Piaget (1952) Conservation of Number Study

Piaget’s conservation of number study (1952) tested whether children know that a number stays the same when its appearance changes. Children saw two equal rows of counters, and one row was spread out. Younger children said the longer row had more. Many older children said the numbers were the same, and could say why.

Key Takeaways

Aim

  • To show that concrete operational children (about 7 to 11) are more likely than pre-operational children (about 2 to 7) to conserve number. This means knowing the number stays the same when it looks different.

Method

  • A natural experiment (the researcher cannot change age) and a cross-sectional study (different ages compared at one time), with an independent measures design (different children in each group).
  • The sample was a small group of school children in Geneva, Switzerland. It included Piaget’s own three children.
  • A child saw two equal rows of counters, lined up one to one. The child was asked, “Is there the same number of counters in each row?”
  • One row was spread out or squashed, with nothing added or taken away. The child was asked the same question again.
  • The independent variable (what differs) was age. The dependent variable (what is measured) was whether the child said the number was unchanged.

Results

  • Children aged 3 to 4 typically said the longer row had more.
  • Some late pre-operational children, aged 5 to 6, said the rows were the same, but rarely gave a reason.
  • Many concrete operational children (about 7 to 11), especially the older ones, said the rows were the same and gave logical reasons.

Conclusion

  • Concrete operational children are more likely than pre-operational children to conserve number.

Strengths

  • Simple task: counters are easy for young children to understand, and the task is easy to repeat.
  • Repeatable: other researchers repeated it with changes, which showed where its weaknesses were.
  • Age comparison: younger children failed and older children passed, which fits the idea of stages.
  • Children’s reasons: the study recorded why older children thought the number stayed the same.

Limitations

  • Repeated question: asking the same question twice may make a child think the first answer was wrong, so the child changes it.
  • Ecological validity (how well results fit real life): spreading counters for an adult is not a real-life task. In a later study, more children got it right when the change looked accidental.
  • Population validity (how well results fit a wider group): the sample was small and from one place, so the results may not apply to other children or cultures.
  • Cross-sectional design: different children were compared at each age, so differences may not be due to age.
  • Construct validity (whether a test measures what it claims to): saying “the same” is a narrow measure of conservation.

Ethical Issues

  • Informed consent (agreeing after being told what will happen): young children cannot give it. A sensible way of dealing with it: ask their parents.
  • Piaget’s own children took part, so they may not have felt able to refuse. A sensible way of dealing with it: the right to withdraw (stopping at any time).
  • Debriefing (explaining the study afterwards): none is reported. A sensible way of dealing with it: explain the task to the children afterwards.

Exam Use

  • In the exam you get marks for both the procedure and the findings. A description with no findings cannot get full marks.
  • In the exam you get marks for criticisms linked to the study. “Demand characteristics” (clues that tell people what a study wants) alone is not enough. Explain that the child expected a repeated question to mean the first answer was wrong.
Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Background

Conservation means understanding that something stays the same, even when it looks different. A row of coins has the same number whether the coins are bunched up or spread out.

Piaget’s theory says children go through stages. Children in the pre-operational stage, aged about 2 to 7, are heavily influenced by how things look. So most cannot conserve, though some late pre-operational children begin to.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Children in the concrete operational stage, aged about 7 to 11, develop the ability to conserve.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Piaget was a French-speaking Swiss psychologist. He designed many conservation tasks, including tests of conservation of number.

They are in his book The Child’s Conception of Number, which was translated into English in 1952. This study describes one of those tests.

Aim

The aim was to show that children in the concrete operational stage are more likely to be able to conserve number than children in the pre-operational stage.

A hypothesis is a prediction that a study can test. The hypothesis was that children in the concrete operational stage will be able to conserve number, whereas children in the pre-operational stage will not.

Method

Design and Variables

Piaget (1952) ran what is called a natural experiment. The independent variable, age, occurs naturally, so the researcher cannot change it.

It is also a cross-sectional study. This compares different children of different ages at one time. So it has an independent measures design: different children in each age group.

  • Independent variable: the age, or stage, of the children. This is the thing that differs between the groups.
  • Dependent variable: whether the child could conserve number. This means whether the child said the number of counters was unchanged.

In the exam you get marks for saying what was controlled, such as the procedure and the questions asked. How strictly the questions were kept the same is not known.

Sample

The sample was a small group of school children from Geneva, Switzerland. They were of different ages. They included Piaget’s own three children.

OCR says the sample was small. The number of children is not given.

Materials

The only materials were counters.

Procedure

conservation of number
  1. The child was shown two rows of counters of equal length, side by side. The counters were matched one to one, so that each counter faced one in the other row.
  2. The child was asked, “Is there the same number of counters in each row?”
  3. One row was spread out, so that it looked longer. Or it was squashed, so that it looked shorter. No counters were added or taken away.
  4. The child was asked the same question again: “Is there the same number of counters in each row?”

Results

The study gave three main findings.

  • Children aged 3 to 4: they typically said that the longer row had more counters.
  • Late pre-operational children, aged 5 to 6: some said correctly that both rows had the same number, before and after. But they were rarely able to give a good reason.
  • Concrete operational children: many, especially the older ones, said that both rows had the same number before and after. They could give logical reasons.

