Wilder Penfield’s 1959 study of the interpretive cortex reported what happened when a surgeon gently stimulated the brains of awake patients having epilepsy surgery. In a part of the temporal lobes he named the interpretive cortex, a weak current occasionally made a patient re-live a scene from the past. Penfield did not claim the area stores memories.
Key Takeaways
- Aim: To describe the part of the temporal lobes (the interpretive cortex) where a weak electric current made some patients re-live the past, and to suggest what that area does normally.
- Method: This was a case study with an element of experiment inside each operation. The independent variable was where on the cortex the current was applied, and whether it was on. The dependent variable was what the patient reported feeling, as the surgeon recorded it. The patients were awake epilepsy patients under local anaesthetic, so they could speak. The surgeon applied a weak current to the exposed cortex, often again without warning, and questioned them. In one control trial he said he was about to stimulate but did not.
- Results: Only the temporal lobes gave re-lived scenes or changed interpretations, in more than 1,000 operations since 1936. S.Be. heard a piano and D.F. an orchestra. R.W. heard his mother on the telephone, and J.V., a girl of 16, felt fear. Other areas gave only simple responses such as movement, lights, ringing or tingling. A note gives 35 of 384 temporal lobe cases with an experiential response, about 9 per cent. A larger 1963 count gave 40 of 1,132 patients in all, about 3.5 per cent.
- Conclusion: Penfield suggested the interpretive cortex takes part in comparing the present with past experience. He said the record of the past is not laid down there. He called it unjustified to say the area stores memories.
- Strengths: Awake patients could describe what they felt, which gave direct evidence from a known place. AQA credits the study for information about localisation of function and brain mapping. AQA also credits case studies as open to unexpected results and as helping us understand what is normal. Penfield found the responses largely by stimulating, not by testing a prediction set in advance.
- Limitations: The patients were all severely epileptic, an unusual sample that may not represent other people. Few patients responded, so the vivid cases were exceptions. The reports were private, hard to describe and different for each patient, so conclusions are hard to draw.
- Ethical Issues: Informed consent is not described. A way of dealing with it is to explain what patients will take part in and ask if they are happy. Confidentiality is a concern. The patients were named by initials, but J.V. attended a meeting 21 years later where her case was discussed, a sign that cases can reach an audience. AQA credits confidentiality because unusual participants may be identified. AQA’s way is to leave names out of reports and use a number or a letter if they must be referred to..
Aim
Penfield was a neurosurgeon. That is a doctor who operates on the brain. From 1936 he and his colleagues operated on awake patients at the Montreal Neurological Institute.
The patients had epilepsy, a condition that causes seizures, also called fits. Some seizures begin with a warning experience. The surgeon wanted to remove the brain tissue that caused a patient’s attacks, if that did not cost the patient an important function.
A weak electric current helped to find it. If it brought back the experience that began an attack, it showed the surgeon where to operate.
Sometimes the current did more. It produced experiences the patient had never had during a seizure.
Penfield did not set out to test a prediction. Stimulation was part of the search for tissue to remove, and he recorded what patients felt.
The outer layer of the brain is the cortex. It is folded and divided into lobes. The temporal lobes are two of them, one on each side. Penfield named part of them the interpretive cortex.
He called it slang for use in discussion. It did not mean the area works on its own.
The idea that different parts of the brain have different jobs is called localisation of function. For example, one area produces movement and another gives touch sensations.
Penfield’s study is used as an example. He said localisation means specialisation, not separation. Each area has its own job but still works with the rest of the brain.
In the article he describes the area that gave these responses and suggests what it does in normal life.
These aims can be put as three questions.
- Where: Which part of the cortex gives re-lived experiences or changed feelings about the present when it is stimulated?
- What: What are these responses like, and how do they differ from the movements and sensations that other areas give?
- Why: What does this area do in normal life, and does it show where memory is stored?
Method
Design and Variables
This was a case study: a detailed study of one person or a small group (Penfield, 1959). AQA calls it a case study.
