Modernization Theory

Modernization theory is the mid-twentieth-century idea that poor countries develop by replacing traditional customs and institutions with modern ones, following the same path today’s rich, industrialised nations already took.

Key Takeaways

  • Core Idea: Modernization theory is a sociological and economic approach to development (Knöbl, 2003). Rooted in functionalist sociology, it holds that societies travel one path from traditional to modern, driven by internal factors.
  • Cold War Origins: The theory took shape in the late 1940s and 1950s as an explicitly non-communist answer to global poverty, built on a capitalist model of industrial development.
  • Rostow’s Comparison: W. W. Rostow compared developed and undeveloped nations, treating gaps in technology, capital and entrepreneurship as the explanation for the developing world’s poverty.
  • Internal Focus: The theory looks at a country’s own institutions and values, and holds that external aid can help traditional societies follow the same path richer nations already took.
  • Modern Practices: Adopting modern economic practices and dismantling traditional norms are, on this account, vital to progress.
  • Modern Evidence: Real income convergence, with poor countries catching up with rich ones, has now begun. It came decades later than the theory predicted, and for different reasons (Kremer, Willis, & You, 2022).
Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Origins of the Theory

Modernization theory finds its origin in the ideas of Max Weber, the German sociologist. Weber studied a traditional society, one built on subsistence agriculture, custom and kinship, as it moved toward a modern one (Mayhew, 1985; Dibua, 2006).

Weber’s approach later became the foundation for the modernization paradigm developed by Harvard sociologist Talcott Parsons.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Parsons translated Weber’s writings and added his own interpretation. He then built an approach meant to help poor nations overcome what he saw as the obstacles to development.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Modernization theory took shape in the late 1940s. It aimed to address third-world poverty with an explicitly non-communist solution: a capitalist model of industrialized development and Western democratic values.

In the aftermath of WWII, many Asian, African and Latin American nations, despite some prior exposure to capitalism, remained poor and largely un-industrialized. The West was alarmed. It saw fertile ground for violent revolution and Soviet-aligned communism.

The Cold War shaped the theory in three concrete ways.

  • Funding: much of the field’s research ran through well-funded university centers focused on foreign-policy questions, including the Harvard project behind the six-country study discussed below (Inkeles, 1969).
  • Personnel: Rostow advised the Kennedy and Johnson administrations and helped shape US policy toward Latin America, so his stages model circulated as government doctrine, not just scholarship.
  • Framing: Rostow subtitled his book A Non-Communist Manifesto, a title that states the work’s political purpose as plainly as any critic could (Rostow, 1960).

Characteristics of Modernization Theory

The features of modernization theory are chiefly twofold:

Modernization theory makes this case in two parts. First, it explains poverty. Cultural norms in the poorer countries of Latin America, Africa and Asia were treated as the primary impediment to progress. Internal institutions, customs, governance and economic practices were held responsible before any external cause was considered.

Second, it prescribes a solution. These nations would need to adopt industrial practices such as large-scale factory production in place of small home workshops. They would also need a capitalist system in which private capital runs industry and goods are manufactured for large markets rather than individual consumption.

The Single-Path Assumption

Underneath these two parts sits a single assumption: that societies travel a single path from “traditional” to “modern” (Parsons, 1951, 1964). Rich and poor countries differ in position on that path, not in kind.

The assumption is inherited. Ferdinand Tönnies contrasted community with association. Émile Durkheim contrasted the solidarity of similarity with the solidarity of the division of labour. Max Weber described rationalization. Modernization theory applied the same opposition to whole nations rather than historical epochs.

Two features of this move cause most of the later criticism:

  • Residual Category: “traditional” is defined by the absence of modern features, not by any account of how such societies work.
  • Direction: movement along the path counts as progress, so description and value judgement blur together.

The assumption does have one virtue: it is testable. If societies converge as they develop, long-run data should show poor countries catching up with rich ones.

Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Parsons’ Pattern Variables

Talcott Parsons named five paired choices that shape any social relationship, called the pattern variables (Parsons, 1951; Parsons & Shils, 1951). Traditional societies cluster on one side of each pair. Modern societies cluster on the other.

  • Affectivity: emotional closeness, as within a family, versus emotional restraint, as between an official and an applicant.
  • Self vs. Collectivity: pursuing one’s own interests, or subordinating them to a group.
  • Universalism vs. Particularism: judging people by general rules, or by their relationship to the person judging them.
  • Achievement vs. Ascription: being judged by what a person does, or by what they are by birth.
  • Specificity vs. Diffuseness: a relationship confined to one purpose, or one that extends across many parts of life.

This scheme is what makes particularism and universalism, discussed below, more than just examples. They are two of Parsons’ five defining dimensions, and the theory holds that a modernising society has to shift along all five together.

Evolutionary Universals and Structural Differentiation

Parsons later gave the framework an evolutionary form.

He argued that certain institutional complexes, which he called evolutionary universals, greatly raise a society’s capacity to adapt. Societies that acquire them tend to prevail (Parsons, 1964).

