Meritocracy is an ideology wherein those who work hard are rewarded for their ability and efforts. From a sociological perspective, the meritocratic system believes that successful people are fully deserving of such.
A meritocratic society rewards talent and achievement. It allocates jobs and pay on that basis rather than on ascriptive factors, such as social class, gender, ethnicity, or wealth. These are traits a person has by birth or circumstance, not through anything they have done.
In contrast, those who do not work hard are seen as undeserving. They receive no reward.
The British sociologist Michael Young coined the term in 1958 (Young, 1958). It has received much attention since.
Young reflected that meritocracy would result in dystopia. A society where status depends on natural ability and hard work would establish further inequalities. However, many societies have increasingly recognized meritocracy as a positive system.
Key Takeaways
- Origins: Michael Young coined “meritocracy” in 1958 as a satire. He warned that ranking people by merit would create a dystopia, not a fair society.
- Case For: Functionalists argue that rewarding talent and effort fills key roles with the most qualified people. It also motivates people to work hard.
- Education: School quality, resources, and family background shape attainment. Education therefore falls short of equal opportunity.
- Hidden Inequality: Meritocracy can lead people to blame individuals for failure and overlook structural inequality. It can even increase bias.
- Psychology: Belief persists because it protects the sense that the world is fair. Just-world belief and system justification both play a part.
- Marxist View: Marxists argue that meritocracy is a myth that makes the unjust class system seem deserved.
- Mobility Evidence: Americans overestimate social mobility. Whether rising inequality strengthens or weakens belief in meritocracy is still contested.
What Does Meritocracy Mean In Society?
It is often claimed that modern industrial societies are more meritocratic than in the past.
The allocation of rewards is justified
Reward allocation is justified by meritocratic ideology in that whoever performs best deserves the highest reward. It provides a moral basis for allocating rewards such as money, status, and societal success.
Meritocracy corresponds to the functionalist idea: achievement should replace ascription.
This contrasts with rewards given through nepotism and bribery, among other methods. For society to perform most efficiently, differences in achievement should lead to different rewards (Mijs, 2016).
Hiring is a common example. An employer who picks the candidate with the highest qualifications and most experience makes a meritocratic choice. Hiring someone through bribery or nepotism is the opposite.
Davis and Moore (1945) formulated this principle in the following quote:
‘Social inequality is an unconsciously evolved device by which societies ensure that the most important positions are conscientiously filled by the most qualified persons.’
There is an incentive to work hard
One of the main purposes of a meritocratic society is to incentivize people to work harder. Its purpose is to stimulate effort and motivation.
The stronger the practice of nepotism and bribery, the less likely people feel motivated to spend their effort to attain the impossible.
Ascription implies that reward is allocated to people independent of their achievements, whereas meritocracy values individual achievement (Mijs, 2016).
Equal opportunity and social mobility
Meritocracy rests on a belief in equal opportunity. It assumes that the world is just and fair, so a meritocratic society would suggest that anyone can succeed regardless of age, gender, ethnicity, and social status.
Social mobility is a major principle of meritocracy (Liu, 2011). Individuals can achieve social status through their abilities and contributions.
A meritocratic society allows those from lower socioeconomic status to aspire to a higher social class, status, and place in the hierarchy (Kim & Choi, 2017).
Belief in social mobility drives effort. Individuals will work hard and display certain abilities if they believe they can move up.
Meritocracy In Education
Whether education is meritocratic is debated. Functionalists believe that it is.
The meritocratic view of education means that the system is fair and supports all students. A meritocratic education system gives students equal opportunity to accomplish and receive rewards regardless of outside factors (Erivwo et al., 2021).
If education is meritocratic, the hardest-working student gets the best grades, gets into the best university or college, and goes on to get the best job.
Suppose students believe they will be assessed and rewarded meritocratically. This can be a positive thing. Without this belief, it may be harder for students to motivate themselves to put in effort at school (Mijs, 2016).
Why the education system is not meritocratic
Many schools promote the idea that the hardest worker gets the best grades, then further education and a good career. Research suggests that education is not truly meritocratic, because students do not have the same opportunity. Six factors stand out:
- School quality: Schools differ in instruction and in their student population. Even within integrated public schools, ability grouping changes the quality of instruction and the learning atmosphere (Mijs, 2016).
- School ratings: Schools are rated by their students’ achievement. Two equally intelligent students at a highly rated and a low-rated school will likely have different learning experiences.
- Resources: A good internet connection, a personal computer, and a well-funded school with quality textbooks all shape learning. Students without them have a different educational experience, whatever their ability.
- Family background: Even when children are similarly talented, their social backgrounds can lead to different quality of education. Parents play an important role (Jackson et al., 2007).
- Social class: When opportunities expand and schools become more inclusive, social class background remains an important predictor of the quality and level of education (Lucas, 2001).
