Gilchrist and Nesberg’s Motivation & Perception Study (1952)

Gilchrist and Nesberg’s 1952 study tested whether going without food changes how pictures of food look. University students saw pictures of meals, then had to set each picture’s brightness from memory after a short gap. As the hungry group went longer without food, its settings rose, while a group that ate normally stayed level.

Key Takeaways

Aim

  • To test whether a need such as hunger, which psychologists call motivation, changes how bright people set pictures linked to that need.

Method

  • Experiment I was a laboratory experiment (a controlled setting) with 26 student volunteers, put into two groups by chance.
  • The hungry group (the experimental group, which got the change) went 20 hours without food but could drink water. The fed group (the control group) ate normally.
  • Each person saw four projected slides of meals for 15 seconds each. The picture then went dark for 10 seconds.
  • It came back brighter or dimmer, and they turned a knob until it looked as bright as before.
  • The same people did this three times: at the start, after 6 hours and after 20 hours.
  • Independent variable (what the researcher changes): hungry or fed, and time (0, 6 and 20 hours). Dependent variable (what is measured): the lamp voltage they set.

Results

  • The hungry group set the food pictures brighter as the hours went on. A higher lamp voltage meant a brighter picture.
  • Its settings rose from about 76 to about 78 volts, while the fed group’s stayed near 76.
  • The difference in how the two groups changed was too big to put down to chance, which means it was unlikely to be just luck.
  • Later experiments on thirst gave the same pattern, and the thirsty people’s settings fell back after they drank.
  • Pictures unrelated to the need showed no rise.

Conclusion

  • The longer people went without food or drink, the brighter they set pictures linked to that need, but not unrelated pictures.
  • So the motivation of hunger affected how the food pictures were perceived.
  • The authors cautioned that the task was matching a remembered picture and that more work was needed.

Strengths

  • Control: every person saw the same slides and timings in a darkened room, so differences are more likely to come from hunger. It also makes the study easy to repeat.
  • Similar research: in the exam you get marks for mentioning Sanford (1936), who found that hungry people were more likely to see a brown blob as a hamburger.
  • Ecological validity (how well findings apply to real life): in the exam you get marks for saying some people really were hungry, which makes the study more like real life.
  • Validity (measuring what it claims to measure): thirst gave the same pattern and unrelated pictures did not, which helps rule out other explanations.

Limitations

  • Ecological validity: a darkened room, projected slides and a knob are far from everyday life, and pictures of food are not real food.
  • Generalisability (applying findings to other people and settings): high control makes the task artificial, so the findings are hard to apply to normal settings.
  • Sample bias (a sample that does not represent everyone): the 26 students all volunteered to go without food, so they may differ from other people and the results are hard to generalise.
  • Demand characteristics (clues about what the researcher wants): people knew they were fasting and may have guessed the aim, so they may have exaggerated their settings to help.
  • Ethics: going 20 hours without food could cause discomfort to the participants (see Ethical Issues below).

Ethical Issues

  • Protection from harm: 20 hours without food could cause discomfort. A way of dealing with it: make sure the risk is no greater than everyday life.
  • In the exam you also get marks for saying people should leave in the state they started, but as a weakness of the study, not as a way of dealing with an issue.
  • Informed consent (agreeing after being told what will happen): volunteers agreed to fast, but no consent procedure is described. A way of dealing with it: explain what taking part involves and ask if people are happy.
  • Debrief (a full explanation afterwards): none is described. A way of dealing with it: explain afterwards what people took part in, why, and how the results will be used.
Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Aim

Motivation is a need, such as hunger or thirst. The paper calls it need. It grows the longer you go without food or drink.

The AQA specification names this study for the effect of motivation on perception. It sits beside Bruner and Minturn’s study of expectation.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

A perceptual set is a readiness to perceive something in one way rather than another.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

The authors’ aim was to show the effect of need on short-term perceptual recall of need-related objects (Gilchrist & Nesberg, 1952). It means matching a picture from memory.

In GCSE terms, the aim is to find out whether going without food changes how bright food pictures look.

The paper lists no numbered hypotheses. The prediction is that hungry people will set food pictures brighter than people who have eaten.

Earlier studies of need and perception were hard to interpret. The authors named two problems.

