Bowlby’s 44 thieves study (1944) compared 44 children referred to a London clinic for stealing with 44 clinic children who did not steal. Bowlby found 14 thieves he called Affectionless Characters and none among the controls. Most of the 14 had been separated from their mothers early in life, which he linked to their stealing.
Key Takeaways
Aim
- To test whether early separation from the mother is linked to the Affectionless Character (a child lacking normal affection, shame or sense of responsibility) and to persistent stealing.
Method
- A retrospective case-note study: the histories were pieced together from what parents said after the problems began.
- The thieves were 44 children sent to a London clinic for stealing, aged about 5 to 16. The controls (a comparison group) were 44 clinic children who did not steal.
- A psychologist, a social worker and a psychiatrist assessed each child, and Bowlby decided the character type. Bowlby changed nothing.
- The predictor variable (what the groups were compared by) was thief or non-thief. The outcome variables (what was measured) were character type, amount of stealing and early separation.
Results
- 14 of the 44 thieves were Affectionless Characters, against none of the 44 controls. That gap is far too big to put down to chance (it is unlikely to be just luck).
- Two of the 14 had no early separation, so 12 of the 14 had. Wootton (1962) reports the figures from the second part of Bowlby’s paper and says this was much rarer among the controls.
- Most of the 14 were also serious, persistent thieves. These are links, not proof that separation caused the character.
Conclusion
- The Affectionless thieves were a distinct group, with a history of long separation from their mothers or foster-mothers.
- Bowlby saw it as a clear case of a bad early home life changing personality.
- He admitted that the sample was small and did not cover all child offending.
Strengths
- Control group: the 44 non-stealing clinic children let Bowlby see what was special to thieves, not just to disturbed children.
- Ecological validity (how far results reflect real life): the data came from real clinic cases.
- Validity (measuring what it claims to): three professionals saw each child and mothers were often interviewed for months, giving rich information.
- Real-world application: with James and Joyce Robertson, Bowlby’s work on separation fed into the Platt Report, which let parents visit children in hospital (Ministry of Health, 1959). That was the wider programme, not this study alone.
- Intelligence tested: most children were of average or above-average intelligence, so low intelligence is an unlikely main cause of the stealing in this sample.
Limitations
- Retrospective data: parents recalled the separations after the problems began, so memories may be wrong.
- Researcher bias: Bowlby judged each child’s character himself and knew what he was looking for, so his expectations may have shaped his decisions.
- Correlation (a link, not a cause): separation came with other problems such as rejection, so it cannot be shown to have caused the Affectionless Character.
- Contradictory research: in the exam you get marks for Lewis (1954), a large replication that did not find that separation predicted criminality, and for Rutter’s view that the effects were overstated.
- Deprivation and privation: as Rutter argued, Bowlby ran together losing a bond (deprivation) and never forming one (privation).
- Irreversibility: recovery is possible, as Koluchová’s twins show (a single case) and Romanian adoptees who spent under six months in institutions, who were largely free of lasting problems.
- Sensitive period: a sensitive period (a time when children are more open to change) fits the evidence better than a strict critical period.
- Multiple attachments: babies form several attachments, often including the father, not just one to the mother (Schaffer and Emerson, 1964).
- Link to the theory: in the exam, method points such as retrospective data only earn marks if you tie them back to maternal deprivation.
Ethical Issues
- Consent: the paper’s published account gives no sign of agreement from the children or parents, and permission to publish came from the clinic’s medical director. A way of dealing with it today: ask parents to agree.
- Confidentiality: the children are named by first name and surname initial, with intimate family detail. A way of dealing with it today: use codes instead of names.
- Welfare: many children received help, including psychotherapy, hostel placements and weekly work with their mothers.
- Labelling: saying such a child probably always steals could stigmatise children and mothers.
- Social sensitivity and economic implications: blaming mothers could stigmatise them, and in the exam you get marks for economic implications as a point on the theory.
