Language, thought and communication is the study of how words and thinking are linked and how animals and people pass on messages. In AQA GCSE Psychology (8182), it is Section B of Paper 2, worth 25 of the 100 marks. The topic covers Piaget’s theory, the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, Von Frisch’s bee study, body language, Darwin’s theory and Yuki’s study of emoticons.
Key Takeaways
Relationship Between Language and Thought
- Piaget’s theory, a psychologist’s idea about how children think, says language depends on thought. Children understand an idea first, then learn the words for it.
- The Sapir-Whorf hypothesis says thinking depends on language. The language you speak shapes how you think, see and remember.
- Evidence from colours and recall supports it, but is disputed. The Zuni, a Native American people, made more errors on colours their language does not name.
Human and Animal Communication Differences
- Animal communication has limited functions (purposes): survival, reproduction, territory and food. A rabbit thumping the ground to warn of danger is survival.
- In Von Frisch’s study, bees returning from sugar water did a round dance for near food and a waggle dance for far food, telling other bees where it was.
- Human communication has properties animals lack, such as planning ahead and discussing future events.
Non-Verbal Communication
- Verbal communication uses words, spoken, written or signed. Non-verbal communication sends messages without words, such as body language, facial expressions and tone of voice.
- Eye contact is two people looking at each other’s eyes. It regulates the flow of conversation, signals attraction and expresses emotion.
- Open posture looks friendly. Closed posture, such as folded arms, does not. Postural echo is copying another person’s posture. Touch is also a message.
- Personal space is the space a person likes to keep around them. It tends to differ by culture, status and gender.
Explanations of Non-Verbal Behaviour
- Darwin’s theory says non-verbal communication evolved over generations to express emotion. It is adaptive, which means it helps survival.
- Serviceable associated habits are behaviours that regularly happen with a feeling, such as baring teeth in anger. The nervous system also causes some, such as wide pupils when afraid.
- Innate (inborn) behaviour shows in neonates (newborns) and the sensory deprived (little or no input from a sense), who could not have copied it. Learned behaviour is copied from others.
- In Yuki’s study, Japanese and American students rated how happy simple faces looked. Japanese students relied on the eyes and Americans on the mouth, so reading emotion is partly learned.
Exam Skills
- Describe a theory or study first, then evaluate it. Link every point to that study or theory. Never mix up Piaget and Sapir-Whorf.
- Read the command word. If asked for one function, outline just one. Do not only name it, and do not compare animals with humans.
The Possible Relationship Between Language and Thought
The Effect of Language and Thought on Our View of the World
Do you think in words? Language is a system of words or signs used to communicate. Thought is thinking and understanding inside your head.
Psychologists ask which one comes first. If language shapes thought, people who speak different languages may see the world differently. If thought comes first, everyone shares the same view and the words are just labels.
Piaget and the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis give opposite answers. Mixing them up is a common error in this topic. Keep them apart.
| Piaget’s theory | The Sapir-Whorf hypothesis | |
|---|---|---|
| Which comes first? | Thought. Language grows out of what a child understands. | Language. The language you speak shapes how you think. |
| Where does the evidence come from? | Children’s development. | Comparing languages, such as their colour words. |
| What does the exam credit? | Language develops in stages alongside thinking. | Weak and strong versions, based on Native American languages. |
Piaget’s Theory: Language Depends on Thought
Jean Piaget was a Swiss psychologist who studied how children’s thinking develops. His ideas about thinking are in the stage theory, which is covered in the Development topic.
His theory of language says language depends on thought. In the exam you get marks for these points.
- Matching Words to Knowledge: Children match the right words to what they already know about the world. This knowledge is stored in mental packages called schemas. The child understands an idea first.
- Thinking Leads Language: The growth of thinking, called cognitive development, leads to the growth of language. We can only use language at the level our thinking has reached.
- Copying Words: A child may copy a word that others use. Until they understand the idea, they cannot use the word to communicate.
- Stages: Language develops in stages. Everyone moves through the stages in the same order, but not everyone reaches the last stage.
Imagine a child who hears adults say “tomorrow” and repeats it at bedtime. She is upset when told the trip is “tomorrow”, not today.
On Piaget’s view she has copied the word without the idea. This example is made up and carries no data.
Language in Each Stage
Piaget said thinking develops in four stages. The exam credits what language is like in each one.
