expected (letters or numbers) as the independent variable, and the drawing as the dependent variable. The drawing was the main data. The choice of the drawing as the dependent variable is our guidance, not the authors’ or AQA’s.

The full list is below.

  • Independent Variable 1, What People Expected: Letters, numbers or either.
  • Independent Variable 2, How Long the Figure Was Shown: Short, middle or long, set from each person’s own reports.
  • Dependent Variable 1, the Drawing: Whether the broken B was drawn closed (or partly closed) or open.
  • Dependent Variable 2, the Name: Whether people called the figure a B or a 13.
  • Kept the Same: The figure, the device and the rule for how long it was shown.

Everyone met every condition. This is a repeated measures design. Each person is compared with themselves, so differences in eyesight or drawing habits cannot explain a difference between conditions.

The cost is that the same figure was seen three times, so earlier viewings could affect later ones.

To reduce this, the authors used counterbalancing, which means changing the order of the conditions across participants. Half met letters first. Half met numbers first. They report no effect of the order and combined the two halves.

The paper does not use the labels independent variable, dependent variable or repeated measures. These labels are ours, not the authors’. So is volunteer sample, below. AQA’s mark schemes describe the design differently from the paper (see Exam Questions).

Participants

The sample is the group of people who take part. There were 24 students, “drawn haphazardly from the student population”. All had volunteered in various courses to serve as participants.

That makes it a volunteer sample. It means people who put themselves forward.

Anyone whose eyesight was too poor to see the training cards at 110 milliseconds or less was dropped. The training cards were letters or numbers shown before the broken B appeared. A millisecond is a thousandth of a second.

The paper does not say how many were dropped, or give the ages, sexes or university of the participants.

Apparatus and Cards

A tachistoscope is a device that shows a card for a very short, exactly controlled time. The participants looked into one.

The cards showed “normal” capital letters and two-digit numbers, one at a time, all seven millimetres high. The broken B was the one figure that was not normal.

The cards were on view for tens of milliseconds, a fraction of a second.

The Series of Cards

Each person met the broken B three times: once expecting a letter, once expecting a number and once expecting either. Each version is called a set.

Before the broken B, people saw training cards, letters or numbers shown first to set the expectation.

  • Letter Set: Four training letters (L, M, Y, A), then the broken B.
  • Number Set: Four training numbers (16, 17, 10, 12), then the broken B.
  • Either Set: A mixed series of two letters and two numbers. The paper does not say where the broken B came in it.

Half the participants met the letter set first, then the number set, then the either set. The other half met the number set first.

Some short summaries say the broken B sat among letters, or among numbers. In the paper, the expectation came from the cards shown just before it and from the instructions.

The Instructions

Participants were told the study was about “the speed of recognition of letters and numbers”. This was a mild cover story.

It is a reason that is not the real one. The real aim was different. It was about how the figure was perceived and organised.

They had to say what they saw and also draw it. They were told to copy the form exactly: “draw it just as you see it”.

Before each series, they were told what it would contain, such as “This series will contain all letters”.

The Exposure Rule

Every card was first shown for 30 milliseconds. That was too fast for anyone to report. This is called being below threshold.

The card was then shown again and again, each time 20 milliseconds longer, until the participant had reported it three times in a row. The broken B followed the same rule, until it had been called a B or a 13 three times in a row.

Those three successive flashes gave the data. People drew the figure and named it at each one. The authors call them the short, middle and long exposure.

Each was 20 milliseconds longer than the one before, so the long exposure was about 40 milliseconds longer than the short one. That sum is our reading of the stated rule.

Results

The Drawings

The main data were the drawings. The counts below show how many of the 24 participants drew the broken B closed or partly closed. The rest drew it open.

  • Short Exposure: Letter set 16, either set 8, number set 2.
  • Middle Exposure: Letter set 16, either set 5, number set 2.
  • Long Exposure: Letter set 8, either set 3, number set 1.

At the short exposure, 16 of 24 is 67%. The 2 of 24 is 8%.