His list includes bureaucratic organization, money and market exchange, a universalistic legal system and democratic association. The list reads as a description of mid-century Western institutions. That is where the theory turns most normative.

The mechanism that carries societies between the two poles is structural differentiation. Functions once bundled into one institution, typically the extended family, split off into specialized ones.

Factories take over production. Schools take over education. Hospitals and states take over welfare.

On the functionalist account, this makes a change in values structurally necessary. A specialized, achievement-based job market cannot be staffed through particularistic kin obligation. Values must change along with institutions.

Examples of Modernization

  • The eradication of smallpox: a coordinated vaccination campaign, backed by the USSR and the United States, eliminated a disease that had killed millions. The last case came in 1977, with eradication certified in 1980.
  • The Green Revolution (Hazell, 2009): The third agricultural revolution transferred high-yielding crop varieties, fertiliser and irrigation to regions such as India and Mexico. It played a major part in averting the widespread famine predicted for South Asia in the 1970s.

The Green Revolution combined scientific farming methods with modern management techniques, and it cut poverty and infant mortality (Hazell, 2009). It also has a well-documented downside.

The gains favoured larger farmers with access to irrigation and credit. The heavy use of fertiliser and water also carried environmental costs the original programme never budgeted for.

  • Indonesia’s breakthroughs (Prozorovskii, 2016): The 1970s saw Indonesia’s gradual transition to a modernized economy. Western assistance to President Suharto’s anti-communist new order was accompanied by the creation of industrial conglomerates.

The dominance of the military and intelligence agencies assured political stability and permitted sustained investment. Yet the administration was far from ideal.

Indonesia under Suharto suffered the suppression of human rights, corruption and nepotism (Prozorovskii, 2016).

Development Policy and Aid

Modernization theory’s practical legacy is a policy programme and the institutions built to deliver it, from international lenders to national aid agencies. Both long outlived the theory. Much of the contemporary debate about development is conducted through arguments about how these institutions should behave.

The sections below take the policy instruments, the institutions that delivered them, and the goals that replaced them in turn.

Five Policy Instruments

The theory locates the obstacles inside poor countries and treats the path as already known. Its policy programme follows almost mechanically. Five instruments recur:

  • Capital Transfer: aid, loans or foreign investment bridge the saving gap and tip an economy over the take-off threshold.
  • Technology Transfer: poor countries adopt existing industrial and agricultural technology instead of reinventing it. The Green Revolution is the paradigm case.
  • Education: schooling spreads the skills and values of a modern economy. It outlasted the theory that justified it.
  • Institution-Building: training civil servants, codifying law and creating central banks builds the impersonal institutions modern societies rely on.
  • Population Policy: family planning programmes target high fertility, which the theory saw as a drag on capital per head. It is the most contested item.

The logic is coherent, and that is part of its appeal. But it is also where the theory is most exposed.

Every instrument is delivered by rich countries and international institutions to poor ones. That reproduces the asymmetry critics say causes the problem.

Aid Institutions and Structural Adjustment

Modernization theory supplied the intellectual case for post-war development assistance. The International Monetary Fund and the World Bank became its central multilateral instruments. United Nations programmes and bilateral donor agencies grew up around them.

From the 1980s, aid increasingly came with conditions. Structural adjustment tied loans to requirements that governments liberalize trade, cut public spending and reduce state intervention.

It drew sharp criticism. The conditions were often the opposite of the state-led strategies the successful East Asian industrializers had used.

A partial correction came with the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries initiative of 1996. It funded debt relief for the poorest countries in return for a poverty-reduction strategy.

From the Millennium Development Goals to the SDGs

The Millennium Development Goals, agreed in the late 1990s with a 2015 deadline, turned development into measurable targets. One was to halve the proportion of people living on less than a dollar a day between 1990 and 2015.

Several targets were not met.

Their successor, the Sustainable Development Goals, keeps the idea of common outcomes. It departs from classical modernization theory in three ways:

  • Universal Scope: the goals apply to rich and poor countries alike, not to a journey the poor must make toward the rich.
  • Sustainability: they include environmental sustainability, which the original model of industrial growth did not contain.
  • Outcomes: they are framed around health, education, gender equality and inequality rather than one path of economic modernization.

Impediments to Development

Parsons characterized many indigenous practices, rituals and institutions as utterly hostile to progress. He attributed the paucity of social and geographical mobility in many poor nations to tribal systems and traditional kinship obligations.

He identified four particular cultural values as barriers to development (Parsons, 1951, 1964):

  • Collectivism: loyalty to the group over the individual creates obligations, such as leaving school early to work the family farm.
  • Particularism: roles and jobs go to relatives and friends instead of the most capable people.
  • Discrimination Against Women: patriarchal structures and unequal schooling keep women out of economic and political power.
  • Fatalism: the belief that birth fixes one’s station in life discourages effort and upward mobility.

