Development is the way a person’s brain, thinking and learning change as they grow. In AQA GCSE Psychology (8182), it is Section C of Paper 1, worth 25 of the 100 marks. The topic covers early brain development, Piaget’s stage theory and the effects of learning.
Key Takeaways
Early Brain Development
- Before birth, a simple tube of nerve tissue grows into the brain, which is fully formed by about six months.
- The brain stem controls autonomic (automatic) functions such as breathing. The thalamus handles sensory messages, the cerebellum movement and balance, and the cortex thinking.
- Nature is the influence of genes. Nurture is the influence of environment and experience. Before birth, most development is nature, but nurture matters too.
Piaget’s Stage Theory
- Assimilation fits new information into an existing schema (a block of knowledge). Accommodation changes a schema, or makes a new one, when information does not fit.
- Piaget said thinking develops through four stages: sensorimotor (about 0 to 2), pre-operational (about 2 to 7), concrete operational (7 to 11) and formal operational (11 onwards).
- Schools use Piaget in two ways: child-centred learning, where children discover answers, and readiness, teaching a topic at the right stage.
- Egocentrism is seeing things only from your own point of view. Piaget said pre-operational children are egocentric, and this fades with age.
- Conservation is knowing an amount stays the same when it looks different. Piaget said children manage this at about seven.
- In the naughty teddy study, four- to six-year-olds conserved more often when a teddy changed the counters by accident, so Piaget underestimated them.
- In the policeman doll study, about 90 per cent of young children hid a boy doll from toy policemen, so were less egocentric than Piaget said.
Effects of Learning on Development
- Dweck said people with a fixed mindset believe ability cannot change, so they give up. People with a growth mindset believe effort improves ability, so they keep trying.
- Praise for effort (process praise) supports a growth mindset. Praise for being clever (person praise) can support a fixed one.
- Self-efficacy is a belief in your own ability to succeed at a task. Teachers can raise it with easier questions, small steps and praise.
- Learning styles are preferred ways of taking in information. Verbalisers prefer words and visualisers prefer pictures. Willingham said teaching to a style does not improve learning.
Exam Skills
- For a study, give the aim, method, results and conclusion. Link every evaluation point to that study, not to studies in general.
Early Brain Development
Your brain began as something very simple. Over many months in the womb, it built itself up into a structure that can move, sense and think. How does it grow, and what shapes it?
A Basic Knowledge of Brain Development
In the womb, the brain grows from simple nerve structures into four main parts. What to remember:
- Brain Stem: controls basic autonomic functions, which are automatic body jobs such as breathing and digestion.
- Thalamus: responsible for sensory processing, which means sending and receiving sensory messages.
- Cerebellum: coordinates movement and balance.
- Cortex: the outer covering of the brain, where thinking happens. It controls cognitive processes, which means thinking, knowing and remembering.
From Neural Tube to Brain
In the exam you get marks for this timeline. Weeks are counted from early pregnancy, and sources count them slightly differently, so learn the exam’s numbers.
| When | What forms | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Third week | Brain development begins. | The nervous system starts to form. |
| Fourth week | A neural tube, a simple tube of nerve tissue. | It begins to divide into a spinal cord, forebrain, midbrain and hindbrain. |
| Sixth week | The cortex and the thalamus. | They form when the forebrain divides. |
| Fifteenth week | The cerebellum and part of the brain stem. | They form from the hindbrain. The midbrain also forms part of the brain stem. |
| Sixth month | The brain is fully formed. | It has not yet reached its full size. |
The forebrain, midbrain and hindbrain are the front, middle and back parts of the early brain. Research suggests that the nervous system starts to form in the third and fourth weeks after conception (Stiles & Jernigan, 2010).
Most nerve cells are made before birth. But connections between them keep being built and tidied for years (Stiles & Jernigan, 2010).
Brain Stem
The brain stem joins the spinal cord to the brain. Read more about the brain stem.
Thalamus
The thalamus sends and receives sensory messages to and from other parts of the brain. Read more about the thalamus.
Cerebellum
The cerebellum is a small structure at the base of the brain. It also has a role in language and emotion. Read more about the cerebellum.
Less than two-thirds of students gained the mark when a past exam asked for this structure by its job.
Cortex
The cortex is where mental processing takes place. Planning a holiday is a job for the cortex.
Read more about the cerebral cortex. Do not confuse it with the brain stem. A past exam used the brain stem’s job as a wrong answer about the cortex.
Development After Birth
At birth a baby’s brain is about a quarter of the size of an adult brain. It doubles in size in the first year. By age three it has reached about 80 per cent of adult size.
Brain function keeps developing long after birth. In the exam you get marks for saying it may not be fully developed until the mid-twenties, or even the thirties.
The Roles of Nature and Nurture
Nature is the argument that characteristics and behaviours are influenced by genes. Before birth, these are the genes a baby inherits.