Expectation made a big difference at the two shorter exposures. Expecting letters, two in three people drew the figure closed. Expecting numbers, almost everyone drew it open.

At the long exposure, most people drew it open. Even so, a third of the letter group (8 of 24) still drew it closed.

Under the either set, most people drew it open.

The paper gives counts and percentages only. It does not say whether the differences were too big to be down to chance, which means bigger than luck alone would give.

The Names

The second measure was what people called the figure.

  • Number Set: 83% named it 13 at the short and middle exposures, and 88% at the long exposure.
  • Letter Set: 92% named it B at the short exposure, 71% at the middle and 58% at the long.

At the long exposure, naming and drawing came apart. About six in ten of the letter group still called the figure a B, sometimes a “broken-B”. Yet only a third drew it closed.

So calling a figure a B was not always enough to make people draw it closed.

Under the either set, few people said it could be a B or a 13. Most picked one name. More picked 13 than B, which the authors put down to the gap making the two easier to tell apart.

Why Did Expectation Change What People Drew?

Pulled Towards the Category

The authors’ idea was simple. A figure is assimilated to, or pulled towards, whatever it is identified as.

A figure identified as a B takes on a B’s features. One is being closed. A figure identified as a 13 takes on those of a 1 beside a 3, and these are separate.

One reply is that people expecting letters simply did not notice the gap. The authors did not accept this. They said “not noticing” the gap means the figure is being pulled towards its category.

Why the Effect Faded

The gap was clearly visible at the long exposure. The authors argued that, at still longer exposures, everyone would draw the figure open whatever they called it.

A clear figure leaves little room for expectation. Perception driven by knowledge and expectation is called top-down processing. The long-exposure result points to bottom-up processing, where the stimulus itself drives what is seen.

Conclusion

In perceptual set terms, two points follow.

  1. Expectation Changed What Was Perceived: Expecting letters or numbers changed how the same ambiguous figure was perceived and drawn.
  2. The Effect Faded: It was clear at the two shorter exposures and weakest at the long exposure.

The authors’ own conclusion answered their question about closure. When a figure is ambiguous enough, how people identify it decides how its parts are put together into a shape. Taken for a B, it tended to be drawn closed. Taken for a 13, open.

So closure does not work on its own. The usual Gestalt rules still applied when there was no identification, or when the stimulus was strong.

Strengths

The study has four main strengths:

  1. Controlled Design: Everyone met every condition, so differences cannot come from different people. Order was counterbalanced.
  2. Same Procedure Throughout: The figure, apparatus and exposure rule never changed. The first report came at about the same exposure under both sets, so neither set needed longer.
  3. Two Measures: Drawing and naming showed that what people call a figure and what they draw can differ. Asking only for the name would have missed this.
  4. Later Research Points the Same Way: A 2020 study by Biderman and colleagues rebuilt the B/13 idea. Surrounding items, not an instruction, pushed answers the expected way (Biderman et al., 2020).

Limitations

Before working through each one, here is a one-line summary of the main limitations:

  1. Small Sample and No Statistics: Only 24 volunteers, little detail about them, and no statistical tests.
  2. Generalisability: A student sample, with authors working in the early 1950s, and a task that needs the Latin alphabet.
  3. Mixed Expectation: An instruction and training cards were combined, so the study cannot say which did the work.
  4. Demand Characteristics: People were told what each series would contain.
  5. Low Ecological Validity: A tachistoscope and a single ambiguous card are far from everyday seeing.
  6. Reports, Not Percepts: Drawings and names are reports, not direct measures of what people saw.

Small Sample and No Statistics

There were only 24 volunteers, from “various courses”. The paper gives no ages, sexes or university, and does not say how many were dropped for poor eyesight. It reports no statistical tests.

The gaps in the counts are large, such as 16 against 2. So a real effect is plausible. But a reader cannot tell how much could be chance.

A 2020 study built on the same B/13 idea also used small samples. Its abstract gives 46 participants in one experiment (Biderman et al., 2020).

Generalisability: Sample, Culture and Era

Generalisability means how far results apply beyond the people, place and time studied. The participants were all students. A sample that does not represent everyone is called sample bias.