- Sensorimotor (about 0 to 2): Babies learn what their bodies can do, including making sounds. They begin to copy sounds they hear.
- Pre-Operational (about 2 to 7): Children can speak their own thoughts aloud but rarely use language to share ideas with others.
- Concrete Operational (about 7 to 11): Language has developed a lot, but it is used only to talk about real, concrete things.
- Formal Operational (from about 11): Language can be used to talk about abstract, theoretical ideas.
Strengths of Piaget’s Theory
- Early Language Is Not Random: Two-word phrases such as “Mummy up” or “Daddy phone” show some understanding that the two words are connected. The child seems to understand something before producing the words.
- Natural Behaviour: Much of his data came from his own children. They were unlikely to notice anything unusual, so they behaved naturally.
Limitations of Piaget’s Theory
- Measurement: A schema is inside the head, so nobody can measure scientifically when a child has developed one. Babies cannot say what they know.
- Little Evidence: Very little research supports the theory, and very little is being done now.
- Rival Research: More research supports other theories, including the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, as the colour evidence below shows.
- Asking Questions: He may have misjudged how far children use language to ask questions and learn. Language is partly a tool for getting information from other people.
- Social Function: He neglected the social side of language. A function is a purpose, and one purpose of language is communicating with other people.
- Rival View: In the Piaget versus Vygotsky debate, Vygotsky said language and thought start by developing independently (Vygotsky, 1986).
- Personal Bias: Much of his data came from his own children. His own judgement may have been biased, which lowers objectivity and validity.
- Sample Bias: He studied a small number of middle-class Swiss children. So the findings may not apply to other classes or cultures, which are groups with shared rules and beliefs.
The Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis: Thinking Depends on Language
A hypothesis is an idea that can be tested. Edward Sapir was a linguist, someone who studies language. His student, Benjamin Whorf, developed what became the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis (Whorf, 1956).
In the exam you get marks for these points. The evidence for and against comes in the next section, because evidence is not part of the description.
- Language First: Sapir and Whorf believed language comes first and thought follows. So language affects memory, perception and thinking.
- Weak Version: Language influences thought. Both Sapir and Whorf agreed more with this version. Some books call it linguistic relativity.
- Strong Version: Language determines thought. If you have no word for something, you cannot think about it. Some books call it linguistic determinism.
- Native American Languages: The idea was based on these languages, which Whorf compared with English.
- The Snow Example: Whorf claimed that the Inuit (called Eskimos in older books) had many words for snow. So they could tell more kinds apart.
Variation in Recall of Events and Recognition of Colours
The specification asks for evidence that people who speak different languages recognise colours and recall events differently, for example in Native American cultures.
This evidence goes in an evaluation, not in the description above.
Recognition of Colours
- Exam Example: In one exam question, people whose language has separate words for light and dark green recognised the shades faster. This supports thinking depends on language. Otherwise such a big difference is unlikely.
- The Zuni: The Zuni are a Native American people. Their language has one word for yellow and orange. They made more errors than English speakers when telling those colours apart (Brown & Lenneberg, 1954).
- Bilingual Speakers: Zuni who also spoke English fell between the two groups (Lenneberg & Roberts, 1956). They were in between, as if using the words of both languages.
- Russian Blues: Russian has separate words for lighter and darker blue. Russian speakers were faster at telling blues apart when the colours had different names. English speakers were not (Winawer et al., 2007).
Recall of Events
Recall means remembering. English often says “she broke the vase”, even for an accident.
Spanish prefers “the vase broke”. English speakers remembered who caused an accidental event better than Spanish speakers did (Fausey & Boroditsky, 2011).
Strengths of the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis
- Controlled Experiments: Colour words speed up Russian speakers’ choices (Winawer et al., 2007).
- Blue and Green: English speakers judged two shades as more different when one was called blue and the other green. Tarahumara speakers, with one word for both, did not (Kay & Kempton, 1984).
- More Research: More research supports this hypothesis than supports Piaget’s theory.
Limitations of the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis
Some evidence goes against the hypothesis. Other evidence for it is weak.
- Evidence Against, Translation: We can translate between languages. So people must share an understanding of the world that does not depend on one language. This challenges the strong version.
- Evidence Against, The Dani: The Dani of New Guinea have only two basic colour words. Yet they remembered focal colours, the clearest example of each colour, as well as English speakers (Heider, 1972).