  • Matches Differed in More Than One Way: The two things being matched differed in more than the one thing studied. Adding control objects only moved the problem back, because they differed in form too.
  • Need Was Assumed: Most studies used an assumed need, such as children from poorer families needing money more. The assumptions behind it were not checked.

Their solutions were simple. They used the same picture twice, with a gap between, so no control pictures were needed. And they used hunger and thirst, which can be measured in hours without food or drink.

The paper reports four experiments, one after the other. The first used hunger. The others used thirst and control pictures.

  • Experiment I, Hunger: Does going without food change how bright food pictures look?
  • Experiment II, Thirst: Does thirst give the same pattern, so that the effect is more general?
  • Experiment III, Colour Fields: Does the picture have to relate to the need, or would any picture do?
  • Experiment IV, Landscapes: Is it any picture with detail in it, or only pictures that relate to the need?

AQA’s description follows Experiment I, so most of this article does too.

Method

Design and Variables

This was a laboratory experiment, run in a controlled setting. In Experiment I, hungry and well-fed students looked at four pictures of meals. Then they set each picture’s brightness back to what it had been ten seconds earlier.

The independent variable is what the researcher changes. The dependent variable is what the researcher measures.

The paper does not use these labels. The table gives them for all four experiments.

ExperimentIndependent variableDependent variable
I, hungerHungry or satiated group; session (0, 6 or 20 hours)Lamp voltage set to match each picture
II, thirstThirsty or satiated group; session (four, then after drinking)The same lamp voltage
III, colour fieldsThirsty or satiated group; session; need-related or colour slideThe same lamp voltage
IV, landscapesSession; need-related or landscape slideThe same lamp voltage

The knob turned the lamp’s brightness up or down. The number it set is the lamp voltage, measured in volts. A higher number means a brighter picture.

In an exam on Experiment I, name whether people had gone without food as the independent variable. AQA credits this.

The lamp voltage is the dependent variable.

Groups were compared across repeated sessions. This is a mixed design. It has two parts. It is independent groups for hunger, where different people are in each condition. It is repeated measures for session, where the same people are tested each time.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

In the exam, the study is described as comparing two groups. The experimental group gets the change. Here, that is going without food.

The control group does not get the change, so it is the comparison. The exam also calls this an independent groups design. See Exam Questions for how the paper differs.

The 20 hours is the last of the three sessions, not a single test after 20 hours.

Everything else was kept the same for everyone: the four slides, the 15 second showing, the 10 second gap and a darkened room. The slides came in random order.

Participants

There were 26 students. They came from an elementary psychology course at the University of Wisconsin. All volunteered to go 20 hours without food. They could drink only water.

That makes it a volunteer sample, meaning people who put themselves forward.

They were put into a hungry group or a satiated group at random, which means by chance. Group sizes are not given. The paper does not report ages, sexes or drop-outs.

Pictures and Equipment

A projector behind and above the participant’s chair aimed at a screen 12 feet away. A knob, hidden under a curtain, set the lamp’s voltage. Participants could reach it but not see it.

The four slides were colour pictures of full meals, like those in homemakers’ magazines. The main foods were T-bone steaks, fried chicken, hamburgers and spaghetti.

The Task

Here is one session of Experiment I.

  1. Instructions: Participants sat in the dark and were told it was an experiment in matching pictures.
  2. The Rule: A picture would show for 15 seconds and go off. When it came back looking different, they had to make it look the same by turning the knob.
  3. Showing: The picture stayed on for 15 seconds. Then it went dark for 10 seconds.
  4. The Change: In the gap, the lamp was reset 20 volts higher or lower. So the picture came back brighter or dimmer.
  5. Matching: The participant turned the knob one way only until the picture looked as it had before. For example, if it came back too dim, they turned it up until it matched.
  6. Number of Matches: Each slide was shown twice at two starting levels, 60 and 90 volts, once matched from below and once from above. That is 16 matches a session.

The paper says an accurate average match would be 75 volts. That is halfway between 60 and 90.

There were three sessions. The same people did the task three times: at the start, after 6 hours and after 20 hours.

The first was just after the hungry group’s noon meal, so they were 0 hours without food.