Nurture is the argument that they are influenced by upbringing, environment and experience. Before birth, this means the mother’s environment, lifestyle and experiences during pregnancy.
In the exam you get marks for two points. Most brain development before birth is due to nature. But nurture also plays a role, and the two work together.
Nurture also acts after birth. Past exams treated these as nurture: infection, neglect, experiences with other people, being played with and spoken to, and stressful experiences.
Examiners found that many students wrote that nurture cannot act before birth. This is wrong. The womb is an environment.
Imagine a baby whose mother ate well in pregnancy and has a family history of an inherited condition. Her diet is nurture. The family history is nature. This is an illustration, not a finding.
Evidence
- Nature Starts the Job: In monkeys, the nerve cells of the visual system are made, and form basic connections, before any experience of seeing (Rakic, 1977).
- Nurture Refines It: Connections in the cortex are not complete at birth. So it makes sense that experience after birth tunes a system that nature started.
- Hard to Separate: Differences at birth are not automatically genetic. A mother’s genes affect her own behaviour in pregnancy and her child’s traits (Thapar et al., 2009).
Read more about the nature-nurture debate, which asks whether abilities are born or learned.
Piaget’s Stage Theory and the Development of Intelligence
Jean Piaget was a Swiss psychologist. He studied how children think. To him, intelligence was not a fixed amount that some children have more of.
He saw it as the way a child makes sense of the world. Their thinking changes as they grow (Piaget, 1952).
So in this topic, “the development of intelligence” does not mean IQ. It means how children’s thinking changes. In the exam you get marks for saying that children develop their understanding of the world in stages.
Read more about Piaget’s theory.
Piaget’s Theory of Cognitive Development: Assimilation and Accommodation
Piaget said children build their understanding by acting on the world. The building blocks are schemas. A schema is a block of knowledge about how something works, built from experience. It organises knowledge and guides action.
Newborns start with a few simple action schemas, such as sucking and grasping. They add more as they grow.
Assimilation
Assimilation means fitting new information into an existing schema. A baby who sucks a finger in the same way as it sucks a nipple is assimilating the finger into its sucking schema.
Accommodation
Accommodation means changing a schema, or creating a new one. This happens when new information does not fit.
In a past exam, a child called Megan met a donkey. It looks like a small horse, but it has a thicker coat and longer ears. Megan needs to adapt her horse schema or create a new one.
The exam credited both. Either way, her understanding changes.
Imagine a toddler who calls every four-legged animal “doggie”. That is assimilation. Then she meets a cat that meows and climbs a tree. She makes a new “cat” schema. That is accommodation. This is an illustration, not a finding.
Read more about assimilation and accommodation.
The Four Stages of Development
Piaget said every child goes through four stages, always in the same order. Children reach each stage at different rates, so the ages are only approximate.
Two words matter in the table. To conserve is to know that an amount stays the same when it looks different. Egocentric means seeing things only from your own point of view. It does not mean selfish.
| Piaget’s stage | About what age | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Sensorimotor | 0 to 2 | Learns through the senses and movement. |
| Pre-operational | 2 to 7 | Thinks amounts change when looks change. Sees only its own view. |
| Concrete operational | 7 to 11 | Reasons logically about objects it can see. |
| Formal operational | From about 11 | Thinks about abstract ideas and possibilities. |
Sensorimotor Stage
In the sensorimotor stage, from birth to about two, children learn through their senses and motor skills. Motor skills are movements. They also learn by taking part in physical activity.
Object permanence is knowing that an object still exists when you cannot see it. It develops from about eight months. It arises when the child forms a mental picture of the object.
So a child who first starts to look for a hidden object is in this stage. In the exam you get marks for this. Read more about the sensorimotor stage and object permanence.
Pre-Operational Stage
In the pre-operational stage, from about two to seven, children cannot yet conserve. They do not understand that things stay the same when they look different. They are also egocentric.
A past exam described Mikey. He saw the same amount of orange juice poured into different containers. He thought the containers now held different amounts. This is typical of the stage.
Piaget would say Mikey has not yet reached the right maturation. This means he has not grown to the point where he can understand this.
Read more about the pre-operational stage.
Concrete Operational Stage
In the concrete operational stage, from about seven to eleven, children reason logically about objects they can see. They struggle with abstract ideas, or with situations they cannot see.
Children in this stage can conserve. Piaget said they manage it at about seven. A past exam described Hassan, aged 8, who counts on his fingers. He is in this stage, because he needs objects he can see.
Read more about the concrete operational stage.
Formal Operational Stage
In the formal operational stage, from about eleven, thinking becomes abstract and hypothetical. Hypothetical means about what might be, not only what is. Teenagers can reason logically and systematically, without objects in front of them.
The exam described Rubi, aged 13, who does maths in her head. She is in this stage. Research suggests that not everyone reaches it.