- Elite admissions: Affluent families are over-represented at Ivy League universities. A 2013 study found that 14% of Harvard freshmen had an annual household income over $500,000 (Anasu & Ledecky, 2013).
Official figures for England illustrate the same link between family circumstances and attainment. In state-funded schools in 2025/26, 27.5% of disadvantaged pupils achieved grade 5 or above in English and maths GCSEs.
The figure was 54.3% for pupils not known to be disadvantaged (Department for Education, Key stage 4 performance, released 15 October 2026).
The gap was 26.8 percentage points. It fits the link that Jackson et al. (2007) and Lucas (2001) describe. A meritocratic reading would expect a gap only if ability and effort differed between the groups, and the figures measure neither.
The data have limits. “Disadvantaged” is an administrative marker of family circumstances, not social class. A gap at 16 also cannot separate unequal schooling from differences in prior attainment.
Does Meritocracy Fuel Social Inequality?
Unequal starting points
A meritocratic system rewards the best talent and performance. It assumes that everyone has an equal opportunity to be the best. That is not always the case (Mijs, 2016).
Wealth, geographic area, and quality of schooling all influence an individual’s abilities.
Meritocracy does not consider the structural inequalities and systems of oppression that people face in society. Individuals can have limited opportunities based on their social class, gender, race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, and other social markers.
A flawless meritocracy needs a level playing field. Everyone would need the same opportunities and an equal share of resources.
Too many variables, such as family wealth, social class, race, gender, and nutrition, give some people more opportunity than others.
Researchers have proposed two alternatives in education:
- Principle of need: Compensate for lower talent with a bigger investment of educational resources.
- Principle of equality: Offer all students the same educational opportunities regardless of ability, rather than extra opportunities for high achievers (Mijs, 2016).
How meritocracy can increase bias
The core idea of meritocracy is to avoid inequalities based on social markers. However, it can backfire.
Attempts to implement it can produce the kinds of inequality it aims to eliminate. Castilla and Benard (2010) studied this paradox.
- Aim: To test whether telling managers that their company is meritocratic changes the gender disparities in the pay and evaluations they award.
- Method: Managers were either told explicitly that their company culture was meritocratic or given no such framing. They then awarded pay and evaluation outcomes.
- Results: Managers told the culture was meritocratic awarded larger gender disparities in pay and evaluation than managers who received no such framing.
- Conclusion: Labelling a system meritocratic lowers vigilance about one’s own potential bias. Biased outcomes then pass unchecked.
Being told that a system is meritocratic lowers managers’ vigilance about their own bias. Convinced that the system already sorts people fairly, they scrutinize their own judgements less.
This echoes experimental evidence that priming meritocracy reduces the discrimination people perceive (McCoy & Major, 2007).
Blaming individuals and justifying inequality
Belief in meritocracy shapes how people explain inequality. It has several effects:
- Blame: A meritocratic society can justify blaming individuals for their failings rather than society (Mijs, 2016). An unemployed person’s character and skills are scrutinized, and they may be called ‘lazy’ or ‘unmotivated’.
- Forgotten public issues: Meritocratic policies lead people to forget that personal troubles often reflect wider public issues (Mijs, 2016).
- False hope: Promoting success through talent and effort gives people with less opportunity false hope. Failure can seem justly deserved and can harm self-esteem (Mijs, 2016).
- Acceptance of inequality: People tend to accept inequalities as deserved. This lets them maintain their belief that they live in a fair world (Jost et al., 2004).
- Group interests: It is thought that meritocratic beliefs serve successful societal elites and groups that want to maintain their advantages over others (Mijs, 2016).
People who already have vast family wealth and then succeed can credit their success to their own efforts. They may overlook money and parental encouragement.
Contemporary Research
Since 2015, researchers have asked whether rising economic inequality makes people believe more or less in meritocracy. This matters because belief in meritocracy can make unequal outcomes seem deserved.
Two large survey studies reach opposite answers. The first found that inequality and belief in meritocracy rise together. The second found that they move apart.
Comparing them shows how much study design shapes conclusions.
Does inequality strengthen belief in meritocracy?
Mijs (2021) analyzed 25 years of International Social Survey Programme data from many countries. Citizens of more unequal societies were more likely to explain success in meritocratic terms. They also rated non-meritocratic factors, such as family wealth and connections, as less important.
Mijs argued that this reflects growing economic segregation. As inequality rises, people increasingly live and socialize within their own economic stratum.
They meet fewer people from different backgrounds, so unequal outcomes look individually deserved rather than structurally produced.
Does the finding hold up?
Ehmes and Gangl (2026) tested this “paradox of inequality” with three decades of survey data from 39 advanced capitalist democracies. They did not replicate it.