The second was at 6 hours. It came after the time they usually ate their evening meal. The third was at 20 hours, after the time they usually ate breakfast the next day.

The satiated group followed the same routine. But they ate the two meals the hungry group missed.

Experiments II to IV

The later experiments tested the first result in new ways. All used the same lamp and knob.

  • Experiment II, Thirst: There were 48 students, put at random into four groups. All volunteered to go at least 8 hours without food or drink.
  • Experiment II, Who Did: Half of them (the thirsty groups) did so. The other half ate and drank normally.
  • Experiment II, Slides: Slides showed a pitcher and glass of ice water, orange juice or milk. For some groups, real pitchers and glasses stood on a table.
  • Experiment II, Sessions: Sessions were 2.5 hours apart, at 0, 2.5, 5 and 7.5 hours.
  • After Drinking: At the end, the thirsty groups were given as much to drink as they wished. Without warning, they sat a fifth session straight away.
  • Experiment III, Colour Fields: There were 48 students with normal colour vision. All volunteered to go at least 8 hours without food or drink. Only the thirsty half did so.
  • Experiment III, Slides and Sessions: Some matched only six plain colour fields. Others matched need-related slides and three colour fields. Sessions were 4 hours apart, with a fourth after drinking.
  • Experiment IV, Landscapes: There were 12 students, who went at least 8 hours without food or drink. They matched need-related slides and three landscape slides: mountains, autumn trees, and a park lawn with shrubs.

Results

Experiment I: Hunger and Food Pictures

The hungry group set the pictures brighter and brighter as the hours without food went on. The satiated group’s settings stayed about level. Here “judged brighter” and “set brighter” mean the same thing.

The paper prints no table of means. These values are approximate readings from its graph. A higher number means a brighter picture.

Hours from startHungry group (volts)Satiated group (volts)
0about 76.0about 76.3
6about 76.6about 75.5
20about 78.3about 75.9

At the start the two groups were close. At 20 hours they were about 2.4 volts apart. That is a small but steady rise for the hungry group.

Both groups set the pictures above the accurate 75 volts at every session. So the satiated group also set them a little brighter than they were. What changed was the hungry group.

The hungry group’s settings got brighter as hunger grew, and the fed group’s did not. That difference was too big to put down to chance, which means it was unlikely to be just luck. The paper does not report the two groups as different overall, with the sessions ignored.

The authors called their data too thin for definite claims. They left two questions open. Is the effect a general visual function, and is it only about hunger?

Experiment II: Thirst

Thirst gave the same pattern, and drinking removed it. The numbers below are the lamp voltages the groups set, as in Experiment I.

  • Thirsty Groups: Settings rose from about 79.5 volts at the start to about 81.7, 82.3 and 83.0 at the later sessions.
  • Satiated Groups: Settings stayed between about 81.3 and 81.8.
  • After Drinking: The thirsty groups fell back to about 79.8. The fall from the fourth session was too big to be down to chance.
  • Real Pitchers: Real pitchers and glasses on the table made no difference to the settings.

The authors raised a worry. Participants were hungry as well as thirsty. They argued that thirst was the main cause. The change in 8 hours was larger than in 20 hours of hunger alone, and most of it vanished after drinking.

Experiments III and IV: Control Pictures

The rise appeared for need-related slides only.

  • Experiment III, Need-Related Slides: For the thirsty group, settings rose from about 80.5 volts to about 83.0 at 4 hours and 82.9 at 8 hours. They fell to about 81.3 after drinking.
  • Experiment III, Colour Fields: Settings stayed between about 80.4 and 81.6 volts across the sessions, with no clear rise.
  • Experiment IV, Need-Related Slides: Settings rose from about 80.4 volts to about 83.3 and then about 85.1. They fell to about 81.4 after drinking.
  • Experiment IV, Landscapes: Settings stayed between about 81.2 and 81.7 volts across the sessions.

In both experiments, the two kinds of slide changed differently over the sessions. The difference was too big to be down to chance.

The authors took this to mean that the effect was not a general visual change. Some need-relatedness had to be present in the picture. A critic who thought any detailed picture would do must give a more specific, testable reason.

Conclusion

The authors’ statement was that increasing need gives an increasingly positive time error in brightness matches of objects that relate to the need.