The article is a summary. It brings together 23 years of operations and earlier reports. It describes five patients as case examples. It does not report one new experiment with statistics and a hypothesis, a prediction the researchers set out to test.
Even so, there was an element of experiment inside each operation. The surgeon changed one thing, where the current was applied, and the patient said what they felt.
The independent variable is what the researcher changes.
Here it was where on the cortex the current was applied, and whether it was on (the sham trial is the current-off case).
The dependent variable is what the researcher measures. Here it was what the patient said they felt, as the surgeon recorded it.
Penfield did not use these labels, so they are ours. The wording of the three questions in Aim is ours too.
A control is a check that shows what happens without the key change. The one control the article describes is the sham trial. The surgeon said he was about to stimulate but did not. There was no control group, meaning no separate set of patients to compare.
If a question asks for variables, the area stimulated and what the patient reported fit.
Participants
The patients were having brain surgery for epilepsy, under local anaesthetic. The operations were treatment.
The article describes five patients by their initials: S.Be., D.F., R.W., J.T. and J.V. It gives an exact age only for J.V., a girl of 16 who came to the hospital in 1936. R.W. is described as a boy.
It says almost nothing about cultural background.
The Operation
These were the main steps.
- Awake patients: A local anaesthetic numbs one area, here the scalp and skull. So the patient stayed awake and could speak, and could tell the surgeon what they felt.
- Gentle stimulation: The surgeon placed an electrode, the tip that carries the current, on the exposed cortex. The current was weak.
- No feeling in the brain: The cortex itself has no sensation. A patient could not tell when the electrode touched it unless told.
- Questions: The surgeon questioned the patient. He asked the boy R.W. whether he remembered the conversation he heard, and whether it seemed like a dream.
- Repeating: The surgeon often stimulated the same or a nearby point again without warning.
- A sham trial: This was the control. With S.Be. the surgeon warned the patient, paused, said “Now” and did not stimulate. The patient replied “Nothing”.
The article does not give the setting used at each temporal site. Which points the surgeon tested depended on the patient’s epilepsy, because stimulation was part of the search for tissue to remove.
Results
The Five Patients
Penfield described five patients.
- S.Be.: Stimulation of the right temporal lobe made him hear a piano and someone playing a song he knew. A point 4 cm further forward brought back two lit advertisements in Montreal.
- D.F.: She heard an orchestra playing a popular song. It stopped when the electrode was removed and returned when it was put back.
- R.W.: A boy heard his mother talking to someone on the telephone. Later he heard her telling his brother that his coat was on backwards.
- J.T.: He called out that he could hear people laughing. He seemed to be laughing with two cousins on a South African farm. He knew he was on an operating table in Montreal.
- J.V.: A girl of 16 whose seizures all began with the same hallucination, an experience with no outside source. It was a dream of a scene from early childhood.
At other points the current gave J.V. sudden fear, a sense that someone was coming towards her, or the voices of her mother and brothers.
D.F. believed a gramophone was playing in the operating theatre. Stimulating the same spot again gave the same song, always starting at the same place, more than 20 times.
Two Kinds of Response
Penfield sorted the responses into two kinds.
- Experiential response: The patient re-lives something from an earlier time, in great detail. It stops when the current is switched off. The same scene can often be started again from the same spot.
- Interpretive response: Something happening now suddenly feels different. It may seem familiar, as if seen before, which is déjà vu. Or it may seem strange, far away, or unexpectedly loud. Some patients felt fear.
Patients stayed aware of the present during an experiential response. S.Be. and J.T. both knew they were in the operating theatre.
What Other Areas Gave
Stimulating other areas gave simpler responses. The motor cortex produced movement. The visual cortex gave lights, colours and shadows with crude outlines. The auditory cortex gave ringing, hissing or thumping. The postcentral gyrus, a sensory area, gave tingling or a false sense of movement.
Penfield said the sensory areas gave only the elements of sensation. They never gave happenings that might have been experienced before.
Only the Temporal Lobes
Over 23 years, almost every part of the cortex was stimulated in more than 1,000 operations under local anaesthetic. Only the temporal cortex gave re-lived scenes or changed interpretations.
