Rollo May: Existential Psychology

Rollo May was an American psychologist who helped found humanistic psychology and brought existential philosophy into it. He argued that anxiety is part of being human, not only a symptom to remove. Faced honestly, it can drive growth and creativity. Avoided or numbed, it narrows a person’s life. He wrote books on love, will and creativity.

Key Takeaways

  • Who He Was: A co-founder of humanistic psychology, which studies the whole person. He added existential thought: what it means to exist, choose and die (May, 1983).
  • Anxiety: For May, anxiety is the experience of the threat of not existing (May, 1983). Growing and creating bring it too, because new possibilities shake a person’s world (May, 1975).
  • Normal and Neurotic: Normal anxiety should be tolerated and used constructively. Neurotic anxiety is what normal anxiety becomes when it is not faced (May, 1983).
  • Courage and Creativity: Creativity is the encounter of an intensely conscious person with their world. It takes courage, the capacity to move ahead in spite of despair (May, 1975).
  • The Daimonic: May used the word, without defining it, for strong passions such as love (May, 1975). In Love and Will it covers aggression, anxiety and guilt (May, 1969).
  • Therapy: In The Discovery of Being he states the aim of therapy as helping patients experience their existence as real, not merely adjust (May, 1983).
  • Criticism: His main ideas rest on clinical observation, philosophy and literary reading, not controlled tests. Related therapies show only modest support (Vos et al., 2015).
Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

How Did Rollo May Explain Anxiety?

May’s central idea is about anxiety. He argued it is not only a symptom to remove. It is part of being human, and what matters is what a person does with it.

Anxiety as Part of Being Human

May set out the idea in The Meaning of Anxiety (May, 1950), from his doctoral research. In The Discovery of Being he defined anxiety as “the experience of the threat of imminent nonbeing” (May, 1983).

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Being, for May, is a person’s pattern of potentialities: what they could become, as an acorn could become an oak. Non-being is the possibility of not existing at all. Death is its plainest form (May, 1983).

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

So anxiety is not an emotion that comes and goes. It is a state of existence, not something a person has but something they are. This is what ontological means here (May, 1983).

Anxiety also differs from fear in kind, not only in degree. A snub from someone a person respects is milder than a dentist’s drill. Yet it can torment them all day, because it strikes at their sense of being a valued self (May, 1983).

Why Growing and Creating Bring Anxiety

May also explained why the pull toward one’s potential should feel anxious. The threat of not existing is not only about death.

A new possibility also threatens the person one is now, because realising it would destroy their present security. That tempts people to deny it. Anxiety therefore always involves an inner conflict between being and non-being (May, 1983).

For May, creating is an encounter: an intensely conscious person meeting their world. His reasoning has three parts, drawn from two chapters of The Courage to Create (May, 1975).

First, self and world are correlated. When the world is no longer as it was, the person is no longer what they were (May, 1975).

Second, a creative encounter shakes that relation. The anxiety felt is temporary rootlessness and disorientation, which he calls the anxiety of nothingness (May, 1975).

Third, a new idea has to destroy something, such as the thinker’s own earlier hypothesis. That destruction is the source of guilt. The loss of footing is the source of anxiety (May, 1975).

Normal and Neurotic Anxiety

May names two kinds: normal and neurotic anxiety.

Normal anxiety belongs to the threat of non-being that every person faces. It has to be accepted: tolerated without repression (pushing it out of awareness) and used constructively where possible. Neurotic anxiety develops because the person could not accept the normal kind (May, 1983).

Freedom is at stake. The existential philosopher Kierkegaard called anxiety the dizziness of freedom, and people give up freedom to escape unbearable anxiety. A person who runs from every situation that might arouse anxiety, hostility or aggression ends with a thin, unreal sense of being (May, 1983).

May’s conclusion: therapy should help people face and use anxiety. Numbing it with addictions, medication or denial, he held, leaves the underlying conflict untouched (May, 1977).

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

An Invented Example: Two Students, One Big Choice

Take two invented students, Dana and Eli. Each is offered a place at a university far from home. Each feels anxious.