A time error is a mistake in comparing two things seen one after the other. The paper does not define a positive one. From the graphs, it means setting the picture brighter than it was.

In plain words, the longer people went without food or drink, the brighter they set pictures of food or drink after a short gap. They did not do this for unrelated pictures, or after drinking.

The authors hedged as they went.

  1. After Experiment I: The data were too thin for definite claims. It was not clear that the effect was not a general visual function.
  2. After Experiment II: The general statement seemed more likely. But it was not shown that the pictures had to relate to the need, and the thirsty people may have been partly hungry.
  3. After Experiments III and IV: The results favour an effect that is restricted to need-related objects. Two more lines of work were needed: how the effect develops, and wider degrees of need-relatedness.

AQA’s version is simpler. It says the motivation of hunger affected how food pictures were perceived. The authors’ own measure was a memory match.

Strengths

The study has six main strengths:

  1. Controlled Procedure: The same slides, timings and dark room were used for everyone. In the exam you get marks for saying this makes the study easy to repeat.
  2. Four Experiments: Thirst gave the same pattern and control pictures did not. The same thirsty people’s settings fell back after drinking, the paper’s most direct check. Drinking itself is not ruled out.
  3. Similar Research Agrees: In the exam you get marks for mentioning Sanford (1936), an earlier study in which hungry participants were more likely to see a brown blob as a hamburger.
  4. Real Need: In the exam you get marks for saying some participants really were hungry, which makes the study more like real life. This is ecological validity: how well findings fit real life.
  5. Random Groups: People were put into groups by chance. In Experiment I the two groups started close, at about 76.0 and 76.3 volts. So the later gap is unlikely to come from the start.
  6. Later Research Agrees: Hungry students kept food pictures in view for longer (Weng et al., 2019).

Limitations

Before working through each one, here is a one-line summary of the main limitations:

  1. Artificial Setting and Task: A darkened room, slides and a knob are not an everyday way of meeting food.
  2. Small Volunteer Sample: Students who volunteered to fast, with little described about them.
  3. Demand Characteristics: Participants knew they were fasting and may have guessed the aim.
  4. A Memory Match: The task tests how a picture is remembered and set, not only how it looks.
  5. Other Explanations Not Ruled Out: Thirst was mixed with hunger, and the groups did not start level.
  6. Later Research Mixed: Later studies find the direction of the effect but not always its size.
  7. One Need, One Era: Only hunger and thirst were tested, among students in the early 1950s.
  8. Ethics: Going 20 hours without food could cause discomfort.

Artificial Setting and Task

This limits ecological validity. A darkened room, projected slides and a knob that changes a lamp are not an everyday way of meeting food.

AQA credits this as evaluation of the research method. Artificial materials, such as pictures and not real food, can reduce validity. The results might differ with real food.

AQA also credits that high control makes behaviour artificial. So findings are hard to generalise to normal settings.

One result points the other way. In Experiment II, real pitchers and glasses on the table made no difference to the settings. For thirst at least, this suggests that real objects might not have changed the result.

More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Small Volunteer Sample

Generalisability means how far results apply beyond the people studied. The samples were 26, 48, 48 and 12 students from beginning psychology courses at one university. In Experiment II, some came from sociology courses. All had volunteered to go without food.

Volunteers for a fasting study may differ from other students. A sample that does not represent everyone is said to have sample bias. University students are also a narrow slice of people.

Group sizes, ages and sexes are not reported. Nor are drop-outs, or whether anyone took part in more than one experiment.

People also differed a lot from one another in the settings they chose. With so few people, the groups could differ for reasons other than hunger.

Demand Characteristics

Demand characteristics are cues that tell participants what the researcher wants, so that they behave to suit.

Participants knew they had volunteered to go without food. They were told it was a study of matching pictures. The paper does not say whether the aim was explained or guessed.

Someone who guessed it could have set food pictures brighter to help the researcher. AQA credits this point.

Two things weigh against it. The lamp control was hidden behind a screen (the paper does not say whether they could see the voltmeter). And the rise did not appear for the control slides shown in the same session in Experiments III and IV.

It does not rule demand out.

A Memory Match

The task asked people to restore a picture to how it looked ten seconds earlier. The authors call it short-term perceptual recall.