The authors worked at two American universities in the early 1950s. The task also needs people who know the Latin alphabet and Arabic numerals.

A 2020 study found a similar effect with another script. It used a Hebrew letter that could be read as a number. That is a different figure, so it only partly answers the question about culture (Biderman et al., 2020).

Mixed Expectation

The expectation came from two things. One was the instruction, “This series will contain all letters”.

The other was the four training cards shown just before the broken B. The study cannot say which did the work.

It also tests something different from later studies, where the figure sits between letters or between numbers (Biderman et al., 2020).

In an answer, describe the expectation as created by the instruction and by what was shown just before.

More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Demand Characteristics

Demand characteristics are cues that tell participants what the researcher wants, so that they behave to suit (Orne, 1962).

Here, participants knew they were in an experiment on recognition. They were told what each series would contain. They also reported the same figure again and again. Someone told “all letters” could say B and draw a B just because it was expected.

Two points may weigh against this. Participants were told to draw exactly what they saw, including incomplete figures. And the effect faded as exposure rose, although the instructions stayed the same.

This argument, both points, is our reading of the paper, not the authors’ own. It does not rule out demand characteristics.

Low Ecological Validity

Ecological validity means how well findings apply to real life. A tachistoscope, a display lasting a fraction of a second and a single character on a card are far from everyday viewing. So ecological validity is low.

The figure was also chosen to be ambiguous. The study shows how expectation settles a tie.

It does not show how expectation acts on a clear input. The authors’ own long-exposure results show the effect fading as the input clears.

Reports, Not Percepts

The drawings and names were collected after the event. They are reports of what people saw. The percept is what a person actually sees.

The authors defended drawing as a method. A critic had objected that the effect might not show up if people picked the figure from alternatives instead.

So the study shows that expectation changes what people report seeing. It does not prove that their percept itself changed.

Ethical Issues

The study raises some ethical points, though the risk was low.

  • Cover Story: The stated purpose, recognition speed, was not the real one. This mild cover story counts as deception, meaning misleading participants, in our reading.
  • Deception in a Mark Scheme: AQA’s June 2025 Paper 2 mark scheme credited deception when evaluating Asch’s study.
  • Informed Consent Not Described: Informed consent means agreeing to take part after being told what will happen. The participants were volunteers, but the paper describes no consent procedure.
  • Debriefing Not Described: Debriefing means explaining the study to participants afterwards. The paper does not describe it.
  • Low Risk: The participants were volunteers and the risk was low.

AQA credits these ways of dealing with such issues.

  • For Consent: Explain what people will be taking part in and ask if they are happy to do so.
  • For Deception: Tell participants as soon as possible if they were lied to.
  • For Debriefing: After the study, explain what they took part in, why, and how the results will be used.

Exam Questions

What Examiners Look For

The AQA specification names “the Bruner and Minturn study of perceptual set” in its Perception topic. This is in Paper 1. It also expects students to show how studies relate to theory.

Paper 1 questions name the study directly. The 2022 and 2023 questions and Question 8.1 begin “Bruner and Minturn investigated the effect of expectation on perception”.

The Paper 1 mark schemes we hold show four questions, quoted in the next section.

  • June 2022, Question 11 (9 marks): Describe the study and evaluate the research method.
  • June 2023, Question 11 (4 marks): Describe the study.
  • June 2025, Question 8.1 (2 marks): Pick two features of the study.
  • June 2025, Question 8.2 (3 marks): Briefly evaluate the study.

AO1 means knowledge and understanding, which is describing. AO3 means analysis and evaluation. The examiners’ reports give this advice in plain words.

  • Describe Means Four Things: Aim, method, results and conclusion. Many 2023 answers described the method and nothing else.
  • Research Method Is Not the Design: In 2022, several students confused the research method with the experimental design.
  • Explain Each Point: In several answers, evaluation points were listed without elaboration.
  • Link It to the Study: Many 2025 evaluations were completely generic, which limited the marks.
  • Half the Marks: In a question like the 9-marker, about half the marks are for evaluation.