Collectivism

An emphasis on group identity over individual identity can create obligations that impede individual development. The clearest example is the expectation that children leave school early to help with family farming.

From a household’s point of view this choice is rational: a child’s labor is worth more right now than their schooling will be worth later. The trade-off is real, not imagined. In aggregate, though, it depresses the stock of human capital a country needs to industrialize.

The same logic applies whenever a successful person’s earnings are claimed by a wide circle of kin. This reduces both the incentive and the capacity to save and reinvest.

Particularism

The allocation of roles based on familial relations in many poor countries diminished opportunities available for competent and talented people.

When a government official or a CEO gives a job based on blood-kinship, ethnic identity or friendship rather than merit, the best available talent goes unused. The nation’s human capital is underutilized as a result.

Modernization theorists did not read this as ordinary corruption. They treated it as the normal operation of a particularistic value system. That is why they thought it could not be fixed by enforcement alone: the problem was cultural, not criminal.

Discrimination against women

Entrenched patriarchal structures in many poor countries often impeded the rise of women to positions of economic and political power. Additionally, the lack of educational opportunities available for women would aggravate the situation, as most women would be ill-equipped to assume such roles.

Consequently, nearly half of a nation’s labor force would be placed on a vicious cycle of disempowerment and underutilization.

Fatalism/Ascribed status

When an individual’s birth is construed as determining his or her ultimate station in life, upward mobility is significantly hindered.

India’s caste system for instance, categorized individuals into Brahmins (priests), Kshatriyas (warriors and rulers), Vaisyas (skilled traders, merchants and minor officials), Sudras (unskilled workers), and Harijans (the untouchable outcastes).

Such division meant people stayed within their own caste. Fatalism is the belief that one’s hardship and station in life are fixed and unavoidable. It often followed: people resigned themselves to the status assigned to them and saw little point in effort or ambition.

Causes of Progress

By contrast, Parsons held that three culturally embedded Western norms accounted for the development of the industrialized nations by promoting economic growth and competition (Parsons, 1951, 1964):

  • Universalism: judging everyone by the same standards makes the rule of law predictable, which attracts investment.
  • Individualism: freedom from family and tribal expectations lets people pursue education, start businesses and choose unconventional careers.
  • Meritocracy: effort rather than connections decides success, so talent ends up where it is most productive.

Universalism

This is the antithesis of particularism. Herein, individuals are judged by universal standards applicable, in principle, to everyone in society. In other words, judgments do not depend upon a subject’s relationship to the adjudicator.

In such societies, the rule of law is upheld. This predictability supports long-term stability. Environments like this are more prone to attract investments and entrepreneurs than corrupt societies characterized by nepotism.

Individualism

When individual freedom and personal responsibility are valued over collectivist norms, people are no more required to constantly live up to the expectations of their families or tribal groups.

Consequently, individuals gain the liberty to pursue educational opportunities of their choice, set up businesses, and start unconventional careers. They are no longer strictly bound to roles assigned by others, such as working on a family farm.

Meritocracy/Achieved status

In more meritocratic societies, individual effort determines success more than family connections to power. When meritocracy is genuinely practiced, the most competent and hardworking people rise to the top, improving the match between talent and position and spurring economic growth.

Real societies rarely match this ideal. Family wealth, connections and inherited advantage still shape who reaches the top, even in highly developed economies.

Rostow’s 5-Stage Model

Rostow compared developed countries with developing countries (Rostow, 1959, 1960):

Stage I: Traditional Society

At this inaugural stage, traditional societies depend on rural economies built around subsistence agriculture and barter, with little access to technology or industry. Output per person stays low, and so does its ceiling: the available technology places a hard limit on how productive the economy can become.

Little surplus is generated, so little wealth exists for investment. What surplus there is tends to be consumed, or spent on status display and religious observance, rather than reinvested.

Modernization theorists added a cultural explanation on top of this: a weak work ethic and a fatalistic outlook that treats hardship as simply the unavoidable condition of life. Rostow’s own image captures the stage well. The aircraft is on the ground, engines off.

Stage II: Preconditions for Take-Off

This is a transitional stage of specialization, production surpluses and infrastructure building. Rostow thought an external shock or stimulus normally set it in motion, rather than it arising spontaneously.

Science and technology improve agriculture, and aid helps build highways and communications. Skills develop, and education is valued more. Western companies start establishing manufacturing plants.

Banks and other institutions able to mobilize savings appear, and a centralized state with an interest in economic development typically emerges.

None of this is yet self-sustaining growth. It creates the conditions under which self-sustaining growth becomes possible.

Stage III: Take-Off

This is the take-off stage: investment rises sharply as a share of national income, typically within two or three decades. The pace quickens fast. One or more manufacturing sectors grow rapidly and start pulling the rest of the economy along, while a supportive political and institutional framework takes hold.

The nation moves beyond subsistence, exporting manufactured goods instead of only raw materials. A domestic entrepreneurial class emerges that is willing to take real risks.

