The Clive Wearing study (2008) is a case study, a detailed study of one person. A brain infection in 1985 left this musician with severe amnesia (memory loss). For 21 years he could form almost no new memories, and for many years he said he had just woken up. OCR uses it with the Multi-store Model of memory.
Key Takeaways
Aim
- To report the case of Clive Wearing, called CW in the paper, a musician left with severe amnesia, and to ask why he said he had just woken up.
Method
- This was a case study: a detailed study of one person. It lasted 21 years, so it was longitudinal (the same person studied over a long time).
- Clive Wearing was a professional musician. In 1985, aged 46, a brain infection called herpes simplex encephalitis left him severely amnesic.
- The data were brain scans (MRI), memory and IQ tests, his diary, video of him, and what he said.
- The data were quantitative (test scores) and qualitative (his own words). It was not an experiment, so there is no independent or dependent variable.
Results
- The scans showed severe damage to the hippocampus (a brain area that helps form new memories) and parts of the temporal lobes (areas at the sides of the brain). There was very little change between 1991 and 2006.
- His immediate memory (remembering for a few seconds) was normal. His delayed recall (remembering after a gap) was always zero. He could not form new memories (anterograde amnesia).
- He had lost most of his episodic memories, which are memories of events, from the 45 years before the illness (retrograde amnesia).
- He said he had just become conscious for the first time, and that he was not conscious when he wrote his diary.
Conclusion
- The authors suggested three explanations for his belief: a delusion (a false belief held very firmly), impaired consciousness or a coping strategy (a way of dealing with a difficulty).
- A delusion alone was no longer enough, and the authors left the other two open. His sense of self, the feeling of being the same person over time, was disrupted.
Strengths
- Depth and detail: the study gathered a lot of information about one man over 21 years.
- Rare condition: a case study lets researchers record a rare and severe case of both anterograde and retrograde amnesia.
- Several kinds of evidence: scans, tests, interviews and his diary agree, which supports reliability (consistent results) and validity (measuring what is claimed).
Limitations
- Generalisability (how far findings apply to other people): CW was a unique individual with a highly unusual condition, so the findings may not apply to others.
- Objectivity (facts that do not rest on one person’s opinion): some information came from his wife’s published account.
- Untestable explanation: one case cannot show which of the three explanations is right.
Ethical Issues
- Informed consent: a man with severe amnesia cannot remember what he agreed to. A way of dealing with it: a carer or family member agrees for him.
- Protection from psychological harm: he became angry when his belief was challenged. A way of dealing with it: stop if he is distressed.
- Confidentiality: the paper gives enough detail to identify him. A way of dealing with it: use initials and leave out identifying details.
- The paper says nothing about how the researchers handled these issues.
Exam Use
- In the exam you get marks for a strength and a weakness of the case study method, each linked to the study. Learn 21 years, MRI scans and one unique man.
- In the exam you get marks for matching anterograde and retrograde amnesia to the findings.
- In the exam, the study is used as support for the Multi-store Model, a model of memory with separate stores: normal immediate memory, but information was not reaching long-term memory.
- The long answer worth 13 marks asks you to pair it with a study from a different topic.
Background
Amnesia means severe memory loss. There are two kinds. In anterograde amnesia a person cannot form new memories after the damage. In retrograde amnesia a person cannot recall memories from before the damage.
In OCR’s Memory topic, the hippocampus is vital. It forms new memories. OCR links damage to it with anterograde amnesia, because information cannot pass from short-term memory into long-term memory.
OCR also teaches the Multi-store Model. It says memory has three stores: the sensory store, short-term memory and long-term memory. Information passes through them in order. OCR uses the Clive Wearing study as support for this model.
Aim
The study aimed to report the case of CW, a musician who became severely amnesic in 1985. The authors also wanted to ask why he kept saying that he had only just woken up.
For years he said this several times a day. He wrote it in his diary. He said he had just become conscious for the first time. The authors wanted to know what this belief meant.
There was no prediction to test. A case study is a detailed study of one person. It describes what was found and tries to explain it, so there is no hypothesis to learn.