- Weak Evidence For, Speed, Not Sight: Russian speakers were faster, not better at seeing. The effect is a difference in speed, not in what people can see.
- Weak Evidence For, Anecdotes: Whorf’s early evidence was anecdotal, which means stories, not tests. The strong version has rarely been tested directly.
A fair conclusion is that language can nudge attention, memory and speed in some areas, but the evidence does not show that thought depends on language.
Slobin (1996) argued that language tunes our attention while we speak.
Differences Between Human and Animal Communication
Animal communication means messages passed between animals by calls, smells, displays or movements. Humans communicate in far more ways.
Limited Functions of Animal Communication
A function is a purpose. Animal communication has only a few. The specification names four: survival, reproduction, territory and food.
“Limited” means limited in purpose, not simple. Animal communication can be complex, as the bee study below shows.
In the exam you get marks for outlining a function, which means explaining what it is. Only naming it is too limited to earn credit.
Examiners warn about two other errors. Do not outline more than one function when asked for one. Each then gets too little detail. Do not compare animals with humans when the question only asks you to describe animal communication.
When a question describes a study, link your function to it. For example, the bees in the study could not signal “up”, which fits the limited functions of animal communication.
Survival
Survival means meeting and protecting the needs of the individual or group so that it keeps existing. Alarm signals about a predator or rival are an example.
A rabbit thumping the ground to warn of a predator is a common one.
Reproduction
Reproduction means courtship, attracting a mate or competing with other suitors for a mate. It also covers coordinating the mating act.
Territory
Territory means marking, defending or increasing an area. It also means establishing dominance over a rival, a group or an area.
Food
Food means alerting others to food: that it is there, how good it is or how much there is.
It also means helping others find it, or keeping others away from it, for example with a threat display. A bee dance about food falls here.
The exam also accepts parent-offspring socialisation (parents teaching their young how to behave), self-defence and navigation. “Motivating others” is not a function.
Von Frisch’s Bee Study
Karl von Frisch studied how bees communicate. An observation is a study where the researcher watches and records behaviour.
- Aim: To find out whether bees use movements to tell other bees where food is.
- Method: The bees were kept in a glass hive so that their movements could be observed and recorded. They fed from containers of sugar water in different places.
- Marking the Bees: Each feeding bee was marked with a tiny dot of paint. This meant it could be identified when it returned to the hive.
- What Changed: The distance of the sugar water from the hive changed. What was recorded was the dance the bees did.
- Results (Distance): The bees moved differently depending on how far away the sugar water was.
- Results (Round Dance): With sugar water under 100 metres away, the bees spun quickly in circles, first to the right and then to the left. This is the round dance.
- Results (Waggle Dance): With sugar water further away, the bees moved forward in a straight line, wagging their abdomen. They then circled left, moved forward again and circled right. This is the waggle dance.
- Results (Other Bees): In one exam question, 60 per cent of the bees that saw the dances went to the food at the right distance. This suggests they understood.
- Conclusion: Bees use movements to communicate where food sources are.
Strengths of Von Frisch’s Study
- Complexity: The study showed that animal communication can be complex. Bees do not just give a simple warning. They pass on information about where food is.
- Replication: Other researchers repeated the study and found the same results. So the study is reliable, which means you get similar results if you repeat it.
- Observation: The glass hive meant the movements could be seen and recorded. The paint meant each bee could be recognised when it returned to the hive.
Limitations of Von Frisch’s Study
- Ecological Validity: This means how well findings fit real life. Bees do not collect sugar water from glass containers every day, so this is not natural behaviour.
- Same Result on Flowers: However, when sugar solution was put onto flowers, the bees behaved in the same way.
- Glass Hive: Hives are not usually made of glass, which could have changed the bees’ natural behaviour. However, research with wooden hives and a video camera found the same results.
- Too Simplistic: The conclusion may be too simple. The noise bees make while dancing is important. Bees may also use cognitive maps, which are mental maps of landmarks, to find food.
- Painted Bees: Bees are not normally painted with dots, and this could have changed their behaviour. Then the study would not be measuring natural communication.
Examiners say it is not a good evaluation point that Von Frisch did not investigate every factor, such as water. A study is not weak for leaving something out.
Properties of Human Communication Not Present in Animal Communication
Human communication has properties that animal communication does not. The specification gives two examples, so use these.
- Plan Ahead: People can use language to plan. For example, friends decide together where to eat after a film.