Reinvestment becomes routine rather than exceptional. Growth turns self-reinforcing. It no longer needs the outside push that started it.

This is the moment the aircraft leaves the runway. It is also the stage at which modernization theorists thought foreign aid could make the biggest difference. A modest injection of capital at the right moment could tip an economy over the threshold.

Stage IV: Drive to Maturity

This is a long period, something like the sixty years following take-off, in which modern technology spreads from the original leading sectors to the whole economy. Investment stays high. The industrial base diversifies well beyond where it started.

The economy becomes able to produce more or less whatever it chooses, not just what its existing resources happen to allow.

Dependence on imports falls as domestic capacity broadens, and skills, management and technological competence all deepen. The shift compounds over decades.

The workforce grows more urban, more literate and more highly trained. New opportunities open up, and people strive to make the most of them. The aircraft climbs steadily toward cruising altitude.

Official figures show the pattern this stage describes.

In 2025, 35.2% of people in low-income countries lived in urban areas (World Bank, Urban population (% of total population), database updated 13 July 2026). The share was 55.4% in middle-income countries, 80.2% in high-income countries and 57.8% for the world.

Schooling follows the same order. In 2024, the gross secondary enrollment ratio was 41.5% in low-income countries (World Bank, School enrolment, secondary (% gross), database updated 13 July 2026). It was 79.1% in middle-income countries, 103.2% in high-income countries and 77.3% for the world.

These figures illustrate Rostow’s stage description. They do not prove that cities or schools cause development.

Higher incomes could pay for cities and schools, or an unequal place in the world economy could produce both.

These are snapshots of country income groups, so they cannot show the order in which urbanization, schooling and income changed within any country. Gross enrollment counts attendance, not learning, and a ratio can exceed 100% because it counts pupils of any age against the school-age population.

Stage V: The Age of High Mass Consumption

In the final stage, leading industries shift toward consumer durables and services. Growth broadens further. Real incomes rise to the point where large numbers of people can buy considerably more than basic necessities, and the service sector becomes dominant.

Societies at this stage face a genuine choice about what to do with their surplus. Rostow argued it could go into consumption, into welfare provision, or into projecting power abroad. This is where his economic model turns most explicitly political.

Living standards approach those of the already-industrialized nations. The aircraft is in level flight.

Two qualifications apply to the whole model. First, the order is often garbled. Secondary accounts sometimes put high mass consumption fourth. Rostow placed the drive to maturity fourth and high mass consumption last, because mass consumption presupposes the broad industrial base that maturity supplies.

Second, the model is a generalization, not a forecast. Rostow built it from the countries that industrialized early. Whether it works as a predictive schedule for later industrializers is exactly what critics dispute (Rostow, 1959, 1960).

More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

The Cultural and Psychological Strand

Alongside Rostow’s economic stages, a related line of work asked what a “modern” individual actually believes and does, and whether that mindset can be deliberately produced.

This strand produced most of the theory’s actual empirical research. It is therefore where the strongest evidence for and against the theory is found.

Hoselitz: Education as a Lever

Bert Hoselitz took Parsons’ pattern variables and applied them to economic growth. He argued that the shift from particularism to universalism, and from ascription to achievement, was a precondition for development rather than a side effect of it (Hoselitz, 1960).

His practical focus was education. Formal schooling does two things at once. It teaches the skills a modern economy needs, and it weakens a child’s exclusive attachment to the family by judging them against universal, impersonal standards.

Lerner: Media and Psychic Mobility

Daniel Lerner told a different story about how people become modern.

His survey research across Middle Eastern countries put the mass media at the centre of the picture. Exposure to newspapers, radio and film, he argued, cultivates empathy: the ability to imagine a life different from one’s own (Lerner, 1958).

This “psychic mobility” makes physical and social mobility thinkable. Alex Inkeles made a related point, stressing how media exposure spreads ideas such as democratic participation and family planning. But it was Lerner, not Inkeles, who built the empathy argument that gives this strand its name.

McClelland: The Need for Achievement

David McClelland’s work is the most psychologically explicit version of modernization theory’s internal-obstacles argument. This is the claim that the causes of underdevelopment lie inside poor countries, in their own values and institutions, rather than in their relationships with richer nations.

  • Aim: to test whether the need for achievement, a drive to meet a standard of excellence for its own sake, causes national economic growth rather than merely following it (McClelland, 1961).
  • Method: McClelland’s team content-analysed children’s school readers from 23 countries, around 1925 and 1950, scoring the stories for achievement imagery. National scores were then related to later growth in electricity production per head.
  • Results: achievement imagery in the earlier readers was linked to faster growth decades later, with motivation coming before growth rather than the reverse.
  • Conclusion: achievement motivation, instilled in childhood, is a genuine cause of development, not just a consequence of it.

The design is ingenious. But the evidence is weaker than it looks. The study is ecological: nothing shows the individuals who drove growth were the ones with high achievement motivation. Children’s readers are also a very indirect proxy for the motives of a working-age population.