A change could be in how the picture was remembered. Or it could be in how people chose to set the knob. It need not be a change in how bright the picture looked.

The measure was lamp voltage. The authors admit this does not rise in a straight line with brightness across the whole range. They say it does between 60 and 120 volts. The pictures also varied in colour and shade.

So “perceived brighter”, as AQA puts it, is a reading of a memory-based setting.

Later critics make the same point more widely. Firestone and Scholl (2016) argue that many studies claiming motivation changes what we see may reflect judgement or response, not perception. They do not discuss this study, but the criticism fits a memory match.

Other Explanations Not Ruled Out

In the thirst experiments, participants had no food either. So the effect may be partly hunger. The authors accept this. They say 21 participants who drank only ice water or orange juice were probably still hungry.

The groups also did not start level. In Experiment II the thirsty groups started about 1.8 volts below the satiated groups. This was before any deprivation. It is about 79.5 against 81.3 on the graph.

In Experiments III and IV the need-related slides also started lower than the control slides. A starting difference makes it harder to say how much of the later change came from need.

Later Research Mixed

Later studies support the direction of the effect but not always its size. That is a limit.

In 2019, hungry students kept food pictures in view for longer (Weng et al., 2019). In 2020, a study of perceived food size found inconsistent effects that depended on the method (Zitron-Emanuel & Ganel, 2020).

Neither used the brightness task, so neither confirms or rejects the 1952 result directly. See Later Research.

One Need, One Era

Only hunger and thirst were tested. The sample was students at one American university in the early 1950s. The authors say that wider degrees of need-relatedness still needed study.

So the findings may not apply to other needs, other people or other times.

Ethics

AQA credits an ethical point as a weakness. Going 20 hours without food could cause discomfort, and researchers should make sure people leave in the state they started. See Ethical Issues.

Ethical Issues

The paper does not discuss ethics. These are its details.

  • Protection From Harm: Experiment I meant 20 hours without food. That could cause discomfort.
  • Thirst Experiments: Experiments II to IV meant at least 8 hours without drink for the thirsty groups. That is a smaller deprivation, but it is still a deprivation.
  • In the Mark Schemes: AQA credits this as a weakness, and examiners found it the most popular correct one.
  • Relief of the Need: The thirsty groups in Experiment II were given as much to drink as they wished. The paper says nothing about food after Experiment I.
  • Informed Consent: This means agreeing to take part after being told what will happen. All volunteered. The paper describes no consent procedure and no right to withdraw.
  • What They Were Told: The instructions described a picture-matching experiment. The paper does not say whether people were told the study was about hunger or thirst.
  • Debriefing: This means explaining the study to participants afterwards. The paper describes none.
  • Approval: The paper mentions no ethical review.

AQA asks about ethics inside research-design questions. The credited issues in the mark schemes are respect, competence, responsibility and integrity. They also include confidentiality, informed consent, deception, right to withdraw, protection from harm and debrief.

Parental consent is credited as an issue in several series. Students can apply these to this study. They are not claims about what the authors did.

These are credited ways of dealing with an issue.

  • For Protection From Harm: Make sure the risk is no greater than in everyday life.
  • Not a Way of Dealing: In the exam, leaving people in the state they started is credited as a weakness (June 2024, Question 9), not as a way of dealing with an issue.
  • For Informed Consent: Explain what people will take part in and ask if they are happy to.
  • For Parental Consent: Ask parents for permission if they are under 16, or ask parents to sign a consent form.
  • For Confidentiality: Use a number or a letter, not a name.
  • For Deception: Tell people as soon as possible if they were lied to.
  • For Right to Withdraw: Tell people before and during that they can stop, and afterwards that they can remove their results.
  • For Debrief: Afterwards, explain what they took part in, why, and how the results will be used.

See informed consent for more.

Exam Questions

What Examiners Look For

The AQA specification names “the Gilchrist and Nesberg study of motivation” in its Perception topic. It is in Paper 1.

The Paper 1 mark schemes show five questions on it. Each is quoted below as the mark scheme prints it.