Read more about the formal operational stage.
The Role of Piaget’s Theory in Education: Application of These Stages in Education
A past exam asked for two ways Piaget’s theory can be applied in education, each with a classroom example. One mark went to each way and one to each example.
Child-Centred Learning and Discovery Learning
In a child-centred approach, the teacher provides materials and the child finds things out. This is discovery learning, which means learning by finding out for yourself.
The credited example was giving pupils bulbs and wires and letting them discover how to make a circuit. The teacher does not tell them the answer.
Readiness
Readiness means children are given chances to learn a topic only when they are at the right stage of intellectual development. A concrete operational child needs real objects. Abstract ideas can wait for the formal stage.
The credited example was children learning to conserve number before they learn to conserve volume.
Strengths of Piaget’s Ideas in Education
- Practical Use: Concrete materials and hands-on activity suit children in the concrete operational stage. This is why the ideas shaped primary teaching.
- Teaching Can Be Tested: In the CASE project, special thinking lessons ran about every two weeks for two years. Boys aged 12 or over gained against matched classes (Adey & Shayer, 1990).
Limitations of Piaget’s Ideas in Education
- Waiting for Readiness: The CASE gains suggest that thinking is not just a matter of waiting for the stage. But girls and younger classes showed no gain.
- Social Help Ignored: Piaget’s focus on the individual child downplays the help of teachers and other children.
- Task Presentation: The teddy and policeman doll studies below suggest a child’s failure on a school task may come from how it is asked.
Reduction of Egocentricity
Egocentrism is a pre-operational child’s difficulty in seeing a situation from another person’s point of view. It is a limit on thinking. It is not selfishness.
Piaget and Inhelder tested it with a model of three mountains. A child had to pick the picture that shows what a doll at another position can see. Children below six or seven tended to pick their own view (Piaget & Inhelder, 1956).
Piaget said this self-centred view fades as children develop. That is the “reduction of egocentricity”. The policeman doll study below challenges it.
Development of Conservation
Conservation is understanding that an amount stays the same when its appearance changes and nothing is added or taken away.
In the usual task, a child sees two equal glasses of juice. The juice from one is poured into a tall thin glass. The child is asked again.
A child who cannot conserve often says the taller glass holds more. Piaget explained this by saying the child looks at only one thing, such as height, and ignores the rest (Piaget & Szeminska, 1952).
In the exam you get marks for three points. Conservation means the quantity stays the same when the appearance changes. Piaget said children develop it at about seven. A child who is fooled is still pre-operational.
One past exam gave a table of data. It showed that 16 per cent of four-year-olds and 58 per cent of six-year-olds could conserve. Two points earned marks:
- More six-year-olds than four-year-olds could conserve. This supports Piaget’s idea that thinking becomes more complex with age.
- Some four-year-olds could conserve. This suggests children can conserve earlier than Piaget claimed.
Read more about conservation.
McGarrigle and Donaldson’s Naughty Teddy Study
McGarrigle and Donaldson (1974) tested whether young children can conserve when the change is accidental.
The full study, with its ethics, exam questions and later research, is on the naughty teddy study page.
- Aim: To investigate whether young children can conserve when accidental changes are made to the appearance of objects.
- Method: This was a laboratory experiment, which means a controlled but artificial setting. Eighty children aged four to six took part.
- The Task: Children saw two identical rows of counters and said if the rows matched. A “naughty teddy” then accidentally spread one row out. They were asked again.
- Variables: The independent variable, which the researcher changes, was an accidental or deliberate change. The dependent variable, which is measured, was whether children said the number of counters in each row was the same.
- Results: Over 60 per cent of the children gave the correct answer, that there were the same number of counters in each row. A higher proportion of the older children were correct. Fewer children conserved after the usual deliberate change.
- Conclusion: Children under seven can conserve. The ability to conserve number increases with age. So the usual task may underestimate what children know.
Strengths of the Study
- Control: A highly controlled laboratory removes extraneous variables, which are other things that could change the results. So the researcher can be surer the change caused the effect.
- Same Children, Same Materials: Every child did both conditions with the same counters and questions. This is a repeated measures design, where the same people do every condition.
- Standardised Procedure: The procedure was the same for every child, so the study can be repeated. This means the reliability of the findings can be tested with other groups of children.
- Replication: Another psychologist repeated the study. This is called replication. More children conserved with the teddy, though fewer than here (Light et al., 1979).
- Importance: It challenged Piaget’s claim that children cannot conserve until about seven. It showed that many younger children could.
Limitations of the Study
- Ecological Validity: This means how well findings fit real life. Counters, a teddy and an unfamiliar adult in a strange place are not like real life.
- Different Schools: The older children all came from one primary school, and the younger ones from different nurseries. So how they were taught, not age, could change the results. This is an extraneous variable.