- Discuss Future Events: People can talk about things that have not happened yet. For example, you can talk about what you might do tomorrow after school.
Humans can also imagine possible events and talk about them. This gives human communication a greater variety of functions than animal communication.
The exam accepts other properties too. Examples are displacement (talking about things that are not here), productivity (making endless new messages) and creativity. Give an example of each property you name.
Non-Verbal Communication
Every day you send messages without saying a word. A raised eyebrow, a folded arm or the distance you stand from a friend all say something.
Definitions of Non-Verbal and Verbal Communication
- Verbal Communication: Sending and receiving messages using words. The words can be spoken, written or signed. A chat about plans and a text message are both verbal.
- Non-Verbal Communication: Sending and receiving messages without using words. It includes body language, facial expressions and paralinguistics, which means the tone, pitch, volume and intonation of your voice.
Two traps catch many students. Sign language is verbal, because it uses words. And the difference is not “speech”, because speech includes tone and volume, which are non-verbal.
Social media messages are verbal too, even though nobody speaks.
Functions of Eye Contact
Eye contact is when two people look at each other’s eyes at the same time. A function is a purpose. Eye contact has three that the specification names.
Regulating the Flow of Conversation
Eye contact helps people know whose turn it is to speak. In one exam question, a speaker paused and said “um”. The other person’s sunglasses hid her eyes, so he could not tell when it was his turn.
Signalling Attraction
Eye contact can show that we are attracted to someone.
Expressing Emotion
Eyes give feedback about how someone feels. In the same question, he could not tell how she felt, because he could not see her eyes. The exam also accepts showing attention and interest.
When a question gives a conversation, link each function to it. A function that is not tied to the conversation is not credited.
Body Language: Open and Closed Posture, Postural Echo and Touch
Body language is how we use the position of the body to send messages. Posture is the position of the body.
Open Posture
An open posture is relaxed, with arms not crossed. Research suggests that people who use an open posture are seen as friendlier, more agreeable and more approachable.
In one exam question, a student was asked to suggest a posture for a friend’s job interview.
Open posture earned credit, because the interviewer would see the friend as friendlier, which could improve the chance of the job.
Closed Posture
A closed posture is a closed-off position, for example with arms folded across the body. It is the type least likely to communicate friendliness.
Postural Echo
Postural echo is copying another person’s body position during a conversation.
People who do this are seen as friendlier, or as “on the same wavelength”. Do not write about open and closed posture when the question is about copying.
Touch
Touch is physical contact used as a message, for example a pat on the back. Cultures differ in how much touch they use, as the next section shows.
Personal Space: Cultural, Status and Gender Differences
Personal space is the amount of space a person likes to keep between themselves and others.
It is about how much space, not about feeling comfortable or uncomfortable. Answers that say only “comfortable” or “intimidated” earn nothing.
Findings vary, and recent research contradicts some earlier results. So write “tends to”, and compare two groups. You do not need to name the researchers.
Culture
Mediterranean and Latin American cultures are called contact cultures.
People there tend to prefer less space and more touch than in non-contact cultures, such as Asian and North American cultures.
Status
Status is a person’s rank or importance. People of equal status tend to stand closer than people of different status.
Lower-status people tend to stand further from higher-status people. They also feel less able to choose how close others get.
In one exam question, a man felt his boss stood too close, though the boss stood no closer than another person did. The reason was status, because the boss ranked higher.
Gender
Findings tend to be as follows.
- Males and females both stand closer to a female than to a male.
- Two females stand closer than a male and a female.
- Two males stand furthest apart.
Other factors also earn marks.
Examples are age, personality, how well people know each other, temperature, disorders such as autism and long-term surroundings such as a crowded city. Factors that only change the space available do not.
Imagine two strangers in a lift. Saying one “feels uncomfortable” does not answer the question. Saying that people of different status keep more distance, and describing how much, does.
Explanations of Non-Verbal Behaviour
Why do we smile, frown or stand where we do? Psychologists ask whether we are born with these behaviours or learn them.
Darwin’s Evolutionary Theory of Non-Verbal Communication as Evolved and Adaptive
Charles Darwin is famous for the theory of evolution. Evolution means gradual change in a species over many generations.
In his book The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals, he applied it to non-verbal communication (Darwin, 1897).