He described it as covering part of both temporal lobes. It was from these two matching areas, and nowhere else, that these responses occasionally came.
No special function had been given to this region before. Some doctors had suggested it was to do with the recall of music.
How Often Did It Happen?
The responses were uncommon. A note in the article says a review of 384 temporal lobe cases found 35 with an experiential response. That is about 9 per cent.
Other counts exist. A later, larger count by Penfield and Perot found 40 patients with experiential responses among all 1,132 patients, about 3.5 per cent. The same 40 are 7.7 per cent of the 520 whose temporal lobes were explored (Penfield & Perot, 1963).
The 9 and 3.5 per cent figures are our calculations; the 1963 paper prints the 7.7. The vivid cases were exceptions.
Conclusion
In short, the area seems to help compare what is happening now with past experience. Penfield did not say it stores memories.
Penfield drew these conclusions.
- A Comparing Area: The interpretive cortex takes part in comparing the present with past experience. He thought this happens automatically, below conscious thought, and helps us make sense of the present.
- A Scene Starts at Random: The current started a scene from the past at a random point. The scene then ran forward.
- The Record Is Elsewhere: The record of the past is kept in a closely connected part of the brain, not here. Calling the area the memory store would be unjustified.
- Limits: What the area contributes to the whole process is not clear. The name would serve until more was known.
Some summaries say the brain replays old memories like a recording. This is the replay reading. Penfield used that comparison at the start of the article. Later he said that concluding the area stores memory would be unjustified.
He also looked at what surgery did. The hippocampus lies underneath the interpretive cortex. It is needed to form new long-term memories.
Removing large areas of interpretive cortex, even on both sides, did not abolish the ability to remember recent events, though patients might complain of mild memory trouble. He cited others’ work on removals that interfered with the hippocampal region on both sides, which made recording recent events impossible.
Penfield gave an everyday example of why the brain might compare the present with the past. You meet a man you had forgotten. You feel a sudden sense of familiarity before you have time to think. Then you remember him, even that his name was Jones.
He suggested that the sight of the man instantly and automatically reached your records of the past that include him. This is his argument, not a measured finding.
Strengths
The study has seven main strengths:
- Direct Evidence From Awake People: A known stimulus at a known place, with a patient who could describe the result. D.F. heard the same song more than 20 times from one spot.
- Specific to One Area: None of the 612 patients whose other areas were explored had an experiential response (Penfield & Perot, 1963).
- A Check on Suggestion: The patient could not feel the electrode. In the one sham trial, S.Be. said “Nothing”. One trial is a weaker check than a systematic one.
- Careful Conclusions: Penfield called the name slang and denied the area was the store of memory. Later criticism targets the replay reading, which he did not endorse (Curot et al., 2017).
- Open to Unexpected Results: AQA credits this advantage of case studies. Penfield found the responses by stimulating the brain, not by testing a prediction.
- A Contribution to Brain Mapping: AQA credits information about localisation of function and brain mapping. It credits case studies for helping us understand what is normal.
- A Precise Procedure: AQA credits the procedure as precise and detailed. The article gives no setting for each temporal site.
Limitations
Before working through each one, here is a one-line summary of the main limitations:
- Unrepresentative Sample: All the patients had epilepsy, and the study was done in one place between 1936 and 1959.
- Few Patients Responded: Only a minority had an experiential response, and the article reports no statistics.
- Reports Cannot Be Checked: The experiences were private, and AQA credits that they may have been hard to describe and differed for each patient.
- The Surgeon’s Questions: Questioning during surgery may have shaped what patients reported.
- Case Study Design: Each patient differed and there was no control group, and findings from case studies cannot be applied to other people without more evidence.
An Unrepresentative Sample
All the patients were having brain surgery because of epilepsy. Penfield said an epileptic irritation in the area could produce the same experiences. A later, larger count found that practically all of the 520 patients whose temporal lobes were explored had temporal lobe seizures (Penfield & Perot, 1963).
Generalisability means how far results apply beyond the people studied. A brain with long-standing epileptic activity may not respond as other brains would. AQA credits this point.