The main finding is that older children were more likely to say that the number in the row had not changed.

No counts or percentages are given for these findings. In the exam, describe what children typically said, using words such as “many” and “some”.

Conclusion

Children in the concrete operational stage (about 7 to 11) are more likely to conserve number. Pre-operational children (about 2 to 7) are less likely to.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Link to Piaget’s Theory

In the exam, this is the research study for Piaget’s theory of cognitive development.

The theory says children are “little scientists”. They learn by exploring the world. They go through four stages because they interact with the world and because their brains mature.

The stages come at fixed ages, so all children go through them.

  • Four stages: sensori-motor (birth to 2), pre-operational (2 to 7), concrete operational (7 to 11) and formal operational (11 to adult).
  • Pre-operational children: they are egocentric, which means finding it hard to see another person’s view. They also find it hard to think backwards, such as pushing a spread-out row back together.
  • Concrete operational children: they can decentre, which means taking in more than one feature at once, such as how tall and how thin. They can conserve.

The study supports the theory. It found that concrete operational children are more likely to conserve number than pre-operational children.

The theory has a named criticism. It is too reductionist, which means it explains development by one simple cause, biological maturation. It ignores a more holistic view, which looks at the whole picture. Teachers, parents, friends and culture also help development.

Strengths

  • A simple, concrete task: the child handles real objects, not only words. Counters are easy for young children to understand.
  • Repeatable: the task needs only counters, so other researchers repeated it with changes. This is how its weaknesses were found.
  • An age comparison fits the stage idea: younger children failed and older children passed. This fits the theory that stages come in a fixed order.
  • Children’s reasons: the findings include the reasons older children gave. This shows how they were thinking, which a yes or no answer does not.
More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Limitations

  • The repeated question: asking the same question twice may make a child think the first answer was wrong, so the child changes it.
  • Ecological validity: spreading counters on a table for an adult is not a real-life task. When the change looked accidental, more children got it right.
  • Population validity and cultural bias: how well results apply to a wider group. The sample was small and from one culture, Geneva, so the results may not apply to others.
  • Cross-sectional design: different children were compared at each age, and none was followed over time. So the study cannot show one child moving from one stage to the next.
  • Construct validity: a child saying “the same” is a narrow measure of conservation. The answer may depend on what the child thinks “same” or “more” means.

The Repeated Question

Piaget’s task asks the same question before and after one row is spread out. A child who is asked twice by an adult may think the first answer was wrong. So the child changes it.

Samuel and Bryant (1984) tested this. They compared the usual two questions with asking only one question, after the change. The children were 252 aged 5 to 8 and a half. They made fewer mistakes on the number task with one question, at every age.

In the exam, explain this problem in words. OCR’s Guide calls it demand characteristics, meaning clues that tell people what a study wants, but examiners want it explained.

The youngest children probably did not guess the aim and pretend. Instead, a child may think: “The adult asked again, so my first answer must have been wrong.” So the child changes the answer.

An Artificial Task: Ecological Validity

Ecological validity means how well the results fit real life. Children do not usually see counters spread out on a table, or get asked about them by an adult.

McGarrigle and Donaldson (1974) used a “naughty teddy” that messed up one row of counters by accident. Of 80 children aged about 4 to 6, 50 conserved when the teddy did it.

Only 13 conserved when the experimenter did it on purpose.

A Small Sample from One Place

A sample point needs a reason to count. The sample was small, so you cannot be sure it represents all children. The children were from Geneva. So the results may not apply to other cultures.

The size of the sample is not even given, so it cannot be checked.

The sample also included the researcher’s own children, who may have known his methods.

Ethical Issues

The account of the study says nothing about ethics. You can still discuss the kind of procedure it was. Each issue has a way of dealing with it.

  • Informed consent: agreeing after being told what will happen. Young children cannot give it themselves. A sensible way of dealing with it: ask their parents.
  • The researcher’s own children: Piaget’s children took part and may not have felt able to refuse. A sensible way of dealing with it: the right to withdraw, so children can stop at any time.
  • Deception and debriefing: the questions were honest, so deception was not a big issue. No explanation afterwards is reported. A sensible way of dealing with it: debriefing, a full explanation at the end.
  • Protection from psychological harm: the task, counting counters, is harmless.

Exam Questions

What the Exam Asks

Answers must be tied to the study. Points that could be about any study score little. The practice questions below are examples, not the exam board’s own wording.

  • Describe the study (5 marks): marked by levels. You need both procedure and findings. Credit goes to the method, the sample, the two variables, the controls, the main finding and the conclusion.
  • Evaluate the study (5 marks): marked by levels for breadth and depth. Credited points: culturally biased sample, small sample, artificial set-up, narrow measure, same question twice, cross-sectional design.
  • Common slips on describe questions: some students described a different Piaget study, such as conservation of volume. Others gave no findings. The same detail cannot be credited twice.
  • Common slips on evaluate questions: the best answers gave two or three criticisms explained in the context of the study. Generic points scored less. Explain why the repeated question is a problem.
  • Questions on the theory: these ask how Piaget’s ideas are used in education, or why the theory may be reductionist or not generalisable. On the generalisability question, points about the study’s sample earn nothing.