Method
Design and Variables
Wilson, Kopelman and Kapur (2008) wrote a case study of one man. It was longitudinal, which means CW was assessed on many occasions over 21 years.
The study used both kinds of data. The quantitative data were numbers, such as test scores and scan findings. The qualitative data were descriptions in words, such as his statements, his diary and his wife’s account.
This was not an experiment. The researchers did not change a variable. So there is no independent variable and no dependent variable to name. There was no control group for the memory findings. The only comparison was a scan of a healthy person of the same age.
Sample
The sample was one person, CW. He was a man born in 1938 and a professional musician.
In March 1985, aged 46, he had an illness like flu, with a headache and a fever. A few days later he was admitted to hospital. Doctors found he had herpes simplex encephalitis, a brain infection caused by a virus.
He was treated with a drug called acyclovir, which probably saved his life. But the virus had destroyed large sections of his brain.
Materials
The researchers used these.
- MRI scans of his brain, taken in July 1991 and January 2006.
- Neuropsychological tests, which are tests of thinking and memory, including IQ tests, memory tests and naming tests.
- His diary, and video of him playing the piano and conducting his choir.
- His statements, made in conversation over the years.
- His wife’s published account, for how the illness began and how he changed.
Procedure
- In 1985 CW became ill, went to hospital and was diagnosed with the brain infection. In October 1985 he was referred to one of the study’s authors.
- In November 1985 his memory and thinking were first assessed.
- In July 1991 he had his first MRI scan. Three raters, working separately, looked at it, and they agreed.
- Over 21 years he was assessed many times. His delayed recall was always zero. The researchers also recorded what he said and wrote.
- They showed him his diary and video of himself, and noted how he reacted.
- In January 2006 he had a second MRI scan, using a stronger machine.
Results
The Brain Scans
The 1991 scan showed marked damage to the hippocampus on both sides and to parts of the temporal lobes, the areas at the sides of the brain.
The 2006 scan showed very severe loss of tissue in the temporal lobes. There was very little change from 1991.
Memory
His immediate memory was normal. For example, he could repeat back seven digits straight after hearing them. But his delayed recall was always zero. Delayed recall means remembering something after a wait.
This was anterograde amnesia. He could not form new memories. His memory for events in his own life was extremely poor, and some memory for facts and meanings (semantic memory) was also damaged.
He also had retrograde amnesia. He had lost most of his episodic memories, which are memories of events, from the 45 years before the illness. He still knew who he was, that he was a musician and that he had married his wife.
His IQ was in the average range. The authors say this was a decline. They estimated his IQ before the illness from his achievements, and thought it was much higher.
The Belief That He Had Just Woken Up
For many years he said he had only just become conscious. In the early years he said this many times a day, and said it was like being dead.
Shown his diary, he agreed it was his handwriting. But he said he was not conscious when he wrote it. Shown video of himself, he recognised himself, but said he was not conscious then.
If anyone challenged him, he became angry. To him it felt like waking from a total blank.
What He Could Still Do
His memory was not wiped out entirely. He could find his way to parts of the home such as the kitchen. He could still sight-read music.
He also showed some learning that he did not know about. In recent years he began to learn some new facts, such as how to use a mobile phone.
Conclusion
The authors suggested three explanations for his belief that he had just woken up.
- A delusion: a false belief held very firmly. The authors said this was not enough on its own, because he had no other delusions, such as thinking people were plotting against him.
- Impaired consciousness: his damaged brain meant he could not link his present to his past, so he lost the sense of a self built from his personal history.
- A coping strategy: with almost no memory to explain his diary entries, he coped by denying that he had been awake before.
To see the second explanation, think of the diary. He agreed the handwriting was his. But he could not link the man who wrote it to the man he felt he was now.
The authors said a delusion on its own is no longer enough to explain his belief. They left the other two explanations open. They said his sense of self had almost certainly been disrupted by his memory disorder.