The patients were treated in Montreal between 1936 and 1959. Their reports were personal: an orchestra, a radio theme tune, two local advertisements, friends on a farm in South Africa. Nothing in the article tests whether people from other cultures or eras would respond in the same way.
Few Patients Responded
Only a minority responded. The 1959 note gives 35 of 384 temporal lobe cases, about 9 per cent. The later count gives 40 of 1,132 patients, about 3.5 per cent (Penfield & Perot, 1963).
Penfield chose cases such as D.F.’s to illustrate. The article reports no statistics. A conclusion about what the temporal cortex does in people in general cannot rest on them alone.
AQA credits the point that vivid recall appeared in under 5 per cent of participants. That matches the 1963 count of about 3.5 per cent, not the 9 per cent of the 1959 note.
Reports Cannot Be Checked
The experiences were private, so nobody else could check them. The 1963 paper accepts that in some cases other people, called witnesses, could not prove the experience came from the patient’s past. In most cases the patient was confident that it did (Penfield & Perot, 1963).
D.F. believed that a gramophone was playing in the room. That is a hallucination taken as real, not a memory.
A later review of 80 years of such reports, by Curot et al. (2017), found that most evoked memories were poorly detailed. Few were memories of a particular event. AQA credits that findings differed for each participant and that participants may have found their experiences hard to describe.
These points weaken the reading of the responses as memories. They do not weaken the fact that stimulation changed experience.
The Surgeon’s Questions May Shape the Report
The surgeon questioned patients as they spoke. He asked R.W. whether he remembered the conversation and whether it seemed like a dream.
Sjöberg (2022) argued that stimulation, and the talk between patient and surgeon, could create experiences that patients then read as memories.
Patients’ words may reflect the situation, not only the brain. The sham trial with S.Be. is the one check on expectation that the article describes.
Case Study Design
Each patient differed. There was no control group and no statistical test. Findings from case studies cannot be applied to other people without extra evidence, and AQA credits this point.
The same mark scheme credits an advantage. Case studies are open to unexpected results and help us understand what is normal.
This matters here. Penfield found the responses by stimulating the brain, not by testing a hypothesis, a prediction he had set in advance.
Ethical Issues
The article does not describe consent. The operations were treatment, and the patients were awake and talking to the surgeon.
The standard for informed consent today is stricter than in the 1930s to 1950s.
- Informed Consent: Informed consent means agreeing to take part after being told what will happen. The article does not describe it.
- Confidentiality: Patients are named by initials. J.V., a physician’s daughter, attended a meeting 21 years later where her case was discussed, a sign that cases can reach an audience.
- Harm: Stimulation produced fear in J.V. The article does not mention harm.
AQA credits confidentiality because unusual participants may be identified.
AQA’s mark schemes credit these ways of dealing with ethical issues in a study.
- Consent: Explain what participants will take part in and ask if they are happy to do so.
- Anonymity: Do not use names in any report. Use a number or a letter if they must be referred to. Penfield used initials. Leaving out identifying details as well is our addition.
- Harm: Make sure the risk is no greater than in everyday life.
- Right to withdraw: Tell participants they can stop at any point.
- Debrief: After the study, explain what they took part in, why, and how the results will be used.
Exam Questions
What Examiners Look For
AQA names this study in the GCSE Psychology specification, topic 3.2.3 Brain and neuropsychology, as “Penfield’s study of the interpretive cortex”. It is a Paper 2 study, but Paper 1 has also used his method. These four questions are real AQA questions.
- June 2022, Question 15.1 (3 marks): “Briefly describe Penfield’s study of the interpretive cortex.” All three marks are for knowledge.
- June 2022, Question 15.2 (5 marks): “Evaluate Penfield’s study of the interpretive cortex.” All five marks are for evaluation, marked by levels.
- June 2020, Question 14 (9 marks): “Describe Penfield’s case study of the interpretive cortex. Evaluate the research method used in this study.”.