The theory says non-verbal communication has evolved, which means it developed over many generations. It is also adaptive, which means it helped the species cope and survive.
In the exam you get marks for these points.
- Natural Selection: Living things that change in the best ways to fit their environment survive and reproduce most. This is survival of the fittest. This point alone earns at most one mark.
- Expressing Emotion: Darwin proposed that non-verbal communication evolved as a way of expressing emotions. Link the theory to non-verbal communication, not just to survival.
- Serviceable Associated Habits: A serviceable behaviour has a purpose. A serviceable associated habit is a behaviour that regularly happens when we feel a certain way, such as baring teeth when angry.
- Example of a Habit: People bare their teeth when angry because humans may once have used biting for self-defence. As in many animals, bared teeth say “back off”.
- The Nervous System: The nervous system causes some non-verbal communication. Dilated (widened) pupils and an open mouth when frightened are examples.
- Fight or Flight: These come from the fight or flight response, the body’s automatic reaction to danger.
- Why They Help: An open mouth takes in more oxygen, so we can run faster. The exam also credits the idea that dilated pupils let us see more, to find the best escape.
Fight or Flight and Darwin’s Theory
The exam can ask you to discuss whether the fight or flight response supports Darwin. Describe the response briefly.
- Automatic: It is an automatic reaction to a real or imagined threat. Culture and upbringing do not change it, so it can be seen as innate.
- The Switch: The autonomic nervous system, which controls organs automatically, switches from parasympathetic activity (calming) to sympathetic activity (preparing for action). Adrenaline, a hormone, is released.
- Body Changes: Breathing and heart rate speed up, sweating rises, pupils widen and digestion slows. These help people fight or run.
- Rest and Digest: After the threat, the body switches back to parasympathetic activity.
It supports Darwin because the response is automatic, not changed by culture, and helps survival. Against him, not all non-verbal behaviour helps people fight or run.
Strengths of Darwin’s Theory
- Same Across Cultures: Some research suggests that at least some non-verbal behaviours are genetic. Anger and happiness seem to share facial expressions in all cultures. The evidence is mixed.
- Medical Evidence: Medical evidence supports the nervous system causing actions such as pupil dilation.
- Innate Evidence: Newborn babies and the sensory deprived show some behaviours that could not have been learned, as the next section explains.
Limitations of Darwin’s Theory
- Social Learning: Some behaviours are learned, which means copied from others, so culture affects them. This is the view of social learning theory. Yuki’s study below supports it.
- Both Innate and Learned: Some behaviours are both. Innate means inborn. We cry and laugh at birth but learn to control them.
- Not All Behaviour Aids Survival: Not all non-verbal behaviour helps survival or reproduction. Gestures are an example.
- Not Universal: Jack et al. (2012) reported cultural differences in how people read facial expressions. So facial expressions are less universal than the theory suggests.
Evidence That Non-Verbal Behaviour Is Innate
Innate means inborn, due to heredity rather than learned from experience. Two groups help to test this.
Neonates
A neonate is a newborn baby less than a month old. A neonate has had almost no time to copy anyone. So an expression it shows looks inborn.
The Sensory Deprived
The sensory deprived are people or animals with limited or no information from one or more senses, for example people who are blind. They have never watched others’ expressions.
So expressions they show anyway look inborn.
When asked what these words mean, define them. Do not describe research on newborns. Explain “deprived” too, which means being without something.
A case study is an in-depth study of one person or a small group.
Do not just describe a case study when asked why it suits this research.
Say why. It suits the sensory deprived because they are a rare group. It lets researchers watch closely over time and record changes in their non-verbal communication.
Evidence That Non-Verbal Behaviour Is Learned
Learned means gained from experience. Social learning theory, from Bandura, says we learn by observing and copying other people. So behaviour can differ between cultures.
- Eye Contact Ratings: Japanese participants rated a face making eye contact as angrier and less approachable (Akechi et al., 2013). The authors link this to cultural rules.
- Personal Space: Cultures differ in how much space and touch they use, as shown earlier.
- Emoticons: Yuki’s study, below, found that Japanese and American students read faces differently.
The exam credits three conclusions about nature and nurture: some behaviour is innate, some is learned and some is both.
Yuki’s Study of Emoticons
An emoticon is a simple face made of eyes and a mouth. Yuki, Maddux and Masuda (2007) used them to compare two cultures. A cross-cultural study compares people from different cultures.