Instead, belief in meritocracy fell as inequality rose within a country over time. The effect was moderate but robust. Beliefs also became more polarized, with a growing share of citizens skeptical that success is merit-based.
This design tracks change within countries over time, so it is arguably better placed to isolate cause. Even so, this larger test covers only advanced capitalist democracies. Whether inequality bolsters or erodes belief in meritocracy remains an open question.
The Myth of Meritocracy
Marxists believe that meritocracy is a myth. It was made up to legitimize the unjust class system. In this system, the bourgeoisie (the capitalist class) is in charge. The proletariat (the working class) is exploited.
Marxists make three further arguments:
- Acceptance: Meritocratic ideology sets up a way for working-class acceptance that they are working class and always will be.
- Early disadvantage: Working-class children start school with disadvantages, such as material deprivation and fewer resources.
- Cultural capital: Middle-class parents provide cultural capital (e.g., skills, knowledge, and attitudes). They are better able than working-class parents to use these skills to get their children into the best schools.
Therefore, the working class cannot have the same chances as people from higher social classes.
Young’s original warning
Michael Young did not advocate meritocracy. He coined the term in a satire, The Rise of the Meritocracy (Young, 1958).
The book is a fictional report from the year 2033. Britain has replaced its class system with one in which status follows a formula: IQ plus effort equals merit.
Young’s imagined Britain becomes more unequal, not less.
Under the old class system, a poor person could at least believe the system itself was unfair. Under a ‘fair’ meritocracy, failure becomes evidence of personal inadequacy.
No external cause is left to blame.
More than forty years later, Young (2001) wrote that he was alarmed. The term had been adopted as a positive goal, particularly by the British political establishment. Meritocracy, he concluded, would bring dystopia and prolonged inequality.
As Young (2001) explained, sorting everyone by measured ability and effort would concentrate power and self-regard in a narrow elite. That elite would be convinced of its superior worth. It would also remove the solidarity between rich and poor that had restrained inequality.
The Psychology of Believing in Meritocracy
If education and society fall short of the meritocratic ideal, why does belief in meritocracy persist? Social psychology offers two answers: belief in a just world and system justification.
Both treat the belief as something that performs a function for the believer, whatever its accuracy.
Belief in a just world
People are strongly motivated to believe that individuals generally get what they deserve. An innocent person suffering threatens that belief. Observers must resolve the threat somehow.
Lerner and Simmons (1966) ran the classic test.
- Aim: To test how observers respond when an apparently innocent person suffers. Do they blame the victim rather than revise their belief that the world is fair?
- Method: Female undergraduates watched a peer apparently receive painful electric shocks for errors on a learning task. Researchers varied whether observers could compensate her, expected further suffering, or saw her as a martyr.
- Results: Observers who could not help her, and expected more suffering, rated her as less likeable and less admirable. This was strongest when she suffered on their behalf and largely absent when they could compensate her.
- Conclusion: People have a basic need to believe the world is just. Unable to help an innocent victim, observers reinterpret her character so that her suffering seems deserved.
This finding became the empirical foundation of belief-in-a-just-world theory. It is also the ancestor of reasoning about meritocracy.
If the world is assumed to be just, unequal income, status, and opportunity are easily read as earned rather than as accidents of birth or circumstance.
System justification and priming meritocracy
System-justification theory (Jost & Banaji, 1994) goes further.
It proposes that people defend and rationalize the social, economic, and political arrangements they live under, even arrangements that disadvantage themselves or their group.
Meritocratic ideology is one of its tools. It supplies a ready explanation for the hierarchy: talent and effort. McCoy and Major (2007) tested this experimentally.
- Aim: To test whether priming meritocratic beliefs makes people justify status inequality, including inequality that disadvantages them or their group.
- Method: Lower-status group members completed a meritocracy prime or a neutral prime across two experiments. In the second, women read about prejudice inside their own university or against an outside group, then reported perceived discrimination and status-justifying stereotypes.
- Results: Priming led lower-status group members to justify their own and their group’s disadvantage. They saw less discrimination within their own system and used more status-justifying stereotypes, but the effect was weaker for outside groups.
- Conclusion: Meritocratic beliefs help disadvantaged groups cope with lower status by legitimizing it, but only within the system the ideology governs. Believing in meritocracy changes how much discrimination people are willing to perceive.
Together, these studies explain the persistence of the meritocracy myth.
People hold the belief because it protects their sense that the world is fair, not because the evidence for it is strong. It serves advantaged and disadvantaged people alike.
Jost et al. (2004) reviewed system-justification research more broadly. They concluded that the tendency to rationalize the status quo, including economic inequality, operates largely outside conscious awareness. It is not confined to those who benefit.
Do people overestimate social mobility?
Belief in meritocracy also depends on the assumption that talent and effort can move people up the social ladder. Do people judge that mobility accurately?
Kraus and Tan (2015) tested this.