- Not Noticing: Some children may not have noticed the change, because they were watching the teddy. They may have said “the same” for that reason.
- Still Failing: Over 30 per cent of children still failed to conserve after the accidental change. So many children under seven still could not conserve.
- Ethics With Children: Very young children saw a staged accident. A modern study would ask parents to sign a consent form and explain afterwards what happened.
Hughes’ Policeman Doll Study
Hughes and Donaldson (1979) reported the policeman doll study. It tested Piaget’s claim that young children are egocentric.
The full study, with its ethics, exam questions and later research, is on the policeman doll study page.
- Aim: To test whether young children can see a situation from another person’s point of view, using a hiding game rather than Piaget’s mountains.
- Method: Thirty children from Edinburgh, aged about three and a half to five, took part in a laboratory study. The model had two walls crossing each other, a boy doll and policeman dolls.
- The Task: First, one policeman doll was placed on the model. The child hid the boy from him. A child who made a mistake was told and tried again.
- The Test: A second policeman doll was added. The child hid the boy so that neither policeman could see him.
- Results: About 90 per cent of children hid the boy from both policemen. In later trials with more walls, the younger children were correct only about 60 per cent of the time.
- Conclusion: Most children between three and a half and five can see things from another person’s point of view. So they are not egocentric in their thinking, as Piaget claimed.
Strengths of the Study
- Engaging Task: A hiding game made sense to children. Hiding games were likely to be familiar. So children could show their ability better than in Piaget’s mountain task.
- Challenges Piaget: It suggested that some children can see the world from different viewpoints much earlier than seven.
- Supporting Research: Other studies also found that some children under seven can see another person’s point of view.
Limitations of the Study
- Sample Bias: All the children came from Edinburgh. So it may be hard to generalise, which means apply the findings, to children from other cultures.
- Researcher Bias: Researcher bias means the researcher affects the results. Hidden cues, such as looking at where the doll might go, may have influenced the children.
- A Different Skill: The policeman task asks whether someone can see the boy. The mountain task asks how a whole scene looks from another position.
- Ecological Validity: Toy dolls and walls on a table are not like real life. So the findings may not fit everyday behaviour.
- Ethics With Children: The children enjoyed the games, so harm was probably small. Even so, a modern study would ask a parent first.
Evaluating Piaget’s Stage Theory
In the exam you get marks for points about the theory itself. A study with no link to the theory earns at most one mark.
Strengths of Piaget’s Theory
- Influence on Education: Piaget greatly influenced early years and primary teaching, for example through the Plowden Report (Central Advisory Council for Education, 1967).
- Order of the Stages: Many psychologists still agree that development follows a sequence and that children build their own understanding (Lourenço & Machado, 1996).
- Across Cultures: The order of stages looks broadly the same in different cultures, although the speed varies (Dasen, 1994).
Limitations of Piaget’s Theory
- Underestimated Children: In the first three stages, Piaget set the ages too late. The teddy and policeman doll studies show that children can think in more advanced ways when tested differently.
- Earlier Skills: Babies of about three and a half months look longer at impossible events (Baillargeon & DeVos, 1991). This may mean they understand hidden objects earlier than Piaget said.
- Not Everyone Reaches Formal Operations: A large UK study found only about 30 per cent of 16-year-olds showed even early formal reasoning (Shayer et al., 1976). So the stage does not describe everyone.
- Sample Bias: Piaget studied a small number of middle-class Swiss children. Many of his claims rest on observing his own three children. So the findings may not apply to all children.
- Flawed Data: His questions were not standardised and differed for each child, so the work is hard to repeat. He often did not record the behaviours he saw.
- Confusing Tasks: Repeated questions may have led children to change correct answers. Asking only one question raised success (Rose & Blank, 1974; Samuel & Bryant, 1984).
- Ignores Social Help: Piaget focused on the individual child. Vygotsky said guidance from a more knowledgeable person matters too. Read more about Piaget compared with Vygotsky.
A fair conclusion is that Piaget was right about the sequence and about children building their own understanding.
He was less right about the timing, the sharpness of the stages and who reaches the last one.
Effects of Learning on Development
Dweck’s Mindset Theory of Learning: Fixed Mindset and Growth Mindset
Dweck’s Mindset Theory is a theory of motivation. It explains how students can succeed in their learning.
A mindset is a belief about whether ability can change. Students have one of two kinds.
Fixed Mindset
A fixed mindset is the belief that ability is fixed, from things such as genes or talent. So nothing can change it. A student with a fixed mindset is more likely to give up when a task is hard. They see failure as a lack of talent.
Growth Mindset
A growth mindset is the belief that ability and success come from hard work, perseverance and practice. This includes asking for help when you are stuck.
A student with a growth mindset is more likely to keep trying. They see failure as a chance to grow.