- Aim: To find out whether people from Japan and the USA use different parts of the face to read emotion.
- Participants: The participants were students from America and Japan.
- Method: They were shown emoticons with six different combinations of happy, neutral or sad eyes and mouths. They rated how happy each face looked on a scale from 1 to 9.
- Variables: The independent variable, which the researcher changes or compares, was the culture of the students: Japanese or American. The dependent variable, which is measured, was the happiness rating.
- Results (Japanese): Japanese students gave the highest ratings to faces with happy eyes and the lowest to faces with sad eyes.
- Results (American): American students gave the highest ratings to faces with happy mouths and the lowest to faces with sad mouths.
- Conclusion: Japanese people focus more on the eyes and Americans more on the mouth. Yuki concluded this is due to differences in socialisation, which is how each culture teaches its people to behave. So reading emotion is partly learned.
Strengths of Yuki’s Study
- Evidence for Learning: The study provided evidence that the way we respond to non-verbal behaviour is learned.
- Also, Quantitative Data: The ratings were numbers, called quantitative data. This makes the two groups easy to compare.
- Also, Standardised Procedure: Both groups rated the same kind of faces on the same scale. So the groups could be compared fairly.
- Also, Later Support: A later study reported a similar pattern (Jack et al., 2012).
Limitations of Yuki’s Study
- Ecological Validity: This means how well findings fit real life. The faces were computer generated, not real. Real faces move and are more complex.
- Demand Characteristics: These are clues that tell participants what the study is about. They knew they were in research, so they may not have given true answers.
- Sample Bias: Both groups were students, so there were no younger or older people. The samples may not represent people of different ages or education levels.
- Generalisability: The faces showed only two emotions, happy and sad. People express many more, so the findings cannot be applied to all emotions.
- Rating Scale: A scale from 1 to 9 may be too simple to measure something as complex as human emotion.
Research Methods in Language, Thought and Communication Questions
Paper 2 tests research methods, such as variables, inside every topic. In this topic the questions use the studies above.
Hypotheses and Variables
- Alternative Hypothesis: It predicts a difference between two groups and names a measurable dependent variable.
- Example Hypothesis: For Yuki’s study, this earned two marks: “There will be a difference in the happiness ratings given to each face by Japanese or American students.”
- What Earns Nothing: A null hypothesis, an aim, a question, a conclusion, a result or different variables. “Perception” is not measurable. “Ratings” is.
- Independent Variable: In one exam question, it was the language the participants spoke, English or non-English. Naming only one condition earned nothing.
Data and Calculations
- Ratio: One table gave 500 seconds for English speakers and 300 for non-English speakers. The ratio of non-English to English is 300 : 500, which simplifies to 3 : 5.
- Range: The range is the highest value minus the lowest. For a bar chart of preferred distances, the answer 7 or 8 earned a mark. Showing “8 − 1” also earned a mark.
- Types of Data: Words that are counted, such as yes or no, are quantitative data. Primary data is collected first-hand by the researcher.
- Smiling Babies: In one specimen question, two groups of babies gave 33 and 40 smiles. Similar numbers, only 7 apart, suggest smiling is innate. Different numbers suggest it is learned.
- Other Answers: You can also say there is not enough information. The smiles may have been counted wrongly, or the adults’ familiarity may have mattered.
Designing and Evaluating a Study
- Designing a Study: Name a target population, a procedure and the data. To study postural echo, the best answers used two conditions.
- Postural Echo Design: A confederate, a secret helper, copied the participant’s posture in one conversation and did not copy it in another. The friendliness ratings were quantitative, primary data.
- Cross-Cultural Design: To test whether surprise is recognised across cultures, use participants from more than one cultural group and say why. Many students tested sadness or happiness by mistake.
- Other Designs: Comparing personal space or hand gestures across cultures also earned credit.
- Evaluating a Described Study: Use its own features. Opportunity sampling can be biased and unrepresentative, but it is quick.
- Video and Languages: Video clips are not real life, but they are easy to repeat. People who speak many languages add participant differences.
Ethics
- Ethical Issue: Give one issue and a way of dealing with it that fits the study. For confidentiality, use a number or letter, not a name.
- Consent: For informed consent, explain the study and ask. For parental consent, ask the parents of under-16s.
- Deception and Withdrawal: For deception, tell people as soon as possible. For the right to withdraw, say they can stop at any time.