  • June 2021, Question 12 (9 marks): Describe the study and evaluate its research method.
  • June 2022, Question 6 (2 marks): Pick the two correct statements.
  • June 2024, Question 8 (2 marks): Describe one result.
  • June 2024, Question 9 (4 marks): Outline one strength and one weakness.
  • June 2025, Question 21 (9 marks): Discuss laboratory or field experiments, using one published experiment.

AO1 means knowledge and understanding, which is describing. AO3 means analysis and evaluation. The examiners’ reports add advice to each question below.

Ethics is asked inside research-design questions, not about this study. The June 2020 Paper 2 question was worth 4 marks. The June 2025 Paper 1 Question 17 was worth 6.

The model answers and mark schemes below are examples based on the credited points, not AQA’s own wording. The three practice questions at the end use invented scenarios.

June 2021, Question 12 (9 marks)

Question (9 marks): “Describe Gilchrist and Nesberg’s study into how motivation affects perception. Evaluate the research method used in this study.”.

Model answer: Gilchrist and Nesberg tested whether motivation affects perception. It was a laboratory experiment with 26 student volunteers. One group went 20 hours without food. The other group ate normal meals.

Each person was shown four projected pictures of meals, each for 15 seconds. The picture was then switched off. When it came back, its brightness had been changed. Participants turned a knob to set it back to how bright it had been.

By the last session, the hungry group set the pictures brighter than the group that ate normally. So how food pictures were perceived depended on how hungry people were. The researchers concluded that the motivation of hunger affected perception.

The research method was a laboratory experiment. One strength is high control.

Many extraneous variables, which are other things that could change the result, are removed. So the researcher can be more confident that, if there is an effect, the independent variable caused it. A second strength is standardised procedures, so the study can be repeated.

One weakness is artificial materials. Pictures of food are not real food, which can reduce validity. A second weakness is that high control makes the task artificial. So the findings are hard to generalise.

  • Describing, 4 Marks (AO1): One group deprived of food for 20 hours, the other eating normally. Four projected food images, each shown for 15 seconds, then again with altered brightness.
  • Describing, Results: Participants adjusted the brightness back. The deprived group adjusted the images brighter. The conclusion was that hunger affected perception.
  • Evaluating, 5 Marks (AO3): High control removes extraneous variables, and standardised procedures allow replication. Artificial materials, such as food images, reduce validity and make findings hard to generalise.
  • Levels: 7 to 9, 4 to 6 and 1 to 3. Level 3 needs the method, the results and the conclusion, with accurate detail.
  • True Extras: The paper also has three sessions at 0, 6 and 20 hours, a 10 second gap, and the same pattern with thirst. AQA does not require these.

June 2022, Question 6 (2 marks)

Question (2 marks): “Gilchrist and Nesberg investigated the effect of motivation on perception. Which two of the following statements about their study are correct? Shade two boxes.”.

The mark scheme prints only the credited answers. The other options are not printed.

  • Credited Answer 1: The independent variable was whether participants were deprived of food or not.
  • Credited Answer 2: Participants were shown slides of four different meals.

Examiners said this multiple-choice question was harder than expected. Fewer than two-thirds gained both marks.

June 2024, Question 8 (2 marks)

Question (2 marks): “Describe one result from Gilchrist and Nesberg’s study into the effects of motivation on perception.”.

Model answer: As the hungry group went longer without food, they judged the pictures to be brighter. By the last session, they set them brighter than the group that ate normally.

  • Mark Scheme: 2 marks for a clear and accurate description and 1 for a limited or muddled one. If more than one result is given, the clearest earns the marks.
  • Credited Points: As the experimental group got hungrier they judged the pictures brighter. They judged them brighter than they were, or brighter than the control group did.
  • Take Care: Refer to both conditions. A result about one group only was limited to 1 mark.

June 2024, Question 9 (4 marks)

Question (4 marks): “Outline one strength and one weakness of Gilchrist and Nesberg’s study into the effects of motivation on perception.”.

Model answer: One strength is that the study was carefully controlled. The same pictures and timings were used for each condition. So it can be repeated easily.

One weakness is that going without food for 20 hours may be unethical. Participants could feel discomfort. Researchers should make sure participants leave in the state they started.