Dana treats the anxiety as information. It tells her that two parts of her are pulling apart: she wants the place, and she fears leaving home. She faces it, talks it through and decides. This is normal anxiety, faced and used.

Eli tries not to feel it. He distracts himself and puts the decision off until it is made for him. The conflict is still there, and his room to choose has shrunk. This is a picture of giving up freedom to escape anxiety.

The feeling was the same in both. What differed was what each did with it.

An Example From May’s Own Research

In the mid-1940s, May studied anxiety in unmarried pregnant young women in a New York shelter home. He expected anxiety to rise with the degree of rejection by their mothers. Half the group fitted that.

The other half had been openly driven out by their mothers, yet showed no unusual anxiety on tests such as the Rorschach inkblots.

May concluded that the source of anxiety is not rejection but rejection that is lied about. The person cannot know the world they are in or orient themselves in it (May, 1975).

How Did May Link Courage and Creativity?

Courage and Its Four Kinds

May called courage the capacity to move ahead in spite of despair. He saw it as the foundation of the other virtues. Without courage, love shrinks into dependency and fidelity into conformity (May, 1975).

He named four kinds, and called the last the most important (May, 1975):

  • Physical Courage: Using the body to cultivate sensitivity and empathy, not to assert power over others.
  • Moral Courage: Righting wrongs, usually by identifying with other people’s suffering. His example is the writer Solzhenitsyn, who protested alone against the treatment of prisoners.
  • Social Courage: Risking oneself in lasting intimacy, whose effect cannot be known at the start.
  • Creative Courage: Discovering new forms, symbols and patterns on which a new society can be built.

Creativity as Encounter

May defined creativity as the process of bringing something new into being. He put encounter at its centre: “the encounter of the intensively conscious human being with his or her world” (May, 1975).

His example is Cézanne looking at a tree. Cézanne sees it as no one has seen it. He feels grasped by it. The painting shows not a tree but the essence of Tree, something that did not exist before (May, 1975).

A person’s world, for May, is the pattern of meaningful relations in which they exist, not the sum of the objects around them. Creativity is not confined to artists. May counts the scientist and a mother’s ordinary relationship with her child, and excludes hobbies and weekend painting (May, 1975).

Why Creativity Takes Courage

May answered by way of myth. In his reading, Prometheus stole fire from the gods, and Adam and Eve ate from the tree of knowledge. In both stories, creativity and consciousness are born in rebellion against an omnipotent force (May, 1975).

Both stories point to death. May concluded that creativity is a yearning for immortality, a passion to live beyond one’s death. He also argued that creativity needs limits. A river exists only because of its banks (May, 1975).

What Else Did May Write About?

The Daimonic, Will and Love

May uses the word daimonic in The Courage to Create. He never defines it. He applies it to strong passions such as love.

The early Greeks, he says, accepted and directed these powers instead of denying them (May, 1975). In Love and Will, the word covers aggression, anxiety and guilt (May, 1969).

Will, for May, is not mere will power. It is closer to commitment. People cannot will insight or creativity. They can will to give themselves to an encounter with dedication (May, 1975).

A wish alone cannot act, he held. It cannot come out in its real power without will (May, 1983).

Love and Will examined how love and will interact in close relationships, including therapy (May, 1969). In his later book, he says love depends on personal decision and commitment, not on biology alone (May, 1983).

How Did May Bring Existential Ideas into Psychology and Therapy?

In 1958, May co-edited Existence with Angel and Ellenberger (May et al., 1958).

It is widely treated as the work that introduced existential thought to American psychology and psychiatry. May himself says the approach was practically unknown in America until 1960 (May, 1983).

What a Session Looks Like

May is often named the primary originator of existential-humanistic therapy, which takes freedom, meaning, mortality and responsibility as central. The clearest picture comes from his own cases. He tells them from the therapist’s chair.

Mrs. Hutchens was in her middle thirties. She tried to look poised, but her eyes showed something of a frightened animal or a lost child. She was permanently hoarse. Her specialists told May her main problem was tension in the larynx (May, 1983).