- Harm: For protection from harm, keep risk no greater than everyday life.
How the Exam Asks About Language, Thought and Communication
Language, thought and communication is worth 25 marks. AO1 is knowledge, AO2 is applying it and AO3 is evaluation. The split changes each year.
Command Words
- What is meant by: Give a short, accurate definition, such as eye contact or neonate.
- Outline: Set out the main points. Only naming a function of animal communication is too limited to earn credit.
- Explain: Give a reason tied to the stem. Describing two personal space factors without using the conversation earned nothing.
- Briefly evaluate: Link every point to the named study or theory. A general point about a described study earns at most one mark.
- Describe and evaluate: Give both. The marks are split between description and evaluation, and the split varies by question. Answers are marked in levels. The examiner judges the whole answer.
- Discuss whether or not: Describe both ideas, then argue. Yuki has been paired with Gregory’s theory of perception. Darwin has been paired with the fight or flight response.
What Examiners Look For
- Keep the Theories Apart: Examiners call mixing up Piaget and Sapir-Whorf the most common error when describing Sapir-Whorf.
- Describe First: In Von Frisch answers, many students missed the distances. In Yuki answers, many missed the rating scale and the emoticon detail.
- Balance the Answer: Spend about as long on evaluation as on description. A general point about laboratory control lost marks.
- Know the Terms: Define neonate, sensory deprived and postural echo. In Darwin answers, “survival of the fittest” with no link to non-verbal communication stays low. The best outlined serviceable habits and the nervous system.
- Justify From the Results: In a Yuki conclusion, the commonest lost mark was explaining why Japanese people focus on the eyes. Use the results to justify the conclusion.
- Use the Stem: Use the features of a described study. Generic answers earned less.
How the Studies and Theories Are Marked
- Piaget: A 4-mark outline, or a 9-mark describe and evaluate. Students lost marks by describing stages without linking them to language, or by evaluating his studies instead of his theory.
- Sapir-Whorf: A 4-mark describe. The recall and colour evidence belongs in evaluation, not in the description.
- Von Frisch: 3 marks for results, 3 for a brief evaluation, or a 6-mark describe and evaluate.
- Darwin: A 6-mark describe and evaluate, or a 4-mark outline. Not all behaviour helps survival is a credited limitation.
- Yuki: A 6-mark or 9-mark describe and evaluate, or 5 marks for results, a conclusion and a justification.
- Yuki With Gregory: Gregory said perception is an active process using stored knowledge from past experience. Japanese and American students read faces differently because they grew up in different cultures, which supports him.
- Paper 1: One specimen 9-mark question asked what Bartlett’s research and a theory of language and thought tell us about their relationship.
- Paper 1, Evaluation: Bartlett’s results may suggest thinking depends on language, so they support Sapir-Whorf. The story’s unfamiliar style is an alternative explanation. The scoring method may be unreliable.
- Paper 1, Vygotsky: Vygotsky said language and thought develop independently.
Practice Question 1: Describe and Evaluate Von Frisch’s Bee Study (6 Marks)
These model answers are examples. They are not the exam board’s own wording.
Model answer: Von Frisch wanted to find out whether bees use movements to tell other bees where food is. He kept bees in a glass hive so he could observe and record them.
They fed from sugar water in different places. Each feeding bee was marked with a dot of paint.
Under 100 metres away, the bees did a round dance. They spun in circles to the right and then the left.
Further away, they did a waggle dance. They moved forward wagging their abdomen, circled left, moved forward and circled right. He concluded that bees use movements to communicate where food is.
One strength is that other researchers replicated the study and found the same results. So it is reliable.
One limitation is that bees do not normally feed from glass containers. So the study may lack ecological validity. However, the same results were found with sugar on flowers.
- Marking Note: In one exam, three marks were for description: the glass hive and sugar water, the two dances with the distances, and the conclusion. Three were for evaluation linked to this study.
Practice Question 2: Describe and Evaluate Yuki’s Study of Emoticons (9 Marks)
Model answer: Yuki compared students from America and Japan. He showed them emoticons with six different combinations of happy, neutral or sad eyes and mouths. They rated how happy each face looked from 1 to 9.
Japanese students gave the highest ratings to faces with happy eyes. They gave the lowest to sad eyes.
American students gave the highest ratings to happy mouths and the lowest to sad mouths.