  • Mark Scheme: Up to 2 marks for a strength and up to 2 for a weakness. A generic point is capped at 1 mark.
  • Credited Strengths, Control and Support: Careful control, with the same pictures and timings, so it is easily replicated. Similar studies, such as Sanford (1936), found similar results, which raises validity or reliability.
  • Credited Strengths, Real Hunger: Ecological validity was raised because some participants really were hungry.
  • Credited Weaknesses, Ethics: Going 20 hours without food may be unethical, and participants should leave in the state they started.
  • Credited Weaknesses, Other: The study does not reflect an everyday situation, and results may differ with real food. Participants may have guessed the aim and exaggerated.
  • Take Care: Link each point to this study. The most popular correct weakness was the ethical one.

June 2025, Question 21 (9 marks)

Question (9 marks): “Briefly outline what is meant by ‘laboratory experiments’ and by ‘field experiments’. Use your knowledge of one published experiment to discuss the strengths and weaknesses of either laboratory experiments or field experiments.”.

The stem does not name the study. The mark scheme gives Gilchrist and Nesberg as one example.

Model answer: A laboratory experiment takes place in an artificial, controlled setting. A field experiment takes place in an everyday setting, such as a school playground. In both, the researcher changes the independent variable and measures the dependent variable.

Gilchrist and Nesberg’s study was a laboratory experiment. Hungry and normally fed students were shown pictures of meals in a darkened room. They set each picture’s brightness after a short gap.

One strength of laboratory experiments is a standardised procedure. Every participant was shown each slide of a meal for 15 seconds, so all were tested the same way. This increases reliability.

One weakness is that a laboratory is not like everyday life. Judging pictures of food in a laboratory is not like judging food in a restaurant. This limits ecological validity.

  • Mark Scheme: Discussion without using knowledge of a published experiment is capped at 1 AO3 mark. Naming an experiment is not using knowledge of it.
  • Examiners: Less than 15% gained a Level 3 mark. The main problems were outlining only one type and naming a study without using it.
  • The Definitions: The outline of the two types comes from the AO1 content in the mark scheme.

Where the Mark Scheme and the Paper Differ

Some points AQA credits, and some that revision guides print, do not match the paper exactly. Here are the facts. They are not a rule about what to write.

  • How Many Experiments: AQA’s credited description follows one experiment. The paper reports four, with 26, 48, 48 and 12 participants.
  • The 20 Hours: AQA credits one group deprived of food for 20 hours. In the paper, 20 hours is the last of three sessions. Participants could drink water.
  • Fed Group Comparison: AQA credits the deprived group adjusting images brighter. In the paper it was about 2 volts above the fed group at 20 hours (78.3 against 75.9, read from the graph).
  • The Paper’s Test: The paper tests how the settings changed across sessions. It prints no direct test of the groups at 20 hours.
  • The Conclusion: AQA credits that the motivation of hunger affected perception. The authors’ own caution was that the task was a memory match and that more work was needed.
  • The Second Showing: AQA credits the brightness being altered. In the paper the picture came back 20 volts brighter or dimmer. It is sometimes described as dimmer only.
  • Perceived Brighter: AQA credits judging pictures brighter than they were. The paper’s task is a match from memory after 10 seconds.
  • The Design: It is often called independent groups. In the paper, groups were between participants, but each person had three sessions. It is mixed.
  • Sanford (1936): AQA credits it as similar research. The paper does not cite it.
  • Guessing the Aim: AQA credits this. The paper does not say whether participants guessed. The instructions called it a matching experiment.
  • Real Food: AQA credits that results may differ with real food. Experiment I used pictures only. In Experiment II, real pitchers and glasses made no difference.
  • Leaving in the Same State: AQA credits this. After Experiment II the thirsty groups drank freely. The paper is silent on food after Experiment I.
  • 24 Hours: A figure of 24 hours sometimes circulates. The paper says 20 hours in Experiment I and at least 8 in the others.
  • Consent: Participants are sometimes said to have given consent. The paper says only that they volunteered to go without food.

Practice Question 1: Identify the Variables (2 marks)

Question (2 marks): Identify the independent and dependent variables in Experiment I.

Model answer: The independent variable was whether participants had gone without food, hungry or satiated. The dependent variable was the lamp voltage they set to match each picture. A higher voltage meant a brighter picture.