Theory
- Maternal deprivation: the study is the usual evidence for this theory. Deprivation means long or accumulated separation from the mother figure.
- Critical period (a fixed window): the theory places it before about two and a half years, with risk up to five years.
- Harms: the theory links deprivation to delinquency, affectionless psychopathy, emotional problems and low IQ.
- Irreversibility: the theory says the damage from deprivation is permanent and cannot be undone.
- Continuity: the theory says the quality of early attachment predicts the quality of later relationships.
- Internal working model: continuity works through this mental template for relationships, which the child builds from early attachment.
Background
John Bowlby was a psychiatrist at the London Child Guidance Clinic. He asked why some children steal again and again. He argued that the roots of habitual stealing lie before puberty.
A large earlier survey, he said, lumped all kinds of delinquent together. That could hide patterns that show up when types are studied separately.
So he chose the opposite plan. He would study a small number of children intensively. He would sort them into types, then ask what home conditions each type shared.
Child psychology had recently stressed the child’s relation to the mother. Bowlby gave very great attention to it in every case. His enquiries also showed a remarkable proportion of children who had spent long periods away from home. Separation stood out.
The study is the usual evidence for Bowlby’s theory of maternal deprivation. Deprivation means long or accumulated separation from the mother figure.
The theory has a critical period, before about two and a half, with risk up to five years. It links deprivation to delinquency, affectionless psychopathy, emotional problems and low IQ.
It also says the damage is irreversible. The quality of early attachment predicts the quality of later relationships (continuity), through the child’s internal working model, a mental template for relationships.
Aim
Bowlby wanted to know what lies behind chronic stealing in children. His plan was to sort the thieves into character types and then study the home life of each type.
He looked in particular at the mother-child relationship, at separations from the mother and at traumas in childhood, such as bereavement and illness.
The paper states no formal hypothesis. The testable idea that runs through it is that prolonged early separation from the mother is linked to the Affectionless Character, and so to persistent stealing.
The aims can be put as three questions.
- Types: What kinds of child steal?
- Specificity: Is one character type found among thieves but not among other clinic children?
- Early Home Life: Does that type share a history of prolonged separation from the mother?
Bowlby set his own limits. The material allows conclusions about chronic delinquency in children of adequate intelligence. It does not allow conclusions about delinquency as a whole.
The sample is not typical of children who come before the courts.
Method
Design and Variables
The study is a retrospective case-note study with a control group.
Retrospective means the early histories were reconstructed from what parents and others reported at the clinic. They were not recorded as they happened.
A control group is a comparison group, here 44 children who did not steal. Bowlby’s own terms were clinical material, enquiry, control group and case conference.
No variable was manipulated, so the comparison is correlational. It looks for a link, not a cause. So the variables fit the names predictor and outcome better than independent and dependent. Bowlby used neither pair of terms.
- Predictor variable (the thing compared): the group, thief or non-thief. The groups arose from why the children were referred.
- Outcome variables (what was measured): character type, especially the Affectionless Character. Early separation from the mother or foster-mother. The degree of stealing, graded I to IV.
Participants
The thieves were 44 consecutive children referred to the London Child Guidance Clinic in 1936 to 1939. Stealing was a serious or passing symptom in each.
Referrals came from schools, parents, probation officers and courts. Only a minority had been charged in court (Bowlby, 1944a).
- Sex: 31 boys and 13 girls, against 34 boys and 10 girls among the controls.
- Age: About 5 to 16. Half were under 11, and only one child under 11 had been charged.
- Intelligence: 40 of the 44 took a revised Binet intelligence test. Average intelligence was above the population average. Bowlby rules out low intelligence as a cause of stealing here.
- Amount of stealing: Graded from Grade I, a single theft, to Grade IV, chronic and serious stealing. 23 of the 44 were Grade IV (22 at referral, 23 with one later case).
- Institutions: No child from an institution was included in either group.