May heard hints of why in her childhood, under an authoritarian mother and grandmother. He argued that thinking chiefly about the past would miss his only real data, the person now in the room (May, 1983).

After about twenty-five hours she had a dream. She was searching an unfinished house for a baby, and wondered whether to kill it. She and May agreed the baby stood for herself, on evidence May does not give (May, 1983).

After about thirty-five sessions she considered telling her parents she had left their faith. She had fainting spells in his office. Then she wrote the letter.

She asked whether she would go psychotic. May asked whether the fear was really anxiety about standing against her parents (May, 1983).

He read the dream, the fainting and the fear as three faces of one conflict.

An existential therapist, he says, takes such temptations seriously. He neither dismisses them as merely neurotic nor reassures the patient that she need not act on them. Either would help her adjust at the price of part of her existence (May, 1983).

A second patient was a woman of twenty-eight. She had been told in family quarrels that she should not have been born.

She realised she had been born illegitimate but was not a child any more. What was left was “I am”. She likened it to getting the deed to her own house (May, 1983).

More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

What the Therapist Does, and What Cure and Freedom Mean

Do not expect a manual of technique, May warns. Technique follows understanding, so the therapist’s central task is to understand the patient as a being in their world (May, 1983).

The therapist is a living person, not a shadowy reflector.

May says he often feels an impulse to ask a patient not “How are you?” but “Where are you?” He would probably not voice it. He wants to know whether the patient is detached or present (May, 1983).

The aim is that patients experience their existence as real, including their potentialities and their ability to act on them. Relief of symptoms is a by-product. A cure by adjustment, May warns, can mean being cured by giving up being (May, 1983).

Freedom, in his account, rests on self-consciousness. That is the capacity to step back from the immediate situation and live in terms of the possible.

A person always keeps some margin of freedom, and in that margin lies a responsibility even the therapist cannot take away. The therapist is present while the patient finds their own world, not to occupy it (May, 1983).

What Does the Evidence Say About May’s Ideas?

May’s main ideas rest on clinical observation, philosophy and literary reading rather than controlled tests. So the fairest modern tests of his tradition are indirect.

They look at therapies that descend from existential thought, and at how feelings change during therapy, a process his account of anxiety implies.

An Existential Therapy Meta-Analysis (Vos et al., 2015)

A meta-analysis pools the results of many studies.

Vos et al. (2015) pooled randomised controlled trials, in which people are assigned to treatments by chance. The therapies were existential therapies, which draw on existential thought to help people with issues such as meaning and death anxiety.

  • Aim: To review how well existential therapies improve psychological outcomes, such as meaning in life and anxiety.
  • Method: The authors searched databases, journals and reference lists for trials of existential therapy with adults. They extracted effects on meaning in life, anxiety and depression, and physical well-being.
  • Results: Across 15 trials (1,792 participants) in all, meaning-centred therapies had large effects on meaning in life and moderate effects on anxiety and depression. A second type had small effects on anxiety and depression, and two had no significant effects.
  • Conclusion: Despite the small number and low quality of studies, some existential therapies appear beneficial for certain populations. Support was clearest for structured programmes that discuss meaning in life directly and positively with physically ill patients.

This bears on May only indirectly. The trials tested therapies descended from existential thought, mostly meaning-centred programmes, not May’s own approach. The authors flag the small number and low quality of the trials themselves.

Facing Painful Feeling and Recovery (Khayyat-Abuaita et al., 2019)

The second study looks at how feelings change during therapy. Khayyat-Abuaita et al. (2019) examined recorded sessions of emotion-focused therapy for complex trauma.

  • Aim: To test whether moving from early distress toward adaptive (more useful) emotion is linked to how well therapy turns out.
  • Method: The researchers analysed video recordings of 38 people from a randomised trial. They coded emotional processes while people told their trauma stories, early and late in therapy, and related them to two outcome measures.
  • Results: Adaptive emotions were more frequent in later sessions and in good-outcome cases. A rise in them was linked to a good outcome. The expected order of emotions held in early sessions and only partly in late ones.
  • Conclusion: Changes in specific emotions were linked to good outcome, which supports the view that moving through painful feeling, not avoiding it, helps recovery.