The country sample was small and non-random. Electricity production is also sensitive to industrial structure and state investment decisions.

McClelland drew a practical lesson from the work: policy should raise achievement motivation directly, through training for entrepreneurs and managers.

Inkeles and Smith: The Six-Country Study

The largest empirical study in the whole tradition was a Harvard project asking whether “individual modernity” is a real, measurable psychological pattern (Inkeles, 1969; Inkeles & Smith, 1974).

  • Aim: to determine whether exposure to modernization produces a consistent set of modern attitudes and behaviours, and to identify which experiences produce it.
  • Method: the team interviewed about 6,000 men in Argentina, Chile, India, Israel, Nigeria and what was then East Pakistan. Cultivators, craftsmen and industrial workers were compared on a purpose-built Overall Modernity scale (Smith & Inkeles, 1966).
  • Results: the same cluster of attitudes turned up in all six countries: openness to new experience, independence from traditional authority, and active civic participation. Education was the single strongest predictor, and factory work also mattered on its own.
  • Conclusion: individual modernity is a real, cross-culturally consistent pattern, produced by specific institutional experiences rather than fixed by culture, and can therefore be deliberately cultivated.

Men from very traditional, little-schooled backgrounds could still become modern as adults. Exposure to migration and modern institutions was not linked to psychic distress.

The sample was entirely male. The design was cross-sectional too, so it cannot show that schooling and factory work caused the modern attitudes, rather than simply attracting people who already had them.

The scale was also built from a prior idea of what modernity is, so the study may have recovered the theory’s own assumptions. And modern attitudes clustering together does not show they cause national development.

Rival Theories of Development

Several rival accounts displaced or challenged modernization theory. They disagree about where the causes of poverty lie and what should be done about it.

  • Dependency Theory: poverty is caused by a poor country’s exploitative position in the world economy.
  • Market and State: the key constraint is either too much government or too little.
  • Rethinking Development: development should be judged by people’s freedoms, or rejected as a Western construct.

Dependency Theory and World-Systems Analysis

Dependency theory is modernization theory’s direct rival and the tradition that displaced it in sociology. Modernization theory places the cause of underdevelopment inside the poor country. Dependency theory places it outside, in the country’s exploitative position within the world economy (Ahiakpor, 1985).

The two disagree about more than which variables matter.

For modernization theorists, a poor country’s relationship with rich countries is a temporary gap to be closed by emulation. For dependency theorists, it is a structural relationship to be renegotiated or broken.

World-systems analysis extends dependency theory. It replaces pairs of rich and poor countries with one capitalist world economy divided into core, periphery and semi-periphery.

Modernization theory takes the nation-state as its unit of analysis, so it cannot see a structure that exists only at the level of the whole system.

Each side has a reply. Modernization theorists point to East Asia, where economies that engaged heavily with foreign trade, aid and investment grew rapidly.

Dependency theorists answer that modernization theory has no account of colonialism. They have themselves paid little attention to indigenous institutions such as caste and slavery.

Market-Led and State-Led Development

Neoliberal theory kept modernization theory’s optimism about markets but dropped most of its sociology. It holds that government interference is the decisive constraint and that unrestricted capitalism is the route to growth.

This became the prevailing view among economists from the 1980s. It supplied the doctrine behind structural-adjustment conditionality.

Developmental-state theories invert the premise: appropriate government policy produces development. The evidence comes largely from East Asia.

Governments there steered credit toward favoured industries, owned key industries outright and invested heavily in universal education. In several cases they secured political stability coercively, by outlawing unions.

Even the World Bank, long a proponent of market-led theory, concluded by the late 1990s that sustainable development is not possible without an effective state.

For modernization theory this is a serious challenge. The countries that most conspicuously succeeded did so by methods the theory did not recommend.

Capability and Post-Development Critiques

Amartya Sen’s capability approach rejects the terms of the whole debate. Development, he argues, is the expansion of people’s substantive freedoms, their real capabilities to be and do what they have reason to value. It is not growth in income, output or consumption (Sen, 1999).

Two consequences follow for modernization theory. There is no single development path, since societies may value different capabilities. And output per head becomes a proxy of uncertain quality rather than a definition of development.

The approach underlies composite measures of health, education and living standards.

Post-development theory goes furthest. Escobar (1995) argues that development is not a neutral goal but a post-war discourse.

It produced the “underdeveloped world” as an object of expert intervention and made Western industrial society the measure of every other society’s worth.

This is the sharpest statement of the Eurocentrism critique, and it sits within the wider rejection of grand narratives of progress found in postmodernism.

A serious objection is that it risks aestheticizing poverty. Material deprivation and preventable disease are not discursive constructions.

Critical Evaluation

Modernization theory is now heavily criticized, and much of that criticism is well founded. Six objections carry the most weight.