The controls were 44 other clinic children who did not steal. Bowlby calls them an unselected series. Their ages and IQs fell between the upper and lower limits of the thieves’.
Children under five were excluded, as were two of very low ability.
The paper does not say the groups were matched child by child on age, IQ or sex.
The Clinic Assessment
Each child went through the clinic’s routine.
The child took mental tests. Meanwhile a social worker took a preliminary psychiatric history. The psychologist and social worker then reported to the psychiatrist, who interviewed the child and then the mother.
This two-hour examination by three people was followed by a case conference. The team pooled information and made a tentative diagnosis.
In a majority of cases there were many further interviews. The child had psychotherapy, and the mother talked with the social worker, often weekly for six months or more. Important facts, such as a mother’s mixed feelings, often emerged only after weeks.
Bowlby decided each child’s character type. He says the most valuable source was the description of the child by near relatives.
Probably the least valuable, though none the less essential, were the psychological and psychiatric examinations, because children are on their best behaviour in them.
He distrusted his own interview impressions. About half the children seemed fairly normal at interview, which he calls grossly misleading. When he found no positive signs of disorder, he ignored his interview. He relied on the mother’s and teacher’s reports and checked them against each other.
The Six Character Types
Bowlby sorted every child into one of six types. He calls it a rough and ready division, because no adequate classification of childhood character problems existed.
- Normal: fairly normal and stable.
- Depressed: unstable and in a more or less depressed state of mind.
- Circular: unstable, swinging between depression and over-activity.
- Hyperthymic (over-active): constantly over-active, boastful and defiant of authority.
- Affectionless: lacking normal affection, shame or sense of responsibility.
- Schizoid: showing marked schizoid or schizophrenic symptoms.
The 14 Affectionless thieves had apparently never since infancy shown normal affection to anyone. They were solitary, undemonstrative and unresponsive.
They responded neither to kindness nor to punishment. Most truanted and wandered, probably lied more frequently than other thieves and stole alone.
Bowlby’s test for telling them from Hyperthymic children was personal relationships. The Hyperthymic child has real attachments to home. The Affectionless Character is capable of neither attachment, affection nor loyalty.
Results
Character Types in Thieves and Controls
Bowlby counted the character types in both groups.
- Affectionless: 14 thieves, 0 controls.
- Hyperthymic: 13 thieves, 10 controls.
- Depressed: 9 thieves, 13 controls.
- Schizoid and schizophrenic: 4 thieves, 9 controls.
- Emotionally normal: 2 thieves, 3 controls.
- Circular: 2 thieves, 1 control.
- Priggish, with anxiety or hysteria: 0 thieves, 8 controls.
Bowlby calls the absence of Affectionless Characters among the controls the one outstanding difference. That is the key result.
He compared 14 of the 44 thieves with none of the 44 controls. That is far too big to be chance, so it is unlikely to be just luck.
He concluded that the link between the Affectionless Character and stealing was demonstrated. This shows an association. It cannot show that separation caused the character.
The controls had more depressed children. They also had eight of a type not found among the thieves, a good, over-conscientious “priggish” child who had developed a symptom such as a stammer or a phobia. Only two of the 44 thieves were judged normal.
Affectionless Characters and the Amount of Stealing
13 of the 14 Affectionless thieves (93 per cent) were in Grade IV, the chronic and serious stealers. Among the other 30 thieves, 10 were (33 per cent).
This gap is also too big to put down to chance.
So the Affectionless Character and serious stealing are associated. That does not show what caused either.
Affectionless children made up 13 of the 23 Grade IV offenders, more than half. Bowlby concluded that such children almost invariably steal. He said they typically do so seriously and persistently.
Early Separation
Bowlby gave full case histories of all 14 Affectionless thieves. With very few exceptions, he says, they had suffered the complete emotional loss of their mother or foster-mother in infancy and early childhood.
Two had no history of early separation, so 12 of the 14 had been separated.