  • Mark Scheme: 1 mark for each variable. AQA credits the deprivation of food as the independent variable.

Practice Question 2: Apply the Study (4 marks)

Imagine Mia skipped lunch. At 4 pm she thinks the picture of a pizza on a poster looks brighter than it did at breakfast.

Question (4 marks): Use Gilchrist and Nesberg’s study to explain why Mia sees the picture this way.

Model answer: Motivation is one factor that affects perception. Perceptual set is a readiness to perceive something in one way. Gilchrist and Nesberg found that the longer people went without food, the brighter they set pictures of food.

Mia is hungry. Her hunger may make the food picture look brighter to her. The hungry group in the study set food pictures brighter in the same way.

  • Mark Scheme: 2 marks for knowledge, such as motivation, perceptual set, or the finding. 2 marks for applying it to Mia’s hunger and the pizza picture.
  • Take Care: The study was a memory match after a short gap. Say “set the pictures brighter” for what the participants did.

Practice Question 3: Ethical Issues (4 marks)

Question (4 marks): Name two ethical issues that a researcher should consider in a study like Gilchrist and Nesberg’s. Suggest one way of dealing with each.

Model answer: One issue is protection from harm. Going 20 hours without food could cause discomfort. A way of dealing with it is to make sure the risk is no greater than in everyday life.

Another issue is informed consent. A way of dealing with it is to explain what taking part involves and ask if they are happy to.

  • Mark Scheme: Per issue and way, 2 for clear, accurate and in context, 1 for limited or muddled (the AQA 2020 pattern).
  • Issues to Credit: For example, protection from harm, informed consent, deception, right to withdraw, confidentiality and debrief.
  • Parental Consent: This is credited as an issue in several series.
  • Ways to Credit: For example, risk no greater than everyday life, asking consent, asking parents if under 16, telling people if lied to, letting people stop, and a debrief.
  • Note: AQA’s real ethics questions are generic, not about this study.

Later Research

Hunger and Perception Since 1952

In 2019, Weng and colleagues tested the same idea with a different task. The same people were tested hungry and after a meal.

When two pictures competed to be seen, food pictures stayed in view for longer if students were hungry. Non-food pictures were not affected. This held only for pictures they could see, not hidden ones (Weng et al., 2019; abstract only).

In 2020, Zitron-Emanuel and Ganel tested whether food deprivation changes the perceived size of food. The results were inconsistent and depended on the method (Zitron-Emanuel & Ganel, 2020; abstract only).

Neither used the 1952 brightness task. The 2019 study supports the direction of the effect. The 2020 study found small, inconsistent effects. Neither says much about the size of the 1952 effect.

More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

References

Firestone, C., & Scholl, B. J. (2016). Cognition does not affect perception: Evaluating the evidence for “top-down” effects. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 39, Article e229. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X15000965

Gilchrist, J. C., & Nesberg, L. S. (1952). Need and perceptual change in need-related objects. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 44(6), 369-376. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0061823

Sanford, R. N. (1936). The effects of abstinence from food upon imaginal processes: A preliminary experiment. The Journal of Psychology, 2(1), 129-136. https://doi.org/10.1080/00223980.1936.9917447

Weng, X., Lin, Q., Ma, Y., Peng, Y., Hu, Y., Zhou, K., Shen, F., Wang, H., & Wang, Z. (2019). Effects of hunger on visual perception in binocular rivalry. Frontiers in Psychology, 10, Article 418. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00418

Zitron-Emanuel, N., & Ganel, T. (2020). Does food deprivation affect perceived size? Appetite, 155, Article 104829. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.appet.2020.104829

Olivia Guy-Evans, MSc

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MSc Psychology of Education

Associate Editor for Simply Psychology

Olivia Guy-Evans is a writer and associate editor for Simply Psychology, where she contributes accessible content on psychological topics. She is also an autistic PhD student at the University of Birmingham, researching autistic camouflaging in higher education.


Saul McLeod, PhD

Chartered Psychologist (CPsychol)

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MRes, PhD, University of Manchester

Saul McLeod, PhD, is a qualified psychology teacher with over 18 years of experience in further and higher education. He has been published in peer-reviewed journals, including the Journal of Clinical Psychology.