- June 2024, Paper 1, Question 17 (9 marks): a question that used Penfield’s method. It is set out under Past Question 4.
The model answers and the practice questions are ours, written in the style of the exams. The “Imagine” questions use invented numbers or an invented student claim.
The credited points for the description are these.
- Method: Case studies of patients who were conscious during brain surgery. Gentle electrical stimulation of different areas of the cortex, and patients describing what happened.
- Control: The doctor sometimes told patients he was stimulating when he was not.
- Temporal lobe: Vivid recall of memories, feelings such as fear, a piano, an orchestra.
- Other areas: Motor and sensory areas gave different physical actions, or a belief that someone had touched the patient. AQA 2020 adds earlier visual cortex work.
- Conclusion: Evidence for localisation of function, and a strong role for the temporal lobe in memories.
The credited evaluation points are the ones in the Limitations and Strengths sections.
What the Examiners Said
AQA’s examiners’ reports tell you what students got wrong.
- June 2022, Question 15.1: Over half of students gained 2 marks. Common errors were describing only the method, with no results, or describing a different study such as Asch, Tulving or Piliavin.
- June 2022, Question 15.2: Almost two-thirds of students reached Level 2 or Level 3. Most wrote about the unrepresentative epileptic sample and the scientific, precise procedure.
- June 2024, Paper 1, Question 17: Many students found it very challenging, especially outlining early brain development. Some wrote about smoking in pregnancy or Piaget’s stages.
- Same question: More able students gained marks from discussing Penfield’s method. Several discussions did not focus on the time before birth and the early years.
Past Question 1: Briefly Describe the Study (3 marks)
This is a real question.
Question: Briefly describe Penfield’s study of the interpretive cortex. [3 marks]
Model answer: Penfield carried out case studies on patients who were having brain surgery for epilepsy. They were conscious, so they could speak. The surgeon applied gentle electrical stimulation to the cortex and asked patients to describe what happened.
When he stimulated the temporal lobe, some patients re-lived a memory. One heard a piano, another heard an orchestra, and one felt fear.
- Mark scheme (AQA): 3 marks for a clear and detailed description, 2 for a limited description, and 1 for a very limited or muddled description.
Past Question 2: Evaluate the Study (5 marks)
This is a real question.
Question: Evaluate Penfield’s study of the interpretive cortex. [5 marks]
Model answer: The patients were all having brain surgery because they had epilepsy. Their brains may not respond as other brains would, so the results may not apply to everyone.
Only a minority re-lived a scene. In the article’s note it was 35 of 384 temporal lobe cases. So the vivid cases were exceptions.
The reports were private and the patients may have found them hard to describe. The findings differed for each patient, so conclusions are hard to draw.
However, the study gave a lot of information about localisation of function and helped to map the brain.
- Mark scheme (AQA): Level 3, 4 to 5 marks: effective evaluation with sound conclusions. Level 2, 2 to 3 marks: some effective evaluation. Level 1, 1 mark: limited evaluation.
Past Question 3: Describe and Evaluate (9 marks)
This is a real question.
Question: Describe Penfield’s case study of the interpretive cortex. Evaluate the research method used in this study. [9 marks]
The 9 marks are 4 for describing and 5 for evaluating, marked by levels. Here is a model answer of about 240 words.
Penfield’s study was a case study of patients who were having brain surgery for epilepsy. They were conscious, so they could speak. The surgeon applied gentle electrical stimulation to different areas of the cortex and asked the patients to describe what happened.
Stimulating the temporal lobe made some patients re-live a memory. One heard a piano, another heard an orchestra, and a girl felt fear. Stimulating motor and sensory areas gave movements and feelings of touch.
As a control, the surgeon told one patient he was stimulating when he was not. The patient replied “Nothing”.
Penfield concluded that the temporal area takes part in comparing the present with past experience. He said it was not the place where memories are stored. The study is used as evidence for localisation of function.
One weakness of the case study method is the sample. The patients were severely epileptic, so they may not represent the wider population. Findings from a case study cannot be applied to other people without more evidence.
A second weakness is ethics. The patients were identified by initials, but they were so unusual that they might be recognised, which breaks confidentiality.