The cases were very mixed. They included hospital stays, bereavement, foster care, adoption, illegitimacy and a mother in a tuberculosis sanatorium. In several, other adversity sat alongside the separation, such as a father who disliked the child or a rejecting mother.
The original table is in Bowlby’s second paper (Bowlby, 1944b). The figures below are Wootton’s (1962, p. 68) report of it.
Follan and Minnis (2010) counted the cases again and found the same split: 12 of the 14 Affectionless thieves against 7 of the other 74 children.
| Group | Early or prolonged separation in the first five years | Share |
|---|---|---|
| All 44 thieves | 17 of 44 | 39% |
| The 14 Affectionless thieves | 12 of 14 | about 86% |
| The other 30 thieves | 5 of 30 | about 17% |
| The 44 controls | 2 of 44 | about 5% |
Early separation was far more common among the Affectionless thieves than in either comparison group.
Conclusion
Bowlby drew these conclusions:
- A Distinct Group: The Affectionless thieves form a distinct clinical syndrome with a distinctive early history of prolonged separations. Bowlby called it a clear case of a bad early environment distorting personality.
- Essentially Delinquent: The Affectionless Character probably always steals and usually becomes a recidivist, someone who keeps reoffending. Bowlby thought such children form the hard core of recidivism.
- Many Kinds of Thief: Many different kinds of child steal, so mixing them all together hides the causes.
- Feelings Inhibited, Not Absent: Bowlby argued that moral feelings in children labelled morally deficient are usually present but severely inhibited. He said psychopathic personality covers too wide a field.
Bowlby also set out his own hedges.
- Delinquency as a Whole: The material does not allow conclusions about it.
- Small Sample: The work needs repeating on several more carefully selected groups of 50 to 100 cases.
- Depression: The link between the Affectionless Character and early chronic depression is “somewhat speculative”.
- Tentative Diagnoses: Some children lie on the border between types. One Affectionless child might equally be schizoid.
What Revision Notes Often Get Wrong
Some revision notes state the study more strongly than the paper supports. Check these points before you use them.
- “Teenage delinquents”: The children were about 5 to 16, half were under 11, and only a minority had been in court.
- “Separation in the first two years”: The case histories give no fixed window. Wootton (1962, from a conference report) says the summing-up concerned six months or more in the first five years.
- “Matched control group”: The paper does not say the groups were matched child by child. Ages and IQs fell between the thieves’ limits, but the two youngest age bands differ.
- “Affectionless psychopathy”: The paper says Affectionless Character and argues against the label psychopathic personality. It defines the 14 as lacking normal affection, shame or responsibility. “Inability to feel guilt” is not its wording.
- “Bowlby interviewed each child and rated them”: He set aside his own interview where it showed nothing and relied on the mother’s and teacher’s reports.
- “All 14 had been separated”: Two had not.
- “Over half the thieves had been separated”: The figure Wootton (1962) reports is 17 of 44 (39 per cent), not over half.
Strengths
The study has eight main strengths:
- A Comparison Group: The controls were also disturbed children from the same clinic. So the study lets us distinguish what is specific to thieves from what is common to all maladjusted children.
- Multi-Source Assessment: Three professionals saw each child and mothers were often interviewed for months. This gives rich real-world data, so ecological validity (how well results reflect real life) is high.
- Consecutive, Mostly Chronic Cases: Taking 44 consecutive referrals avoids cherry-picking. Mostly habitual thieves avoids diluting the findings with casual offenders.
- Testing the Pattern: Bowlby compared the groups with numbers, which Ainsworth (1962) calls more systematic than earlier work. The Affectionless Character was strongly tied to serious stealing.
- Candour About Limits: Bowlby admits the sample is untypical of court delinquents. He also says economic status was not investigated and that a third control group of ordinary school children would help.
- A Productive Idea: Dixon (2003), in her abstract, calls it Bowlby’s first empirical study and says it ushered in his attachment theory. It gave a testable claim.