OCR uses the study for the Multi-store Model. CW’s immediate memory was normal. But his delayed recall was always zero, so information was not moving into long-term memory. That fits a model with separate short-term and long-term stores.
Strengths
- In-depth, detailed data: A case study gathers a lot of information about one person. This study used scans, tests, his words and his diary.
- A rare condition: A case study lets researchers record a rare condition. CW had a severe and rare case of both anterograde and retrograde amnesia.
- Longitudinal data: The same man was studied for 21 years, with MRI scans taken years apart and both kinds of data.
- Several kinds of evidence: Scans, tests, interviews, his diary and video all point the same way. This supports reliability and validity.
- Something that cannot be set up: Nobody could ethically damage a person’s brain to test memory. A case study can study the effects of damage that happened anyway.
- Real-life behaviour: His statements and his reactions to video happened in everyday life. This supports ecological validity, which means being true to real life.
Strengths Must Link to the Study
In the exam, a strength of the case study method earns one mark. A second mark needs a detail from the Clive Wearing study.
A definition of a case study earns nothing. Writing only that longitudinal research is good also earns nothing. Say what was studied: 21 years, two MRI scans, one man with severe amnesia.
Limitations
- Generalisability: CW was a unique individual with a highly unusual condition. The findings may not apply to other people with amnesia.
- Objectivity: Some information came from his wife’s published account, and the researchers could not hold a full conversation with him.
- An untestable explanation: The three explanations all fit the data. One case cannot show which is right.
- No baseline: A baseline is a measurement from before a change. His ability before the illness was estimated, not measured, so how much he lost is an estimate.
- Damage beyond one area: The scans showed damage to several brain areas, not only the hippocampus. So his problems cannot be blamed on one area.
- Possible bias: The clinicians who treated him over many years may have also written up and interpreted the case.
Objectivity
Objective information is fact that does not depend on one person’s opinion. Some details, such as how the illness began, came from his wife’s published account and not from tests.
The researchers also could not have a deep conversation with CW, because of his amnesia and his belief that he had just woken. So his own explanation is missing.
Damage Beyond One Area
OCR links the hippocampus to anterograde amnesia. But the scans showed damage to the hippocampus, the amygdalas (small areas deep in the brain) and the temporal lobes. He also did badly on some tests of thinking skills, and he had seizures.
So the study cannot show that damage to one structure caused one problem. It fits OCR’s link, but it cannot prove it.
Ethical Issues
The paper says nothing about consent, ethical review or confidentiality. The points below show how OCR’s list applies. They are not claims about what the researchers did.
- Lack of informed consent: CW could not remember what he had agreed to a few minutes earlier, so he could not give informed consent in the usual way.
- Protection from psychological harm: He became angry when his belief was challenged. Showing him his diary and video may have upset him.
- Confidentiality: The paper calls him CW, but it gives enough detail about him to identify him.
Each issue has a way of dealing with it.
- Consent: A carer or family member can agree for him. The paper does not say who agreed.
- Harm: Stop if he is upset, and keep the questions gentle.
- Confidentiality: Use initials and leave out details that identify him.
A patient who cannot remember the study cannot be debriefed in the usual way. Debriefing means explaining the study afterwards. For the same reason, he cannot use the right to withdraw in the usual way.
Nothing in the study suggests deception. Deception means misleading participants.
Exam Questions
How the Exam Asks About This Study
The exam asks about the Clive Wearing study in these ways.
- Strength of the case study method as used here (2 marks): one mark for the strength, such as depth, a rare condition or longitudinal data, and one for a detail from the study.
- Weakness of the case study method as used here (2 marks): lack of generalisability, because CW is a unique and highly unusual individual.
- Match types of amnesia to findings (2 marks): one mark for each correct pair.
- 13-mark essay: in 2023 this was the study students chose most often as the second study, from a different area, in a question about generalisability.
Other memory questions ask about the brain without naming the study. The hippocampus is linked to anterograde amnesia. OCR also teaches the frontal lobe (at the front of the brain) for retrograde amnesia. It teaches the cerebellum for procedural memory, which is memory for skills.