Ethics is asked inside research-design questions, not about this study. The June 2020 Paper 2 question was worth 4 marks. The June 2025 Paper 1 Question 17 was worth 6.

The model answers and mark schemes below are our own wording, based on the credited points. The four practice questions at the end are also ours, with invented data or scenarios.

June 2022, Question 11 (9 marks)

Question (9 marks): “Bruner and Minturn investigated the effect of expectation on perception. Describe this study. Evaluate the research method used in this study.”.

Model answer: Bruner and Minturn tested whether expectation affects perception. There were 24 participants. They did an experiment on recognising letters and numbers. Before an ambiguous figure, they were shown a sequence of letters or a sequence of numbers.

The figure was a B with a gap. It could be seen as the letter B or the number 13. Those expecting letters tended to name a B, and at the shorter flashes to draw it closed. Those expecting numbers tended to name and draw a 13.

The researchers concluded that expectation affected how the figure was perceived.

The research method was a laboratory experiment. One strength is high control. Many extraneous variables are removed, so the researcher can be more confident that the independent variable affected the dependent variable. A second strength is standardised procedures. Everyone is tested the same way, so the study can be repeated.

One weakness is low ecological validity. A laboratory is an artificial setting, and interpreting an ambiguous figure is an artificial task. A second weakness is that high control can make behaviour artificial. So the findings can be hard to generalise to real life.

  • Describing, 4 Marks: AQA credits 24 participants, an experiment on recognising numbers and letters, and a broken B that could be seen as a B or a 13.
  • More Credited Description: Most of those shown numbers drew a 13, and most of those shown letters drew a B. The researchers concluded that expectations directly affected how the figure was interpreted.
  • Evaluating, 5 Marks: AQA credits evaluation of laboratory studies: high control, standardised procedures that allow replication, artificial settings and tasks, and findings hard to generalise.
  • Levels: 7 to 9, 4 to 6 and 1 to 3. Evaluation with no link to the research method earns at most 1 AO3 mark.
  • Not Credited: “This shows that expectation affects perception”. It repeats the question stem.

June 2023, Question 11 (4 marks)

Question (4 marks): “Bruner and Minturn investigated the effect of expectation on perception. Describe Bruner and Minturn’s study.”.

Model answer: The aim was to see whether expectation is an important factor in how an ambiguous figure is perceived. There were 24 participants. They did an experiment on recognising letters and numbers.

The figure was a broken B that could be seen as the letter B or the number 13. Those shown letters were more likely to report a B. Those shown numbers were more likely to report a 13. The researchers concluded that expectation affected how the figure was perceived.

  • Mark Scheme: Levels of 3 to 4 and 1 to 2, all for describing.
  • Credited Points: The aim, 24 participants, an experiment on recognising numbers and letters, the broken B, the results and the conclusion.

June 2025, Question 8.1 (2 marks)

Question (2 marks): “Bruner and Minturn investigated the effect of expectation on perception. Which two of the following statements are features of their study?”.

The mark scheme prints only the credited answers. The other options are not printed.

  • Credited Answer 1: “Participants were asked to report and draw what they saw when they recognised it”.
  • Credited Answer 2: “The independent variable was whether participants were shown a sequence of letters or numbers”.

June 2025, Question 8.2 (3 marks)

Question (3 marks): “Briefly evaluate Bruner and Minturn’s study.”.

Model answer: One strength is its laboratory setting. Procedures were standardised, so each participant was tested the same way. The study is easily replicated.

One weakness is that the broken B was made to be ambiguous. We rarely meet such figures in everyday life, so expectation may matter less in real life.

The idea also applies to real life. When we proofread our own writing, we may miss spelling errors because we perceive what we expect.

  • Mark Scheme: Up to 3 marks: 3 for a clear and detailed evaluation, 2 for a limited one and 1 for a very limited or muddled one.
  • Credited Points: Proofreading as a real-life application. An invented, ambiguous figure that is rarely met in real life. A laboratory with standardised procedures, so easily replicated. Support for Gregory’s constructivist theory.
  • Take Care: Generic points, not linked to the broken B, limit the marks.