Yuki concluded that Japanese people focus more on the eyes and Americans on the mouth. He put it down to socialisation.
One strength is that the study gives evidence that the way we respond to non-verbal behaviour is learned.
One limitation is that the faces were computer generated, not real. So the study lacks ecological validity. Another is that both groups were students, so the sample is not representative of other ages.
A third is that only happy and sad were tested. So the findings cannot be applied to all emotions. Participants also knew they were in a study, so demand characteristics may have changed their answers.
- Marking Note: In one exam, four marks were for knowledge: the sample, the emoticons and rating scale, the results and the conclusion. Five were for evaluation of this study, not of studies in general.
Practice Question 3: Personal Space in a Conversation (4 Marks)
Imagine this conversation. Ravi says: “At the school disco I stood close to Zac. When the head teacher came over, I stepped back.”
Mia says: “I stood closer to my friend Jess than to Zac. I did not mind.”
Use the conversation to explain two factors that can affect personal space. [4 marks]
Model answer: One factor is status. Ravi stepped back from the head teacher because she has higher status. People tend to stand further from someone of higher status than from someone of equal status, such as Zac.
Another factor is gender. Mia stands closer to Jess than to Zac. Males and females both tend to stand closer to a female than to a male.
- Marking Note: Each factor needs an explanation tied to the conversation. Without the conversation, no marks are given.
Practice Question 4: Piaget and Sapir-Whorf (6 Marks)
Imagine Tim is 4. He copies the word “tomorrow” from his parents. He still cries when told the party is “tomorrow”, not today. He does not understand.
Describe Piaget’s theory and the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis. Use Tim to explain Piaget’s theory. [6 marks]
Model answer: Piaget said language depends on thought. A child understands an idea first and then learns the words for it. Tim has copied the word “tomorrow” without the idea. So he cannot use it properly yet.
He is in the pre-operational stage. Children in this stage rarely use language to share ideas with others.
The Sapir-Whorf hypothesis says the opposite: thinking depends on language. The weak version says language influences thought. The strong version says language determines thought, so you cannot think about something with no word for it.
- Marking Note: Marks are in levels. Describe both ideas separately, apply Piaget to Tim and keep evidence out of the description.
References
Akechi, H., Senju, A., Uibo, H., Kikuchi, Y., Hasegawa, T., & Hietanen, J. K. (2013). Attention to eye contact in the West and East: Autonomic responses and evaluative ratings. PLoS ONE, 8(3), e59312. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0059312
Brown, R. W., & Lenneberg, E. H. (1954). A study in language and cognition. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 49(3), 454–462.
Darwin, C. (1897). The expression of the emotions in man and animals. D. Appleton and Company. (Original work published 1872)
Fausey, C. M., & Boroditsky, L. (2011). Who dunnit? Cross-linguistic differences in eyewitness memory. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 18(1), 150–157.
Heider, E. R. (1972). Universals in color naming and memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 93(1), 10–20. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0032606
Jack, R. E., Garrod, O. G. B., Yu, H., Caldara, R., & Schyns, P. G. (2012). Facial expressions of emotion are not culturally universal. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109(19), 7241–7244. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1200155109
Kay, P., & Kempton, W. (1984). What is the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis? American Anthropologist, 86(1), 65–79. https://doi.org/10.1525/aa.1984.86.1.02a00050
Lenneberg, E. H., & Roberts, J. M. (1956). The language of experience: A study in methodology. Waverly Press.
Slobin, D. I. (1996). From “thought and language” to “thinking for speaking.” In J. J. Gumperz & S. C. Levinson (Eds.), Rethinking linguistic relativity (pp. 70–96). Cambridge University Press.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1986). Thought and language (A. Kozulin, Rev. & Ed.). MIT Press. (Original work published 1934)
Whorf, B. L. (1956). Language, thought and reality: Selected writings of Benjamin Lee Whorf (J. B. Carroll, Ed.). MIT Press.
Winawer, J., Witthoft, N., Frank, M. C., Wu, L., Wade, A. R., & Boroditsky, L. (2007). Russian blues reveal effects of language on color discrimination. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 104(19), 7780–7785. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0701644104
Yuki, M., Maddux, W. W., & Masuda, T. (2007). Are the windows to the soul the same in the East and West? Cultural differences in using the eyes and mouth as cues to recognize emotions in Japan and the United States. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 43(2), 303–311. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2006.02.004