In the exam you must apply the theory to a scenario. In one question, a restaurant called Zuppa recruited for talent and valued results over hard work. That is a fixed mindset. Its employees dislike challenges, because failing would look like a lack of talent.
A restaurant called Bravas valued hard work over natural talent. That is a growth mindset. Its employees enjoy challenges, because they can learn even if they fail.
In another question, a student said she was not born with maths talent, which is fixed. A student who said his talent came from practice showed growth.
Evidence for Dweck’s Theory
- Longitudinal Study: A study followed seventh graders for two years. Those who believed intelligence can grow tended to improve their grades. Those who believed it is fixed did not (Blackwell et al., 2007).
- National Experiment: A short online growth mindset course improved the grades of lower-achieving students in a large US sample. It worked mainly in schools where peers backed the message (Yeager et al., 2019).
Strengths of Dweck’s Theory
- Mindsets Can Change: This can be used to improve performance at school, in sport and at work.
- Evidence: The studies above suggest that a growth mindset can be linked to better performance. Dweck’s research found that teaching it in school raised motivation and grades.
- Praise: The type of praise teachers give can affect mindset. Teachers can use this.
Limitations of Dweck’s Theory
- Blame: Too much emphasis on “having the correct mindset” may blame children for doing badly. The real cause may be a lack of resources or poor teaching.
- Weak Link: A review of 273 studies found that the link between mindset and achievement is weak (Sisk et al., 2018).
- Small Effect: A review of 63 studies found a small effect of mindset courses. In the best-designed studies it was small enough to be down to chance (Macnamara & Burgoyne, 2023).
- Not Independent: Dweck helped to write the national experiment, so it is not independent of the theory (Yeager et al., 2019).
Do not write that “praise is damaging” is a weakness. Dweck wrote that some kinds of praise can damage. So this point supports her theory and earns no mark.
The Role of Praise in Learning
Praise, in the context of learning, means approval for the effort put into a piece of work, or admiration for its standard. The definition must refer to learning. An example alone does not earn the mark.
Examiners found that under a fifth of students gained both marks. Writing “praise for their learning” was not enough. “For their piece of work” was.
In a past exam, 37 of 50 teachers said they were more likely to praise effort. So 13/50 were more likely to praise performance.
Person Praise and Process Praise
Person praise praises the person: “You are good at this.” It leads students to blame success or failure on something beyond their control.
Process praise praises what the person did: “That was a good way to answer that question.” It teaches that success or failure depends on the amount of effort.
Teachers can use praise to improve learning. The credited examples were emailing home about a good piece of work, saying “well done” for good effort and giving a merit for an answer.
Mueller and Dweck (1998) compared praise for intelligence with praise for effort. After failure, children praised for intelligence persisted less, enjoyed the task less and did worse than children praised for effort.
The Role of Self-Efficacy Beliefs in Learning
Self-efficacy is a belief in your own capabilities, or in your own ability to succeed at a task. “A belief in yourself” earns one of two marks. “Your own understanding of your abilities” earned nothing.
Over 40 per cent of students gained no marks on this definition in a past exam. Self-efficacy is not the same as self-esteem. It is about a particular task. A pupil may believe they can do football but not algebra.
A pupil with high self-efficacy believes they can do the task and keeps trying. A pupil with low self-efficacy believes they cannot and may give up.
How Teachers Can Raise Self-Efficacy
In a past exam, the credited ideas were:
- Set easier questions that the pupil can complete.
- Break a task into steps and help with one step at a time.
- Point out that other students get stuck and then overcome problems.
- Praise the pupil when she completes tasks, and explain how this raises self-efficacy.
Bandura (1977) named four sources of self-efficacy: success at a task, seeing others succeed, being told you can do it, and your body’s state.
Evidence and Limitations
A review of 59 studies of university students found that self-efficacy was moderately linked to performance (Honicke & Broadbent, 2016).
Limitation: The studies mostly measured two things and compared them. So they could not show which causes which. Read more about self-efficacy.
Learning Styles: Verbalisers and Visualisers
Learning styles are different preferred ways of taking in and working with information. The specification names two.
- Verbalisers: They prefer words. A verbaliser might revise by listening to a podcast.
- Visualisers: They prefer pictures. A visualiser might revise by looking at a diagram or chart. Matt, who looked at a drawing of how castles were designed, was using this style.
Do not mix up mindsets and styles. A past exam offered “fixed” and “growth” as wrong options for Matt.
The central claim is that teaching someone in their preferred style improves learning. This is called the matching idea.
Evidence on Matching
A proper test needs learners sorted by style and then randomly given different teaching methods. A major review found little adequate support for matching (Pashler et al., 2008).
Many teachers still believe in learning styles. In one survey, most of 114 UK university teachers believed in them (Newton & Miah, 2017).
Willingham’s Learning Theory and His Criticism of Learning Styles
Willingham is a cognitive scientist who criticised the learning styles approach. In the exam you get marks for four points.