The examples below are practice questions written in the style of the exam. They are not the exam board’s own wording.
Practice Question 1: A Strength (2 marks)
Question: Explain one strength of the case study method as used in the Clive Wearing study. [2 marks]
Model answer: A case study gives in-depth and detailed data. In the Clive Wearing study, CW was assessed over 21 years, with scans, tests and his own words.
- Mark scheme: 1 mark for a strength, such as depth, a rare condition or longitudinal data. 1 mark for a detail from the study.
- Not credited: a definition of a case study.
Practice Question 2: A Weakness (2 marks)
Question: Explain one weakness of the case study method as used in the Clive Wearing study. [2 marks]
Model answer: One weakness is lack of generalisability. CW was a unique individual with a highly unusual condition, so the findings may not apply to other people with amnesia.
- Mark scheme: 1 mark for the weakness. 1 mark for applying it to CW.
Practice Question 3: Types of Amnesia (2 marks)
Question: Give one finding for each type of amnesia. [2 marks]
Model answer: For anterograde amnesia, his delayed recall was always zero, so he could not form new memories.
For retrograde amnesia, he had lost most of his episodic memories (memories of events) from the 45 years before the illness.
- Mark scheme: 1 mark for a finding that matches anterograde amnesia. 1 mark for a finding that matches retrograde amnesia. No mark if both findings belong to one type.
Practice Question 4: Support for the Multi-store Model (3 marks)
Question: Explain how the Clive Wearing study supports the Multi-store Model. [3 marks]
Model answer: The model says information passes from short-term memory to long-term memory. CW’s immediate memory was normal, because he could repeat back seven digits. But his delayed recall was always zero. So information was not reaching long-term memory.
- Mark scheme: 1 mark for what the model says. 1 mark for a finding about normal immediate memory. 1 mark for zero delayed recall and so no new long-term memories.
- Also credited in a theory question: OCR’s named criticism of the model is rehearsal against meaning. Meaningful information, such as news of a bereavement, does not need rehearsing to be remembered.
The 13-Mark Question
The 13-mark question is the long answer worth 13 marks: 6 for describing and 7 for evaluating, and it ends with a judgement. You need the named study or theory and at least one study from a different area.
The Clive Wearing study is in the Memory topic. So do not pair it with another Memory study. A study from another topic, such as a Social Influence study, works well for generalisability.
When a question asks for a theory, a description of a study earns no credit. Read whether the question asks for a study or a theory.
Later Research
Servais et al. (2026) described three new patients who also said they had just woken up. All three had a brain illness with swelling that damaged the hippocampus on both sides and caused severe anterograde amnesia. The authors named the condition Stream of Consciousness Impairment.
This suggests CW’s belief is not just a quirk of one man. The finding comes from the abstract.
Annese et al. (2023) described a young man, A.V., with similar damage after the same brain infection. His intelligence was preserved, but his memory was very badly damaged. He used his phone to do jobs his memory could no longer do. This also comes from the abstract.
Both are single cases or very small groups. So, like the 2008 study, they are limited in how far they can be generalised.
References
Annese, J., Klaming, R., Haase Alasantro, L., & Feinstein, J. S. (2023). A case of severe anterograde amnesia in the era of smartphone technology. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 45(5), 498-512. https://doi.org/10.1080/13803395.2023.2254911
Servais, A., Gérard, F., Mirabel, H., Rafiq, M., Wolfrum, M., Bost, C., Bonneville, F., Pariente, J., & Barbeau, E. J. (2026). Subjective experience of ‘Stream of Consciousness Impairment’ in three patients with severe amnesia. Neuroscience of Consciousness, 2026(1), niag049. https://doi.org/10.1093/nc/niag049
Wilson, B. A., Kopelman, M., & Kapur, N. (2008). Prominent and persistent loss of past awareness in amnesia: Delusion, impaired consciousness or coping strategy? Neuropsychological Rehabilitation, 18(5-6), 527-540. https://doi.org/10.1080/09602010802141889