Only a minority of patients re-lived a scene. The vivid cases were exceptions.
One strength is that a case study is open to unexpected results. Penfield found the responses by stimulating, not by testing a hypothesis. Case studies also help us understand what is normal.
- Levels (AQA): Level 3, 7 to 9 marks: accurate, detailed knowledge and effective evaluation. Level 2, 4 to 6: some omissions. Level 1, 1 to 3: limited knowledge and evaluation.
Past Question 4: A Paper 1 Question on Penfield’s Method (9 marks)
Penfield is named in the Paper 2 content. But in June 2024 a Paper 1 question used his method. AQA’s examiners call it a synoptic question, one that does not sit in a single topic.
Be ready to use what you know about a study in a new setting. This is a real question.
Question: Psychologists have developed many ways to study the brain. A psychologist called Penfield used a method called the Montreal procedure to study the cortex.
The method involved gently stimulating parts of the cortex with electricity. Participants were asked to describe any sensations that they experienced.
Outline early brain development.
Discuss the appropriateness of Penfield’s method to investigate the brain before birth and during the early years of life.
The question is worth 9 marks. Four marks are for the outline of early brain development and five for the discussion, marked by levels. “Montreal procedure” is AQA’s name. The 1959 article does not use the term.
Model answer, about 220 words. The first two paragraphs are AQA’s credited content on brain development. They are not Penfield facts.
Brain development begins in the third week of pregnancy. In the fourth week the neural tube begins to divide into the spinal cord, forebrain, midbrain and hindbrain.
By the sixth week the forebrain forms the cortex and the thalamus. By the sixth month the brain is fully formed. It is not yet full size.
At birth a baby’s brain is about a quarter of adult size. It doubles in the first year. By age three it is about 80 per cent of adult size.
Penfield’s method is not very appropriate before birth or in the early years. His patients were having open brain surgery for epilepsy. That would be very difficult on an unborn baby.
An unborn baby cannot consent. A young child would not understand what the procedure meant. So there are ethical problems.
The cortex keeps developing through childhood and early adulthood. So the method would be inappropriate for studying a young child’s cortex. The procedure is also invasive. A brain scan such as fMRI would be more appropriate and ethical.
Penfield’s patients described what they felt. Young children may not be able to put their experiences into words well. AQA says adult participants described memories from throughout their lives. Children would have fewer memories to draw on.
So the method suits adults having surgery. It does not suit babies before birth or children in the early years.
- Describing, 4 marks: Early brain development: the weeks, months and sizes at birth, one year and age three. Answers on parts of the brain alone stay at Level 1.
- Discussing, 5 marks: Open surgery, consent, a developing cortex, an invasive method, children’s words and fewer memories. Only before birth, or only the early years, limits this part to Level 1.
How the credited points stand against the paper:
- Matches: The patients had surgery under local anaesthetic to treat epilepsy. The surgeon stimulated and asked what they felt.
- Not in the article: Consent, and brain scanning such as fMRI. These are points about using the method on children.
- Adults only? AQA speaks of adult participants. The article also describes a boy, R.W., and a girl of 16, J.V. It gives no age for R.W..
- “Throughout their lives”: This is AQA’s reading. The reports were experiences such as a piano, an orchestra and a mother’s voice, one from early childhood.
Practice Question 1: Apply Penfield’s Findings (4 marks)
Imagine a student writes: “Penfield proved that memories are stored in the temporal lobe like a video that stimulation replays.”
Question: Use Penfield’s study to explain why she may be wrong. [4 marks]
Model answer: Penfield said the record of the past is not laid down in the interpretive cortex. He said calling it the memory mechanism would be an unjustified assumption. Only a minority of patients re-lived a scene. In the article’s note it was 35 of 384 temporal lobe cases.
So the study does not show that memories are stored in the temporal lobe or that every patient had a replay.
- Mark scheme: 2 marks for knowledge, such as Penfield’s own caution or how few responded. 2 marks for applying it to the student’s claim.