- No Improvement: Willingham says the learning styles approach does not improve learning.
- Teach by Content: Students should be taught with the best method for the content, not their preferred style. Maps and diagrams suit visual material. Speaking and listening suit learning a language.
- No Evidence: He states there is no evidence that the approach improves exam results.
- Ability Versus Style: He says ability is what you can do and style is how you do it. He agrees people differ in ability. He does not see this as evidence for learning styles.
A past multiple-choice question asked for a feature of his ideas. The answer was that learning is most effective when the teaching method matches the content.
Evidence
- Supporting: Cognitive scientists, including Willingham, argue there is no evidence for matching teaching to styles (Clinton-Lisell & Litzinger, 2024).
- Mixed: A review of 21 experiments found a small average benefit from matching (Clinton-Lisell & Litzinger, 2024).
Strengths of Willingham’s Criticism
- Evidence-Based: It rests on the lack of evidence that matching works.
- Practical: Teachers can choose the best method for each topic. That is simpler than sorting pupils into styles.
Limitations of Willingham’s Criticism
- Not Fully Settled: The review judged the small benefit too small and too rare to justify wide use. Many experiments were low quality (Clinton-Lisell & Litzinger, 2024).
Research Methods in Development Questions
Paper 1 tests research methods inside every topic. Development questions use children, so they ask about variables, designs and ethics.
Variables
- Variables: The independent variable is what the researcher changes or compares. The dependent variable is what they measure. See variables.
- Independent Variable: Name both conditions, such as fixed mindset and growth mindset. Never write “Group 1” and “Group 2”.
- Dependent Variable: Name what is measured, such as grades in end-of-year exams. “Mindset” or “performance” alone earns nothing.
Designing Experiments and Observations
Follow the bullet points in the question one by one. You get marks only for the bullets stated.
- Learning Styles Experiment (6 Marks): One mark each went for a verbaliser task (a podcast) and a visualiser task (a diagram). Others went for a standardised procedure with its justification, and an ethical consideration.
- Praise Experiment (6 Marks): Marks went for an independent groups design (different people in each condition), a field experiment (an everyday setting), an ethical issue with a way to deal with it, and results.
- Praise Experiment Results: Give the expected results for both conditions. The dependent variable was the driving test, not confidence.
- Observing Babies (6 Marks): Choose two categories, which are separate behaviours observers agree to record, such as thumb sucking. “Shaking a rattle” and “the child is happy” earned nothing.
- Interobserver Reliability: This means different observers’ records match. Give enough detail for the second mark: use one record sheet, watch the same thing at the same time, then compare.
Ethics With Children
AQA asks for an ethical issue and a way of dealing with it. With young children, the credited ways include:
- Consent: Ask parents to sign a consent form. See informed consent.
- Protection From Harm: Be ready to stop if the child is distressed.
- Confidentiality: Do not name children in the report. Use a number or letter.
- Debrief: Afterwards, explain what the child took part in, why, and how the results will be used.
Keep the way matched to the issue. A way that does not fit the issue earns nothing.
How the Exam Asks About Development
Development is worth 25 marks. AO1 is knowledge, AO2 is applying it and AO3 is evaluation. The split changes each year.
Command Words
- What is meant by: Give a short, accurate meaning. Do not repeat the term.
- Briefly outline: Give the main points with some detail. One short sentence per stage is not enough for 4 marks.
- Describe a study: Give the aim, method, results and conclusion. Some students write A, M, R and C in the margin to remember them.
- Explain or use Piaget: Name the right stage or idea. Add detail beyond the question. Link it to the scenario.
- Evaluate: Give strengths and limitations with reasons. Do not describe.
- Describe and evaluate: Give both. A long description with one line of evaluation cannot reach the top level.
- Design an experiment: Follow the bullet points.
- Discuss: Weigh both sides, as in whether Penfield’s method suits studying the young brain.
What Examiners Look For
- Answer the Question Set: Many students described all four stages, or all of Dweck’s theory, when asked to evaluate.
- Use the Stem: In a Piaget scenario, do not describe all four stages. Use the concrete and abstract detail given, such as Hassan counting on his fingers.
- Mindsets Before Praise: In a Dweck answer, explain the two mindsets first. Do not focus too much on praise.
- Stay on Topic: For early brain development, many students wrote about smoking in pregnancy or about Piaget. This earned no credit.
- Describe All of a Study: Many students gave the method in detail but no results or conclusion.
- Link Evaluation to the Study: General points about all studies are Basic. Naming “policeman dolls” is not a point.
- Go Beyond the Stem: Restating a scenario earns nothing.
- Use the Right Words: “Open” and “closed” mindsets are wrong. Say “growth” and “fixed”.
The Penfield 9-Mark Question
One 9-mark question asked students to outline early brain development and to discuss Penfield’s method. His Montreal procedure used electricity to stimulate the cortex gently, while patients described what they felt.