- Intelligence Checked: The children’s intelligence was tested. Most were of average or above-average intelligence, so low intelligence is an unlikely main cause of the stealing in this sample.
- Lasting Influence: The study launched Bowlby’s maternal deprivation hypothesis. His wider work with James and Joyce Robertson, not this study alone, fed into the Platt Report (Ministry of Health, 1959).
Limitations
The main limitations are:
- Retrospective Data: Separation histories came from memory and the parents’ account.
- Researcher Bias and Subjective Types: Bowlby’s expectations could shape his own diagnoses, and no blinding is described.
- A Small, Untypical Sample: Only 14 children were Affectionless, all from one London clinic.
- Controls Not Matched or Ordinary: The groups differ in age and sex, and the controls were disturbed too.
- Correlation, Not Cause: Separation came with other adversity.
- Separation Covers Many Experiences: Deprivation and privation are run together.
- Later Evidence Disagrees: A follow-up and a large replication did not find the same.
- Irreversibility Is Not Supported: Later cases show that recovery is possible, so the damage is not always permanent.
- One Main Carer Is Too Narrow: Infants form several attachments, not only one to the mother.
Retrospective Data
Bowlby obtained separation histories from parents and carers after the problems had appeared. They rest on memory. They also rest on the parent’s account.
Bowlby himself describes one episode he uncovered. It had happened over three years before. Several case histories note that the mother was a bad witness or that information was thin.
So the evidence is only as good as the memories behind it.
A prospective study avoids this problem by following children forward in time. Hodges and Tizard’s study is an example.
Researcher Bias and Subjective Types
Bowlby made the character diagnoses himself. He was looking for the early factors he thought important. The paper does not describe anyone judging character blind, without knowing the child’s history or group. That is a risk of researcher bias. Expectation shapes what is recorded.
Bowlby says that “if these factors are not looked for they are not found”. That defends expert observers, but it also shows the observer’s expectation.
His diagnoses leaned on the mother’s and teacher’s reports. The same mothers gave the separation history. So the two measures could have contaminated each other.
The character types were also his own rough and ready division. He accepts that some children lie between types.
A Small, Untypical Sample
Only 14 children were Affectionless. All came from one London clinic in 1936 to 1939. Of the 44 thieves, eleven were too young to be charged, boys outnumbered girls by more than two to one, and intelligence was above average. No institutional children were included.
Bowlby says the group is not typical of delinquents who come before the courts. Generalisation, applying the results beyond the sample, is therefore limited.
Controls Not Matched or Ordinary
The paper says the controls’ ages and IQs fell between the thieves’ limits. Bowlby says the age distributions were similar except in the two youngest bands. The groups were not the same.
The youngest band, aged 5 to 6, had 3 thieves and 11 controls. In the next band thieves outnumbered controls 12 to 6.
The paper does not say they were matched child by child. The sex ratios also differ.
The controls were also disturbed clinic children, not ordinary ones. Bowlby wanted a third group of ordinary school children.
So a difference between the groups could partly reflect age or sex rather than stealing.
Correlation, Not Cause
There was no manipulation, so the study shows a link, not a cause. In the case histories separation sits alongside other adversity. Examples are an unwanted child, a rejecting parent, a drinking guardian or a psychotic father.
Those factors cannot be separated from the effect of separation. Ainsworth (1962) warns that case studies like this can drift into assuming that because affectionless children had been separated, separation produces affectionlessness.
Wootton (1962) also called Bowlby’s test for a hereditary factor too confident.
Separation Covers Many Experiences
The separated children had been in hospital, bereaved, fostered, adopted, left with relatives or taken into care. Bowlby counts them together.
Ainsworth (1962) argues the antecedent was really separation with deprivation of sufficient care, or repeated changes of mother-figure. As Rutter (1981) argued, Bowlby ran together deprivation (losing an existing bond) and privation (never forming one).
Some cases fit privation better, such as the child rejected at ten days or the child with “at least four mothers”. A bond may never have formed.