Practice Question 1: Describe the Study (5 marks)

Question: Describe Piaget’s study of the conservation of number. [5 marks]

Model answer: Piaget’s study was a natural experiment. The independent variable was the age of the children, and the dependent variable was whether they said the number of counters had changed.

The sample was a small group of Swiss school children of different ages, from Geneva. The only materials were counters.

A child saw two equal rows of counters, matched one to one. The child said whether each row had the same number. Then one row was spread out. Nothing was added. The child was asked again.

Children aged 3 to 4 typically said the longer row had more. Many concrete operational children said the rows were the same, and gave logical reasons. Piaget concluded that concrete operational children are more likely to conserve number than pre-operational children.

  • Example marking guide: this is an example answer. The exam uses levels. The top level (5 marks) needs a clear, accurate procedure and findings.
  • Credited points: experiment, Swiss children, independent variable (stage), dependent variable (number unchanged or not), counters, the question asked twice, findings and conclusion.

Practice Question 2: Evaluate the Study (5 marks)

Question: Evaluate Piaget’s study of the conservation of number. [5 marks]

Model answer: One criticism is the repeated question. The child was asked the same question before and after one row was spread out. A child may think the first answer was wrong because an adult asked again, and so change it.

A second criticism is ecological validity. Spreading counters on a table is not a real-life task. In a later study, more children got it right when a naughty teddy changed the counters by accident.

A third criticism is the sample. It was small and from Geneva, so the results may not apply to children in other cultures.

  • Example marking guide: this is an example answer. The exam uses levels. The top level (5 marks) has relevant criticisms with breadth and depth, each tied to the study.
  • Creditable criticisms: culturally biased sample, small sample, artificial set-up, narrow measure of conservation (construct validity), the repeated question, and a cross-sectional design.

Practice Question 3: The Theory (2 marks)

Question: Explain why Piaget’s theory could be considered reductionist. [2 marks]

Model answer: The theory explains development as biological maturation, so all children automatically go through the same stages. It ignores other factors, such as teachers, parents, friends and culture.

  • Example marking guide: this is an example, not an official scheme. Credit saying the theory reduces development to one factor, maturation, and credit what it ignores.

The 13-Mark Question

A recent 13-mark question gave a statement about bias. Students had to use Piaget’s study and at least one other study from a different area of psychology.

The describe part gave 3 marks for each study. One study alone was capped at the lowest level. The second study could not be one from the same topic. A strong answer paired Piaget with a study from a different topic.

The evaluation part credited bias in gender, culture, age, the experimenter, the observer and the questions asked. The mark scheme says Piaget’s study has no age bias. It compares ages on purpose.

Many students left out the second study. Others wrote only about bias. Both lost marks.

Other themes that fit this study include generalisability, validity, the artificiality of experiments, and nature and nurture.

Later Research

Later studies repeated Piaget’s task with changes.

  • Samuel and Bryant (1984): five-year-olds still made more mistakes than older children, even with one question. So asking once did not remove the age difference. This supports Piaget’s pattern as well as the criticism.
  • McGarrigle and Donaldson (1974): they tested 80 children. They suggested that the usual task underestimates what children know, because how a child reads the experimenter’s actions changes how they understand the question.
  • Viarouge, Houde and Borst (2019): 6-year-olds saw two rows of dots on a screen. They were less likely to say the rows matched as the spacing grew. The authors suggest conservation develops gradually.
  • Lozada and Carro (2016): 105 first-graders aged 6 to 7 took part. Some moved the material themselves. Others watched an adult. The first group more often saw that the quantity stayed the same.
More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

References

Lozada, M., & Carro, N. (2016). Embodied action improves cognition in children: Evidence from a study based on Piagetian conservation tasks. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, Article 393. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00393

McGarrigle, J., & Donaldson, M. (1974). Conservation accidents. Cognition, 3(4), 341-350. https://doi.org/10.1016/0010-0277(74)90003-1

Piaget, J. (1952). The child’s conception of number. Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Samuel, J., & Bryant, P. (1984). Asking only one question in the conservation experiment. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 25(2), 315-318. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7610.1984.tb00152.x

Viarouge, A., Houde, O., & Borst, G. (2019). The progressive 6-year-old conserver: Numerical saliency and sensitivity as core mechanisms of numerical abstraction in a Piaget-like estimation task. Cognition, 190, 137-142. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2019.05.005

Olivia Guy-Evans, MSc

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MSc Psychology of Education

Associate Editor for Simply Psychology

Olivia Guy-Evans is a writer and associate editor for Simply Psychology, where she contributes accessible content on psychological topics. She is also an autistic PhD student at the University of Birmingham, researching autistic camouflaging in higher education.


Saul McLeod, PhD

Chartered Psychologist (CPsychol)

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MRes, PhD, University of Manchester

Saul McLeod, PhD, is a qualified psychology teacher with over 18 years of experience in further and higher education. He has been published in peer-reviewed journals, including the Journal of Clinical Psychology.