It was done during open brain surgery for epilepsy. That would be very hard to carry out on an unborn baby.
Other credited points were:
- An unborn baby cannot consent, and a young child would not understand what was happening.
- The cortex is still developing, so the method would not suit a young child.
- The method is invasive. Brain scans such as fMRI are more suitable and more ethical.
- Young children struggle to put experiences into words, and they have fewer memories than adults to draw on.
Discuss both before birth and the early years. Covering only one stays at the lowest level. See the Penfield study.
Marking Notes for the Studies and Theories
- Brain Questions: In the 9-mark question, naming brain parts alone stays at the lowest level. In the 6-mark nature and nurture question, use both doctors’ comments and go beyond them.
- Study Questions: Naughty teddy, 6 and 9 marks: in the 9-mark question, evaluate the research method. Policeman doll: 4 marks describe, 5 marks evaluate, 6 marks both.
- Theory Questions: Dweck, 9 marks: describe the theory, apply it to the scenario and evaluate it. Many students did not expect all three in one question.
Practice Question 1: Describe and Evaluate the Naughty Teddy Study (9 Marks)
These model answers are examples, not the exam board’s own wording.
The exam has set this question. It was worth 9 marks. Four were for description and five for evaluation of the research method.
Model answer: McGarrigle and Donaldson wanted to see whether young children can conserve when the change is accidental. Eighty children aged four to six saw two identical rows of counters. They said the rows had the same number.
A naughty teddy then accidentally moved one row so it was more spread out. The children were asked again. Over 60 per cent gave the correct answer. Older children did better than younger ones.
The researchers concluded that children under seven can conserve and that the ability increases with age.
The study was a laboratory experiment. This gives high control, so extraneous variables are removed and we can be surer the change caused the result. The procedure was standardised, so it can be repeated.
But the task was artificial. Counters, a teddy and an unfamiliar adult are not like real life. High control may make behaviour less natural, so the findings are hard to apply to normal settings.
- Marking Note: Describe the aim, method, results and conclusion. Then evaluate the research method, which is the laboratory experiment, not the sample.
Practice Question 2: Describe, Apply and Evaluate Dweck’s Theory (9 Marks)
Imagine two students. Priya says, “I will never be good at science. It’s just not me.” Sam says, “I got that wrong, so I will practise those questions.”
Describe and evaluate Dweck’s mindset theory. Refer to both students. [9 marks]
Model answer: Dweck described two mindsets.
A fixed mindset is the belief that ability is fixed by genes or talent. People give up. They see failure as a lack of talent. A growth mindset is the belief that ability comes from hard work. People keep trying and see failure as a chance to grow.
Priya has a fixed mindset. She thinks she cannot change how good she is at science. Sam has a growth mindset. He uses his mistake to practise more.
One strength is that mindsets can change, so teachers can use the theory to improve performance. There is also evidence that teaching a growth mindset can raise grades. The type of praise teachers give can affect mindset.
One limitation is that too much emphasis on mindset may blame children for doing badly when the cause is poor teaching or a lack of resources. A large review also found only a small effect of mindset courses.
- Marking Note: Marks go for the description, for applying it to both students, and for evaluation. Use “fixed” and “growth”.
Practice Question 3: Piaget Applied to a Scenario (6 Marks)
Imagine Tariq is 5. He sees two equal rows of sweets. One row is spread out. He says it has more.
His sister Aisha is 14. She can work out what would happen if a new rule changed a game, without playing it. Use Piaget’s stage theory to explain the difference. [6 marks]
Model answer: Tariq is in the pre-operational stage, from about two to seven. Children in this stage cannot conserve. They do not understand that the number stays the same when the appearance changes. Tariq thinks the longer row has more.
Aisha is in the formal operational stage, from about eleven. Children here can think about abstract and hypothetical ideas. She can reason about what might happen without seeing it.
So Piaget would say they differ because they are at different stages. Thinking changes in kind as children grow, always in the same order.
- Marking Note: This is marked in levels. Name each stage, give detail beyond the question, and link it to the person.
Practice Question 4: Outline Early Brain Development (4 Marks)
Imagine this question. Outline early brain development. [4 marks]
Model answer: The brain starts to develop in the third week of pregnancy. It begins as a neural tube, which divides into a spinal cord, forebrain, midbrain and hindbrain. The forebrain forms the cortex and the thalamus. The cerebellum and brain stem form from the hindbrain and midbrain.
At birth, the brain is about a quarter of adult size. It doubles in the first year. Brain function keeps developing for many years.
- Marking Note: Only naming brain parts stays in the lowest level. Describe how the brain develops.