- Aim: To test whether Americans overestimate the true rate of social-class mobility, and to explore why.
- Method: Four studies compared participants’ mobility estimates with official statistics. They measured or manipulated subjective social class, and varied beliefs about genetic determinants of class and how personally relevant the estimate felt.
- Results: Participants substantially overestimated upward mobility, especially if younger or higher in subjective class. Stressing genetic and biological limits reduced the overestimate; making the question personally relevant increased it.
- Conclusion: Americans hold an inflated, motivated belief that the class structure is open. It lets people see their own future position as more changeable and controllable than official statistics suggest.
A pre-registered self-replication (Kraus, 2015) tested the same prediction with 763 online participants. It reproduced the pattern with a large effect.
Overestimates were again larger for personally relevant judgements, and higher subjective class again predicted larger overestimates. This held after controlling for objective class, knowledge of mobility rates, age, and political ideology.
Measurement remains disputed. Chambers et al. (2015) used a different method and found that Americans underestimated current mobility.
Davidai and Gilovich (2018) replied that more ecologically representative measures consistently show overestimation. They argued that the earlier method inadvertently primed participants to think about immobility.
Most of the studies above use American samples. Meritocracy is a historically and culturally specific ideology, so the same mechanisms may not operate identically in societies with different histories of stratification. Generalize these findings cautiously.
References
Anasu, L., & Ledecky, M. D. (2013). Freshman survey part II: An uncommon app. The Harvard Crimson.
Castilla, E. J., & Benard, S. (2010). The paradox of meritocracy in organizations. Administrative Science Quarterly, 55(4), 543–676.
Chambers, J. R., Swan, L. K., & Heesacker, M. (2015). Perceptions of U.S. social mobility are divided (and distorted) along ideological lines. Psychological Science, 26(4), 413–423. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797614566657
Davidai, S., & Gilovich, T. (2018). How should we think about Americans’ beliefs about economic mobility? Judgment and Decision Making, 13(3), 297–304. https://doi.org/10.1017/s1930297500007737
Davis, K., & Moore, W. E. (1945). Some principles of stratification. American Sociological Review, 10(2), 242–249.
Ehmes, S., & Gangl, M. (2026). The paradox of inequality that isn’t: Rising economic inequality depresses and polarizes citizens’ belief in meritocracy. Socio-Economic Review, 24(3), 1643–1663. https://doi.org/10.1093/ser/mwag016
Erivwo, A., Varghese, E., Mathai, A., & Afrin, T. (2021). Meritocracy in the educational system. Across the Spectrum of Socioeconomics, 4, 275.
Jackson, M., Erikson, R., Goldthorpe, J. H., & Yaish, M. (2007). Primary and secondary effects in class differentials in educational attainment: The transition to A-level courses in England and Wales. Acta Sociologica, 50(3), 211–229.
Jost, J. T., & Banaji, M. R. (1994). The role of stereotyping in system-justification and the production of false consciousness. British Journal of Social Psychology, 33(1), 1–27. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8309.1994.tb01008.x
Jost, J. T., Banaji, M. R., & Nosek, B. A. (2004). A decade of system justification theory: Accumulated evidence of conscious and unconscious bolstering of the status quo. Political Psychology, 25(6), 881–919.
Kim, C. H., & Choi, Y. B. (2017). How meritocracy is defined today? Contemporary aspects of meritocracy. Economics & Sociology, 10(1), 112.
Kraus, M. W. (2015). Americans still overestimate social class mobility: A pre-registered self-replication. Frontiers in Psychology, 6, Article 1709. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.01709
Kraus, M. W., & Tan, J. J. X. (2015). Americans overestimate social class mobility. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 58, 101–111. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2015.01.005
Lerner, M. J., & Simmons, C. H. (1966). Observer’s reaction to the “innocent victim”: Compassion or rejection? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 4(2), 203–210. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0023562
Liu, A. (2011). Unraveling the myth of meritocracy within the context of US higher education. Higher Education, 62(4), 383–397.
Lucas, S. R. (2001). Effectively maintained inequality: Education transitions, track mobility, and social background effects. American Journal of Sociology, 106(6), 1642–1690.
McCoy, S. K., & Major, B. (2007). Priming meritocracy and the psychological justification of inequality. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 43(3), 341–351. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2006.04.009
Mijs, J. J. (2016). The unfulfillable promise of meritocracy: Three lessons and their implications for justice in education. Social Justice Research, 29(1), 14–34.
Mijs, J. J. B. (2021). The paradox of inequality: Income inequality and belief in meritocracy go hand in hand. Socio-Economic Review, 19(1), 7–35. https://doi.org/10.1093/ser/mwy051
Young, M. (2001, June 29). Down with meritocracy. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment
Young, M. D. (1958). The rise of the meritocracy. Transaction Publishers.