Where the Mark Scheme and the Paper Differ

Some points AQA credits do not match the paper exactly. Here are the facts.

  • The Design, per AQA: AQA credits an independent groups description, with half shown letters and half shown numbers.
  • The Design, per the Paper: Every participant met all three sets, half starting with letters and half with numbers. That is repeated measures with counterbalancing (Bruner & Minturn, 1955).
  • Where the Figure Sat: AQA credits the figure “in the middle” of a series. The paper showed it on its own after four training cards (Bruner & Minturn, 1955).
  • The Mixed Series: Where the broken B came in it is not stated (Bruner & Minturn, 1955).
  • Names: “Most drew a B” and “most drew a 13” fit the names at every exposure (Bruner & Minturn, 1955).
  • Drawings: The letters claim fits the drawings at the shorter exposures only. At the short exposure, 16 of 24 drew it closed after letters, against 2 of 24 after numbers (Bruner & Minturn, 1955).
  • Drawings, Long Exposure: Only 8 of 24 drew it closed after letters (Bruner & Minturn, 1955).
  • “Directly”: This is the mark scheme’s word. The study cannot say whether the instruction or the training cards did the work (Bruner & Minturn, 1955).
  • Proofreading and Gregory: AQA credits both. Neither is from the paper. The fit with Gregory is our reading.

AQA’s mark scheme credits the independent groups description. In the paper, every participant met all three sets, which is the repeated measures description. The 2022 examiners’ report refers to evaluating the independent groups design for this question.

Question 8.1 credits “whether participants were shown a sequence of letters or numbers”. That matches what we call the expectation set.

Our Practice Question 1: Calculate a Percentage (2 marks)

Imagine a study, with invented numbers that are not Bruner and Minturn’s. Twenty students are told to expect letters, then shown an ambiguous figure. Sixteen name it as a letter. Twenty other students are told to expect numbers and shown the same figure. Five name it as a letter.

Question (2 marks): Calculate the percentage of students who named it as a letter in each group. Show your working.

Model answer: expecting letters, 16 ÷ 20 × 100 = 80%. Expecting numbers, 5 ÷ 20 × 100 = 25%.

  • Mark Scheme: 1 mark for each correct percentage, with working shown.

Our Practice Question 2: Apply Perceptual Set (4 marks)

Imagine Ali sees an oval character that is either the letter O or the number 0, depending on where it appears. In a word on a shop sign, he reads it as a letter. In a phone number, he reads it as a digit.

Question (4 marks): Use perceptual set to explain why Ali reads the same character in two ways.

Model answer: A perceptual set is a readiness to perceive something in one way rather than another. Expectation can create it.

In a word, Ali expects letters, so he reads the character as a letter. In a phone number, he expects numbers, so he reads it as a digit.

Bruner and Minturn’s result is a laboratory version of this. People expecting letters tended to name a broken B as a B, and people expecting numbers tended to name it a 13.

  • Mark Scheme: 2 marks for knowledge, such as perceptual set, expectation, or detail from Bruner and Minturn. 2 marks for applying it to the word and the phone number.

Our Practice Question 3: Design an Experiment (6 marks)

Question (6 marks): Design an experiment of your own to test whether expecting letters or numbers changes what people see in an ambiguous figure.

Model answer: The independent variable is what people are told to expect, letters or numbers. The dependent variable is whether they name the figure as a letter or a number, such as how many name it as a letter.

I would use two groups of different people. This is an independent groups design, with different people in each condition. Seeing the same figure twice could affect the second viewing.

Everyone sees the same figure for the same time, and the only difference is the words they are told. This is a standardised procedure, the same steps for everyone. It makes the test fair.

I expect more people told “letters” to name it as a letter. Expectation gives a perceptual set, so they are ready to see it that way.

  • Mark Scheme: 1 mark each for the independent variable, the dependent variable, a suitable design with a reason, and a standardised procedure with a reason.
  • Expected Result: 2 marks, 1 for the prediction and 1 for the reason.
  • Note: Bruner and Minturn used the same people in every set and counterbalanced the order. We would credit that design too if it is explained.