  1. Eurocentrism: the theory treats the historical path of Western Europe and North America as the universal standard every society should follow.
  2. Neglect of Colonialism: it locates the causes of poverty inside poor countries, saying almost nothing about colonial history or unequal trade.
  3. Weak Psychological Evidence: the individual-modernity research the theory generated has serious measurement problems.
  4. The Aid Critique: foreign aid is said to displace local initiative, though the modern evidence on this is more mixed than either side claims.
  5. Cultural Imperialism and the Family: the theory’s push to change traditional family structures has been read as neocolonial.
  6. Conceptual Imprecision: critics argued that “modernization” was used so loosely that it lost analytical meaning, describing a general impression of progress rather than a precise, testable claim.

Eurocentrism

The most persistent criticism is that the theory takes the West’s historical trajectory as the universal measure of progress. “Modern” is defined by a list of features drawn from mid-century Western societies. “Traditional” is defined simply as their absence.

This structure carries an assumption the theory never actually establishes: that other societies want to become more like the West. Its own advocates rarely examined that assumption. Judging one culture by another’s standards is a general problem, and it runs through the whole framework.

Neglect of Colonialism

Much of the criticism stems from dependency theory. It blames colonial powers, not backward customs, for the developing world’s poverty (Ahiakpor, 1985).

Dependency theorists argue that the export of raw materials from poor countries, and the import of manufactured goods from rich ones, keeps this imbalance in place. It is fair to note, though, that dependency theorists have themselves paid little attention to indigenous institutions such as caste systems and slavery.

The colonial record itself is telling. The societies the theory called traditional in the 1950s were not in a pristine pre-modern state. Most had spent decades or even centuries inside colonial economies built around exporting raw materials.

Two lines of evidence show how much this mattered:

  • Settler Mortality: where European settler mortality was high, colonizers built extractive rather than settler institutions. Those institutions still depress income today (Acemoglu, Johnson, & Robinson, 2001).
  • The Slave Trades: the regions of Africa hit hardest by the slave trades remain the poorest today, even after controlling for other factors (Nunn, 2008, 2020).

The theory misidentified the cause.

Weak Psychological Evidence

The strand of the theory that produced the most research also has the shakiest foundations.

Armer and Schnaiberg (1972) put the individual-modernity scales to a direct validity test.

  • Aim: to test whether the modernity scales then in use measured a distinct construct or merely re-measured familiar sociological variables under a new name.
  • Method: four modernity scales, including the Smith and Inkeles OM scale, were given to the same married men in Chicago. Anomie (a sense of normlessness), alienation and socioeconomic status were also measured.
  • Results: the scales agreed only moderately, with correlations of about .40 to .64. They predicted anomie, alienation and, to a lesser extent, socioeconomic status about as well as they predicted each other.
  • Conclusion: the findings call into serious question the meaningfulness of individual modernity, its measurement, or both.

That is a real problem. If a purpose-built scale for a new construct predicts alienation as well as it predicts itself, the construct is not doing independent work.

The Inkeles and Smith study adds to the doubt.

Its all-male, cross-sectional design cannot show that schooling and factory work caused modern attitudes, rather than simply attracting people who already had them.

McClelland’s work has a related problem: it cannot rule out that achievement imagery and later growth both trace back to some third factor, such as prior state capacity.

The Aid Critique

Critics of foreign aid argue that it undermines local initiative and knowledge by substituting foreign expertise and foreign money.

Critics also stress its dehumanizing effect on local populations.

The modern evidence does not support the strongest version of this objection.

A meta-analysis of the aid-and-growth literature found that aid’s positive effect on growth holds up across different time horizons and survives tests for publication bias (Mekasha & Tarp, 2019). A separate long-run study reaches a similar conclusion (Arndt, Jones, & Tarp, 2015).

Nor does the evidence support the theory’s original confidence. The estimated effect is modest and highly variable, and it comes from data that cannot fully solve the problem that aid is not handed out at random.

Cultural Imperialism and the Family

A final criticism concerns the family.

The theory’s treatment of traditional family structures as an obstacle to development has itself been read as an instrument of cultural imperialism. The international promotion of family and population policies has drawn sustained criticism from scholars including Professor Mary Ann Glendon of Harvard Law School (Glendon, 1999).

This criticism is hard to answer. Modernization theory explicitly proposes changing family structure as a development goal, and does so on the authority of outside experts rather than the populations concerned.

Conceptual Imprecision

A different kind of criticism came from within the field itself, not from a rival theory. Tipps (1973) argued that “modernization” spread so widely it stopped meaning any one thing.

The number of definitions in use came close to matching the number of authors using the term. The word had become elastic.

Its popularity rested on the vague, positive image it evoked, not on analytical precision. Both critics and supporters assumed the idea was basically sound, so the concept itself went largely unexamined.

A parallel objection followed.

Bernstein (1971) pressed the same point against the theory’s two core assumptions. Modernisation, he argued, is not really one single process covering a whole society, and it does not follow one universal pattern. Neither claim survives close scrutiny.

The consequence is that “modernization” could mean almost anything a given author needed. That makes the theory harder to test, and easier to defend against any single piece of contrary evidence.