Practice Question 2: Ethical Issues and Ways of Dealing with Them (4 marks)
AQA asks this kind of question about a study you design, not about Penfield by name.
Question: Name two ethical issues in a study like Penfield’s. Suggest one way of dealing with each. [4 marks]
Model answer: One issue is informed consent. The article does not describe consent. A way of dealing with it is to explain what patients will take part in and ask if they are happy to do so.
Another issue is confidentiality. The patients were named by initials, but unusual patients might be recognised. J.V. attended a meeting 21 years later where her case was discussed. A way of dealing with it is to leave names out of reports and use a number or a letter.
- Mark scheme: 2 marks for each issue and way: 1 for a relevant issue and 1 for an appropriate way of dealing with it.
- AQA marks: Each issue and way pair gets 2 for a clear and accurate answer and 1 for a limited or muddled one.
- Creditable issues, among others: Confidentiality, informed consent, parental consent, deception, the right to withdraw, protection from harm and debrief.
- Creditable ways, for example: No names, or a number or letter. Explain and ask if they are happy. Ask parents if under 16. Debrief.
Where Revision Notes and the Paper Differ
Some points credited by AQA, or repeated in revision notes, do not match the 1959 article exactly. Write what AQA credits if the question asks for it. Where you can, show you know what the paper says.
| You may see | What the 1959 article says | In an answer |
|---|---|---|
| In earlier research, visual cortex stimulation made people “see” colours, shadows and balloons. | Lights, colours and shadows with crude outlines. There are no balloons. | Colours and shadows match the paper. AQA’s scheme also credits balloons. |
| Vivid recall in under 5 per cent of participants. | About 9 per cent in 1959. In 1963, 40 of 1,132 patients: about 3.5 per cent (Penfield & Perot, 1963). | Give one figure and say what it is a percentage of. |
| Penfield’s later research did not support his earlier findings. Some notes add that only 7 per cent re-lived a scene. | In 1963, 40 of 520 temporal cases (7.7 per cent): same programme, not an independent repeat (Penfield & Perot, 1963). | AQA credits the point as printed but does not say which later research. Call the 1963 count a larger summary. |
| The interpretive cortex stores memories. | Penfield said the record is not laid down there. | AQA credits a strong temporal lobe role in memory. Add that Penfield did not say it stores them. |
Some notes say Penfield stimulated patients more than 1,000 times over 30 years. The article says more than 1,000 operations since 1936, which is 23 years. Most operations were not in the temporal lobe. So most gave no such responses.
AQA still credits a strong role for the temporal lobe in memories. The challenge to the replay reading, the idea that stimulation replays old memories like a recording, comes from other authors (Curot et al., 2017; Sjöberg, 2022). AQA’s later-research point is credited as printed.
Later Research
Curot et al. (2017) reviewed 80 years of reports of experiences evoked by brain stimulation. Most were poorly detailed. Only a few were episodic memories, memories of a particular event with a time and place.
Which kind appeared depended on the site stimulated. Only a summary of the paper has been read here.
The authors concluded that the findings do not support the idea of a highly stable, detailed memory. They also concluded that stimulation can activate memory in predictable ways (Curot et al., 2017).
In short, stimulation does bring up experiences of different kinds, mostly thin ones, not a detailed recording.
References
Curot, J., Busigny, T., Valton, L., Denuelle, M., Vignal, J.-P., Maillard, L., Chauvel, P., Pariente, J., Trebuchon, A., Bartolomei, F., & Barbeau, E. J. (2017). Memory scrutinized through electrical brain stimulation: A review of 80 years of experiential phenomena. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 78, 161–177. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2017.04.018
Penfield, W. (1959). The interpretive cortex. Science, 129(3365), 1719–1725. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.129.3365.1719
Penfield, W., & Perot, P. (1963). The brain’s record of auditory and visual experience: A final summary and discussion. Brain, 86(4), 595–696. https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/86.4.595
Sjöberg, R. L. (2022). Brain stimulation and elicited memories. Acta Neurochirurgica, 165(10), 2737–2745. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00701-022-05307-6