The study fits May’s claim that avoided anxiety constricts and faced anxiety transforms, but it tests emotion-focused therapy, not May.

It reports that emotion changes were linked to outcomes, in 38 people from a randomised trial.

A Third Line of Evidence and the Overall Picture

A third line of work uses laboratory experiments to test existential ideas.

Terror management theory studies awareness of death this way (Pyszczynski et al., 2015). It shows that such ideas can be tested, though it does not test May’s own.

Across the three lines, the pattern is consistent. Broad existential themes attract moderate, qualified support. May’s specific ideas, such as the daimonic, remain largely untested directly.

How Does May Compare with Carl Rogers and Other Humanistic Psychologists?

May Among the Humanistic Psychologists

May, Rogers and Abraham Maslow are counted among the founders of humanistic psychology in the 1950s and 1960s.

Maslow’s theorising centred on constructive aspects of human potential. May’s emphasised limitation, anxiety, guilt and death (May, 1983).

May disagreed with Carl Rogers. In a series of exchanges, Rogers argued that culture damages an inherent goodness in people (Rogers, 1982a).

May replied that people may tend toward either good or evil. He also argued that Rogers’s position encouraged a narcissistic (self-absorbed) attitude (May, 1982). Rogers answered with his clinical experience. It showed humanistic therapy prompting social concern instead (Rogers, 1982b).

Earlier, in The Discovery of Being, May had called Rogers’s account of entering a relationship as a person, not a scientist, very existential. He also found Rogers’s work at times naively optimistic (May, 1983).

Viktor Frankl’s logotherapy, a meaning-centred therapy, is a parallel voice in the same humanistic-existential current.

Strengths of May’s Existential Psychology

The case for May’s work rests mainly on his ideas and his cases, with some indirect support:

  1. Agenda Setting: He framed anxiety, freedom and meaning as legitimate psychological topics (May et al., 1958).
  2. Vivid Cases: His cases in The Discovery of Being show what an existential reading of a person looks like, more vividly than a statistic could.
  3. Self-Criticism: He warned that existential concepts can be used for intellectual detachment, a temptation he admitted he may not have fully resisted (May, 1983).
  4. Process Fit: Research on emotional processing is partly consistent with his claim that faced anxiety transforms and avoided anxiety constricts (Khayyat-Abuaita et al., 2019).
  5. Related Therapies: Meaning-centred therapies from the same tradition appear beneficial for some groups, such as physically ill patients (Vos et al., 2015).

None of these tests May’s own method directly.

Limitations of May’s Existential Psychology

Before working through the first one, here is a one-line summary of the main criticisms. The first is explained in full afterwards. The other three are short points.

  1. Hard to Falsify: His distinction between healthy and unhealthy anxiety is hard to prove wrong, because almost any behaviour can be redescribed afterwards as life-enhancing or life-constricting.
  2. No Standard Measure: Terms such as the daimonic and ontological anxiety have no standard measure, and encounter and world are defined by description and example, so they remain largely untested directly (May, 1975).
  3. Cases Read by the Therapist: His therapy claims rest on a handful of cases, two of them his own, which he or colleagues interpret, with no systematic comparison of outcomes (May, 1983).
  4. Unsettled Human Nature: Rogers saw an inherent goodness that culture damages (Rogers, 1982a). May said people may tend toward either good or evil (May, 1982). A theoretical dispute, not empirically settled.

Hard to Falsify

May’s earlier book separated healthy anxiety from unhealthy anxiety, as life-enhancing or life-constricting. His later normal and neurotic pair parallels it. Both are hard to prove wrong, which is what falsify means. Almost any behaviour can be redescribed afterwards as life-enhancing or life-constricting.

Return to Eli. If he later builds a good life, his delay could be called a pause that did him good. If he stays stuck, it could be called constriction. The same history fits either label.