Neo-Modernization Theory

By the late 1970s, sociologists had largely abandoned classical modernization theory. It then returned in revised form. The evolutionary modernization programme of Ronald Inglehart and Christian Welzel drew on repeated waves of the World Values Survey and the European Values Study.

Inglehart and Baker (2000) analyzed survey data from dozens of societies containing most of the world’s population. Economic development was associated with a systematic movement of values away from traditional authority and toward secular-rational and self-expression values.

The revision keeps the central claim. Development still produces broadly predictable changes in mass values. But it changes that claim in three ways:

  • Probabilistic: development changes the likelihood of particular value shifts rather than driving every society through a fixed sequence.
  • Path-Dependent: a society’s cultural and religious heritage leaves an enduring imprint, so societies move in parallel directions rather than converging on one destination (Inglehart & Baker, 2000).
  • Human Development Sequence: socioeconomic development spreads self-expression values, which in turn drive democratization (Inglehart & Welzel, 2005).

This is the strongest contemporary form of the modernization thesis. It still assumes that development has a direction. Critics also say its survey instruments define “emancipative” values in terms drawn from the societies that score highest on them.

But the programme is empirically serious, and it has revised itself in response to results.

Contemporary Research

Research since 2015 has tested modernization theory’s predictions directly, because long time-series on incomes, values and institutions have finally accumulated. The four questions below do not all point the same way.

Strong evidence comes from strong designs. Meta-analyses and large replications carry more weight than single surveys. The sections below weight each study by its design, rather than simply counting studies.

Does Development Change Values?

Does development really change a society’s values? The evidence took decades to arrive. Long time-series on incomes, values and institutions have only recently accumulated enough to test the theory’s predictions directly.

  • Aim: Santos, Varnum and Grossmann (2017) tested whether the rise in individualism seen in a handful of rich countries is a global pattern, and what drives it.
  • Method: the researchers assembled 51 years of data on individualist practices and values across 78 countries, and modeled how each country changed over time.
  • Results: individualism rose in most societies studied, linked mainly to rising socioeconomic development. Sizeable cultural differences between countries still remained at the end of the period.
  • Conclusion: development reliably pushes cultures in a particular direction, but it does not make them converge on one destination.

Does Economic Convergence Happen?

This question had a discouraging answer for four decades: poor countries were not catching up with rich ones. That has changed.

  • Aim: Kremer, Willis and You (2022) re-examined the 1990s finding that poor countries were not converging with rich ones, using 25 more years of data as a test.
  • Method: the authors re-estimated cross-country growth relationships over the extended period. They then decomposed the gap between unconditional convergence and convergence conditional on human capital, policy, institutions and culture.
  • Results: poor-country catch-up began to trend from 1990 and has held since around 2000, driven by faster growth in poorer countries and slower growth at the frontier. Many correlates of growth converged too.
  • Conclusion: the world has entered a period of real convergence. But it began decades after modernization theory predicted, and after its own policy programme was most heavily applied.

Does Development Produce Democracy?

A different question follows: does development produce democracy? Seymour Martin Lipset’s classic answer, now called the Lipset hypothesis, holds that richer nations are more likely to sustain democratic government (Lipset, 1959).

Lipset argued that development raises education, enlarges the middle class, moderates class conflict and builds the associational life that democratic politics depends on.

The most influential re-examination split the hypothesis in two. Przeworski and Limongi (1997) analyzed data on 135 countries between 1950 and 1990. Development did not raise the probability of a transition to democracy. But affluence made democratic regimes markedly more stable.

Reviewing the accumulated evidence, Treisman (2020) found a strong link between higher income and both democratization and democratic survival, though mainly over ten- to twenty-year horizons. The pattern is not immediate.

Treisman proposed that development’s effect on democracy is triggered by disruptive events, such as economic crises or a change of leader, rather than acting on its own.

One large study found the opposite arrow. Acemoglu, Naidu, Restrepo and Robinson (2019) used a dynamic panel analysis with instrumental-variable and reweighting strategies. New democracies, they found, raise GDP per person by roughly twenty percent over the long run, working mainly through greater investment in capital, schooling and health.

Do the Theory’s Policy Levers Work?

Education is the theory’s most durable policy plank. Recent evidence complicates it.

Angrist, Djankov, Goldberg and Patrinos (2021) built a globally comparable learning database covering 164 countries from 2000 to 2017, representing 98 percent of the world’s population.

Global progress in learning has been limited despite rising enrolment. Measuring school quality directly, the study found that human capital explains only a fifth to a half of the income gap between countries, and the picture varies widely by region.

The lesson cuts against the theory’s own emphasis on enrolment. Years in school are not the same as learning, and counting classroom seats was never a reliable proxy for the skills that actually drive growth.

More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.

Further Information

References

Acemoglu, D., Johnson, S., & Robinson, J. A. (2001). The colonial origins of comparative development: An empirical investigation. American Economic Review, 91(5), 1369–1401.