Our Practice Question 4: Ethical Issues (4 marks)

Question (4 marks): Name two ethical issues that a researcher should consider in a study like Bruner and Minturn’s. Suggest one way of dealing with each.

Model answer: One issue is informed consent. A way of dealing with it is to explain what people will be taking part in and ask if they are happy to do so.

Another issue is deception. This mild cover story counts as deception. The participants were told the study was about recognition speed, which was not the real question. A way of dealing with it is to tell them as soon as possible that they were misled.

  • Mark Scheme: Per issue and way, 2 for clear, accurate and in context, 1 for limited or muddled (the AQA 2020 pattern).
  • Issues We Would Credit: For example, informed consent, deception, right to withdraw, protection from harm, confidentiality and debrief. AQA 2020 also credits parental consent.
  • Ways We Would Credit: For example, a number, not a name; asking consent; asking parents if under 16; telling people if lied to; letting people stop; a debrief.
  • Note: AQA’s real ethics questions are generic, not about this study.

Later Research

The B/13 Figure Again (Biderman et al., 2020)

In 2020, Biderman, Shir and Mudrik rebuilt the B/13 idea from a 1 and a 3, with a gap of varying size. They tested surrounding items, not an instruction.

The figure sat between two letters (A and C) or two numbers (12 and 14). Participants said whether it was a B or a 13.

The surroundings pushed answers the way expectation would. When the surroundings were masked, which means hidden from conscious view, the effect was smaller. The first, exploratory masked result was called weak (Biderman et al., 2020).

This is not the same test as 1955, when an instruction and training cards set the expectation. The experiments were small. But the direction of the effect seems to have held up, though the first exploratory masked result was weak and one gap size went the other way.

How Does the Study Link to Theories of Perception?

Gregory’s Theory

Gregory (1980) proposed that perceptions are hypotheses (a kind of informed guess) built from clues and past experience. The specification calls it Gregory’s constructivist theory. AQA’s June 2025 mark scheme credits the study as support for it.

Our reading is that the 1955 result fits his account. Expected categories helped to settle an unclear figure.

The authors spoke of assimilation to a category (the figure being pulled towards it). Gregory spoke of hypotheses. Both say that prior knowledge settles unclear input.

Gibson’s Theory

Gibson (1979) held that what reaches the eyes in normal viewing is usually rich enough to tell us what is there, without guessing. So expectation should matter least when the information is rich.

A brief, deliberately ambiguous figure is also the kind of poor display that his approach treats as a special case.

Our reading is that the fading of the effect as the figure became clearer fits that view. Gregory’s account can accept it too.

More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

References

Biderman, D., Shir, Y., & Mudrik, L. (2020). B or 13? Unconscious top-down contextual effects at the categorical but not the lexical level. Psychological Science, 31(6), 663–677. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797620915887

Bruner, J. S., & Minturn, A. L. (1955). Perceptual identification and perceptual organization. The Journal of General Psychology, 53(1), 21–28. https://doi.org/10.1080/00221309.1955.9710133

Gibson, J. J. (1979). The ecological approach to visual perception. Houghton Mifflin.

Gregory, R. L. (1980). Perceptions as hypotheses. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences, 290(1038), 181–197. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.1980.0090

Orne, M. T. (1962). On the social psychology of the psychological experiment: With particular reference to demand characteristics and their implications. American Psychologist, 17(11), 776–783. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0043424

Olivia Guy-Evans, MSc

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MSc Psychology of Education

Associate Editor for Simply Psychology

Olivia Guy-Evans is a writer and associate editor for Simply Psychology, where she contributes accessible content on psychological topics. She is also an autistic PhD student at the University of Birmingham, researching autistic camouflaging in higher education.


Saul McLeod, PhD

Chartered Psychologist (CPsychol)

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MRes, PhD, University of Manchester

Saul McLeod, PhD, is a qualified psychology teacher with over 18 years of experience in further and higher education. He has been published in peer-reviewed journals, including the Journal of Clinical Psychology.