Later Evidence Disagrees
Bowlby and colleagues later followed up children separated from their mothers in a tuberculosis sanatorium. They are reported to have found no excess of affectionless psychopathy and to have conceded that earlier claims were overstated (Bowlby et al., 1956). That cuts against the theory.
In the exam you get marks for Lewis (1954), a large-sample replication. It did not find that separation from the mother predicted criminality or difficulty forming close relationships.
You also get marks for Rutter’s view that the effects of deprivation were overstated.
Irreversibility Is Not Supported
Bowlby’s hypothesis is often read as claiming permanent damage. The Koluchová twins were kept confined and largely isolated from about 18 months to about seven years. By early adolescence they had reached broadly average intelligence (Koluchová, 1976).
A 22-year follow-up found both men in skilled jobs, married, with no psychiatric abnormality (Koluchová, 1991).
This is a single case with no control group. It shows that recovery can happen. It does not show how often.
Recovery has limits. In the English and Romanian Adoptees study, children in institutions for under six months were largely free of lasting problems. Those there for over six months showed raised rates of autistic-like features, disinhibited social engagement and inattention as young adults (Sonuga-Barke et al., 2017). Timing mattered.
A sensitive period, a time when children are most open to change, fits these results better than a strict critical period. The critical period in the theory ends at about two and a half, with risk up to five years.
One Main Carer Is Too Narrow
Bowlby’s theory stressed a single bond with the mother, called monotropy. Schaffer and Emerson (1964) found that multiple attachments were the rule. The father was often a primary or joint-primary attachment figure.
Those findings challenge the emphasis on the mother alone.
Weighing the Evidence
The study is a good source of an idea and a poor source of proof. It shows that in a clinic sample the Affectionless Character was confined to thieves and was linked to early separation in 12 of 14 cases.
It cannot show that separation caused the character. Its clinical judgements were made by the man who proposed the theory.
For an A-level answer, it illustrates maternal deprivation. It also gives a ready example of a method weakness tied to the theory, as the 2023 mark scheme requires.
In an application question, link the child’s care history to the theory. In the exam you get marks for spotting disruption of attachment. That means a long separation or several carers. You also get marks for naming effects: reduced IQ, emotional problems, delinquency and affectionless psychopathy.
Ethical Issues
The paper’s published account gives little explicit ethics discussion.
- Consent: The published account gives no sign of informed consent from the children or parents. Permission to publish came from the clinic’s medical director.
- Confidentiality: The children are named by first name and surname initial, with age. The case histories give intimate family detail. People who knew them could probably recognise the children.
- Welfare: Many children received help, including psychotherapy, hostel placements and weekly work with their mothers. Mothers’ talk with the clinic was also where Bowlby found unadmitted rejection that he then published.
- Labelling: Bowlby says such a child probably always steals. That could stigmatise children and mothers. AQA credits social sensitivity and economic implications as points on the theory.
The paper predates modern ethical codes on consent and confidentiality. Judging it by today’s standards is anachronistic, but these are points a student could raise.
A way of dealing with these issues today would be asking parents to agree and using codes instead of names.
Later Research
A Revisit of the Case Series (Follan and Minnis, 2010)
Follan and Minnis (2010) went back to the published series. They compared the 14 Affectionless children with the other 74 cases Bowlby described, the other 30 thieves and the 44 controls.
Of the 14 Affectionless children, 12 (86 per cent) had early, prolonged separation from their main carer. Among the other 74, 7 (about 9 per cent) had. That gap is far too big to put down to chance.
Every separated Affectionless child also had several moves or other hardship during the separation, such as no visits in hospital.
The authors suggest Bowlby saw separation as the main cause. They say maltreatment is the likelier main factor, in his cases and in a modern sample of children with reactive attachment disorder. Re-reading the case histories, they think these children were probably maltreated before, during or after their separations.