References
Adey, P., & Shayer, M. (1990). Accelerating the development of formal thinking in middle and high school students. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 27(3), 267–285. https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.3660270309
Baillargeon, R., & DeVos, J. (1991). Object permanence in young infants: Further evidence. Child Development, 62(6), 1227–1246. https://doi.org/10.2307/1130803
Bandura, A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review, 84(2), 191–215. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.84.2.191
Blackwell, L. S., Trzesniewski, K. H., & Dweck, C. S. (2007). Implicit theories of intelligence predict achievement across an adolescent transition: A longitudinal study and an intervention. Child Development, 78(1), 246–263. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8624.2007.00995.x
Central Advisory Council for Education (England). (1967). Children and their primary schools (The Plowden Report). Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.
Clinton-Lisell, V., & Litzinger, C. (2024). Is it really a neuromyth? A meta-analysis of the learning styles matching hypothesis. Frontiers in Psychology, 15, Article 1428732. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1428732
Dasen, P. R. (1994). Culture and cognitive development from a Piagetian perspective. In W. J. Lonner & R. S. Malpass (Eds.), Psychology and culture (pp. 145–149). Allyn & Bacon.
Honicke, T., & Broadbent, J. (2016). The influence of academic self-efficacy on academic performance: A systematic review. Educational Research Review, 17, 63–84. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2015.11.002
Hughes, M., & Donaldson, M. (1979). The use of hiding games for studying the coordination of viewpoints. Educational Review, 31(2), 133–140. https://doi.org/10.1080/0013191790310207
Light, P. H., Buckingham, N., & Robbins, A. H. (1979). The conservation task as an interactional setting. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 49(3), 304–310. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8279.1979.tb02430.x
Lourenço, O., & Machado, A. (1996). In defense of Piaget’s theory: A reply to 10 common criticisms. Psychological Review, 103(1), 143–164.
Macnamara, B. N., & Burgoyne, A. P. (2023). Do growth mindset interventions impact students’ academic achievement? A systematic review and meta-analysis with recommendations for best practices. Psychological Bulletin, 149(3–4), 133–173. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000352
McGarrigle, J., & Donaldson, M. (1974). Conservation accidents. Cognition, 3(4), 341–350. https://doi.org/10.1016/0010-0277(74)90003-1
Mueller, C. M., & Dweck, C. S. (1998). Praise for intelligence can undermine children’s motivation and performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75(1), 33–52. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.75.1.33
Newton, P. M., & Miah, M. (2017). Evidence-based higher education — Is the learning styles “myth” important? Frontiers in Psychology, 8, 444. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00444
Pashler, H., McDaniel, M., Rohrer, D., & Bjork, R. (2008). Learning styles: Concepts and evidence. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 9(3), 105–119. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1539-6053.2009.01038.x
Piaget, J. (1952). The origins of intelligence in children (M. Cook, Trans.). International Universities Press. https://doi.org/10.1037/11494-000
Piaget, J., & Inhelder, B. (1956). The child’s conception of space. Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Piaget, J., & Szeminska, A. (1952). The child’s conception of number. Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Rakic, P. (1977). Prenatal development of the visual system in rhesus monkey. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. B, Biological Sciences, 278(961), 245–260. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.1977.0040
Rose, S. A., & Blank, M. (1974). The potency of context in children’s cognition: An illustration through conservation. Child Development, 45(2), 499–502. https://doi.org/10.2307/1127977
Samuel, J., & Bryant, P. (1984). Asking only one question in the conservation experiment. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 25(2), 315–318. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7610.1984.tb00152.x
Shayer, M., Küchemann, D. E., & Wylam, H. (1976). The distribution of Piagetian stages of thinking in British middle and secondary school children. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 46(2), 164–173. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8279.1976.tb02308.x
Sisk, V. F., Burgoyne, A. P., Sun, J., Butler, J. L., & Macnamara, B. N. (2018). To what extent and under which circumstances are growth mind-sets important to academic achievement? Two meta-analyses. Psychological Science, 29(4), 549–571. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797617739704
Stiles, J., & Jernigan, T. L. (2010). The basics of brain development. Neuropsychology Review, 20(4), 327–348. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11065-010-9148-4
Thapar, A., Rice, F., Hay, D., Boivin, J., Langley, K., van den Bree, M., Rutter, M., & Harold, G. (2009). Prenatal smoking might not cause attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder: Evidence from a novel design. Biological Psychiatry, 66(8), 722–727. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsych.2009.05.032
Yeager, D. S., Hanselman, P., Walton, G. M., Murray, J. S., Crosnoe, R., Muller, C., Tipton, E., Schneider, B., Hulleman, C. S., Hinojosa, C. P., Paunesku, D., Romero, C., Flint, K., Roberts, A., Trott, J., Iachan, R., Buontempo, J., Yang, S. M., Carvalho, C. M., … Dweck, C. S. (2019). A national experiment reveals where a growth mindset improves achievement. Nature, 573(7774), 364–369. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-019-1466-y