His definition of anxiety invites the same problem. The signs of ontological anxiety he lists include ennui, compulsive activity and meaningless diversions in “normal” people (May, 1983). If nearly any behaviour, calm or busy, can count as a sign, the claim is hard to put at risk.

His own methods were largely non-empirical. The same caution applies to his claims about anxiety (May, 1977) and to his case against Rogers (May, 1982). May’s work is best judged as a body of ideas and a therapeutic stance, not as a programme of tested findings.

Who Was Rollo May?

May’s ideas make most sense once you know how he reached them. This section gives only the parts of his life that bear on them.

Early Life and Education

May was born in Ohio and grew up in Michigan. He majored in English at Oberlin College, travelled to Greece, and studied painting (Bilmes, 1978).

He also attended seminars given by Alfred Adler, who is known for a whole-person psychology. He then enrolled at Union Theological Seminary in New York. There he met the existential theologian and philosopher Paul Tillich, who became his mentor and friend (Bilmes, 1978).

A fuller biography by Abzug (2021) concentrates on his spiritual development.

Illness and the Turn to Psychology

May was a minister for about two years.

Then he became deeply discouraged and developed tuberculosis, a serious lung disease. He later described his recovery. He took personal responsibility for his condition. He also found a will to live (Bilmes, 1978).

That experience led him to doctoral work in clinical psychology at Columbia University. His dissertation concerned anxiety. In Bilmes’s account, the subject reflected his own struggle with death (Bilmes, 1978).

May later wrote that he spent a year and a half in bed in a tuberculosis sanatorium. He was working on The Meaning of Anxiety. He read the two books on anxiety he says had been written by his day, one by Freud and one by Kierkegaard (May, 1983).

More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

References

Abzug, R. H. (2021). Psyche and soul in America: The spiritual odyssey of Rollo May. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780199754373.001.0001

Bilmes, M. (1978). Rollo May. In R. Valle & M. King (Eds.), Existential-phenomenological alternatives for psychology (pp. 290-294). Oxford University Press.

Khayyat-Abuaita, U., Paivio, S. C., Pascual-Leone, A., & Harrington, S. (2019). Emotional processing of trauma narratives is a predictor of outcome in emotion-focused therapy for complex trauma. Psychotherapy, 56(4), 526-536. https://doi.org/10.1037/pst0000238

May, R. (1950). The meaning of anxiety. Ronald Press.

May, R. (1969). Love and will. Norton.

May, R. (1975). The courage to create. Norton.

May, R. (1977). The meaning of anxiety (Rev. ed.). Norton.

May, R. (1982). The problem of evil: An open letter to Carl Rogers. Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 22(3), 10-21. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022167882223003

May, R. (1983). The discovery of being: Writings in existential psychology. Norton.

May, R., Angel, E., & Ellenberger, H. F. (Eds.). (1958). Existence: A new dimension in psychiatry and psychology. Basic Books.

Pyszczynski, T., Solomon, S., & Greenberg, J. (2015). Thirty years of terror management theory: From genesis to revelation. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 52, 1-70. https://doi.org/10.1016/bs.aesp.2015.03.001

Rogers, C. R. (1982a). Notes on Rollo May. Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 22(3), 8-9. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022167882223002

Rogers, C. R. (1982b). Reply to Rollo May’s letter to Carl Rogers. Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 22(4), 85-89. https://doi.org/10.1177/002216788202200407

Vos, J., Craig, M., & Cooper, M. (2015). Existential therapies: A meta-analysis of their effects on psychological outcomes. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 83(1), 115-128. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0037167

Olivia Guy-Evans, MSc

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MSc Psychology of Education

Associate Editor for Simply Psychology

Olivia Guy-Evans is a writer and associate editor for Simply Psychology, where she contributes accessible content on psychological topics. She is also an autistic PhD student at the University of Birmingham, researching autistic camouflaging in higher education.


Saul McLeod, PhD

Chartered Psychologist (CPsychol)

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MRes, PhD, University of Manchester

Saul McLeod, PhD, is a qualified psychology teacher with over 18 years of experience in further and higher education. He has been published in peer-reviewed journals, including the Journal of Clinical Psychology.