A Modern Study of Callous-Unemotional Traits (Humphreys et al., 2015)
Humphreys et al. (2015) is a Bucharest Early Intervention Project paper that lists Bowlby’s 1944 paper among its references. This block is from the abstract only.
- Aim: To examine callous-unemotional (CU) traits, a developmental precursor to psychopathy, in 12-year-olds exposed to severe early deprivation. It also tested whether high-quality foster care reduced them.
- Method: A randomised controlled trial. Institutionalised Bucharest children were assigned to foster care (n = 68) or care as usual (n = 68). CU traits were assessed at 12.75 years in 95 of the trial children and 50 never-institutionalised children.
- Findings: Children raised in institutions had higher CU traits than never-institutionalised children. Among boys, the foster-care group had lower CU traits than care as usual. Caregiver responsiveness to distress, but not warmth, mediated the effect.
- Conclusion: The authors present this as the first evidence that psychosocial intervention can prevent CU traits. They say responsive foster care reduced the impact of severe early deprivation for boys.
- Evaluation: Random assignment tests whether better care changes the outcome, which the 44 thieves study could not. It does not test separation from an existing bond. The effect is reported for boys only.
References
Ainsworth, M. D. (1962). The effects of maternal deprivation: A review of findings and controversy in the context of research strategy. In Deprivation of maternal care: A reassessment of its effects (Public Health Papers No. 14, pp. 97-165). World Health Organization.
Bowlby, J. (1944a). Forty-four juvenile thieves: Their characters and home-life. The International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 25, 19–53.
Bowlby, J. (1944b). Forty-four juvenile thieves: Their characters and home-life (II). The International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 25, 107–128.
Bowlby, J., Ainsworth, M., Boston, M., & Rosenbluth, D. (1956). The effects of mother-child separation: A follow-up study. British Journal of Medical Psychology, 29(3-4), 211-247. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8341.1956.tb00915.x
Dixon, A. (2003). ‘At all costs let us avoid any risk of allowing our hearts to be broken again’: A review of John Bowlby’s Forty-four juvenile thieves. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 8(2), 278-289. https://doi.org/10.1177/1359104503008002011
Follan, M., & Minnis, H. (2010). Forty-four juvenile thieves revisited: From Bowlby to reactive attachment disorder. Child: Care, Health and Development, 36(5), 639-645. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2214.2009.01048.x
Humphreys, K. L., McGoron, L., Sheridan, M. A., McLaughlin, K. A., Fox, N. A., Nelson, C. A., & Zeanah, C. H. (2015). High-quality foster care mitigates callous-unemotional traits following early deprivation in boys: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 54(12), 977-983. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaac.2015.09.010
Koluchová, J. (1976). The further development of twins after severe and prolonged deprivation: A second report. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 17(3), 181-188. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7610.1976.tb00390.x
Koluchová, J. (1991). Severely deprived twins after 22 years’ observation. Studia Psychologica, 33(1), 23–28.
Lewis, H. (1954). Deprived children: The Mersham experiment, a social and clinical study. Oxford University Press.
Ministry of Health. (1959). The welfare of children in hospital (Platt Report). Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.
Rutter, M. (1981). Maternal deprivation reassessed (2nd ed.). Penguin.
Schaffer, H. R., & Emerson, P. E. (1964). The development of social attachments in infancy. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 29(3), 1–77. https://doi.org/10.2307/1165727
Sonuga-Barke, E. J. S., Kennedy, M., Kumsta, R., Knights, N., Golm, D., Rutter, M., Maughan, B., Schlotz, W., & Kreppner, J. (2017). Child-to-adult neurodevelopmental and mental health trajectories after early life deprivation: The young adult follow-up of the longitudinal English and Romanian Adoptees study. The Lancet, 389(10078), 1539–1548. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(17)30045-4
Wootton, B. (1962). A social scientist’s approach to maternal deprivation. In Deprivation of maternal care: A reassessment of its effects (Public Health Papers No. 14, pp. 63-73). World Health Organization.