Acemoglu, D., Naidu, S., Restrepo, P., & Robinson, J. A. (2019). Democracy does cause growth. Journal of Political Economy, 127(1), 47–100.

Ahiakpor, J. C. W. (1985). The success and failure of dependency theory: The experience of Ghana. International Organization, 39(3), 535–552.

Angrist, N., Djankov, S., Goldberg, P. K., & Patrinos, H. A. (2021). Measuring human capital using global learning data. Nature, 592(7854), 403–408.

Armer, M., & Schnaiberg, A. (1972). Measuring individual modernity: A near myth. American Sociological Review, 37(3), 301–316.

Arndt, C., Jones, S., & Tarp, F. (2015). Assessing foreign aid’s long-run contribution to growth and development. World Development, 69, 6–18.

Bernstein, H. (1971). Modernization theory and the sociological study of development. The Journal of Development Studies, 7(2), 141–160.

Dibua, J. I. (2006). Modernization and the crisis of development in Africa: The Nigerian experience. Ashgate.

Escobar, A. (1995). Encountering development: The making and unmaking of the Third World. Princeton University Press.

Glendon, M. A. (1999). Foundations of human rights: The unfinished business. American Journal of Jurisprudence, 44(1), Article 1.

Hazell, P. B. R. (2009). The Asian Green Revolution (IFPRI Discussion Paper 00911). International Food Policy Research Institute.

Hoselitz, B. F. (1960). Sociological aspects of economic growth. Free Press.

Inglehart, R., & Baker, W. E. (2000). Modernization, cultural change, and the persistence of traditional values. American Sociological Review, 65(1), 19–51.

Inglehart, R., & Welzel, C. (2005). Modernization, cultural change, and democracy: The human development sequence. Cambridge University Press.

Inkeles, A. (1969). Making men modern: On the causes and consequences of individual change in six developing countries. American Journal of Sociology, 75(2), 208–225.

Inkeles, A., & Smith, D. H. (1974). Becoming modern: Individual change in six developing countries. Harvard University Press.

Knöbl, W. (2003). Theories that won’t pass away: The never-ending story. In G. Delanty & E. F. Isin (Eds.), Handbook of historical sociology (pp. 96–107). SAGE.

Kremer, M., Willis, J., & You, Y. (2022). Converging to convergence. NBER Macroeconomics Annual, 36, 337–412.

Lerner, D. (1958). The passing of traditional society: Modernizing the Middle East. Free Press.

Lipset, S. M. (1959). Some social requisites of democracy: Economic development and political legitimacy. American Political Science Review, 53(1), 69–105.

Mayhew, L. H. (Ed.). (1985). Talcott Parsons on institutions and social evolution: Selected writings. University of Chicago Press.

McClelland, D. C. (1961). The achieving society. Van Nostrand.

Mekasha, T. J., & Tarp, F. (2019). A meta-analysis of aid effectiveness: Revisiting the evidence. Politics and Governance, 7(2), 5–28.

Nunn, N. (2008). The long-term effects of Africa’s slave trades. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 123(1), 139–176.

Nunn, N. (2020). The historical roots of economic development. Science, 367(6485), Article eaaz9986.

Parsons, T. (1951). The social system. Free Press.

Parsons, T. (1964). Evolutionary universals in society. American Sociological Review, 29(3), 339–357.

Parsons, T., & Shils, E. A. (Eds.). (1951). Toward a general theory of action. Harvard University Press.

Prozorovskii, A. (2016). Indonesia as an example of modernization. World Economy and International Relations, 60(4), 95–104.

Przeworski, A., & Limongi, F. (1997). Modernization: Theories and facts. World Politics, 49(2), 155–183.

Rostow, W. W. (1959). The stages of economic growth. The Economic History Review, 12(1), 1–16.

Rostow, W. W. (1960). The stages of economic growth: A non-communist manifesto. Cambridge University Press.

Santos, H. C., Varnum, M. E. W., & Grossmann, I. (2017). Global increases in individualism. Psychological Science, 28(9), 1228–1239.

Sen, A. (1999). Development as freedom. Knopf.

Smith, D. H., & Inkeles, A. (1966). The OM scale: A comparative socio-psychological measure of individual modernity. Sociometry, 29(4), 353–377.

Treisman, D. (2020). Economic development and democracy: Predispositions and triggers. Annual Review of Political Science, 23, 241–257.

Saul McLeod, PhD

BSc (Hons) Psychology, MRes, PhD, University of Manchester

Chartered Psychologist (CPsychol)

Saul McLeod, PhD, is a qualified psychology teacher with over 18 years of experience in further and higher education. He has been published in peer-reviewed journals, including the Journal of Clinical Psychology.


Ayesh Perera

Researcher

B.A, MTS, Harvard University

Ayesh Perera, a Harvard graduate, has worked as a researcher in psychology and neuroscience under Dr. Kevin Majeres at Harvard Medical School.